FAQs
Better civic decisions, made with citizens
Better civic decisions, made with citizens
What is public deliberation?
Public deliberation is a process in which people examine a public issue together before arriving at considered judgements or recommendations. Participants draw on evidence, lived experience and different perspectives. They ask questions, discuss possible solutions and weigh their consequences.
It goes beyond expressing an initial opinion: people have time and support to reflect, understand each other’s concerns and consider what would serve the wider community.
How does deliberation differ from a debate, survey, or public hearing?
A debate usually involves defending a position and challenging opposing arguments. A survey records people’s views at a particular time. A public hearing gives people an opportunity to present concerns or comments to an authority.
Deliberation creates space for people to learn and think together. Participants can question evidence, explore alternatives and revise their views. These approaches can complement one another: for example, surveys and hearings can bring broader public concerns into a deliberative process.
What is a citizens’ assembly?
A citizens’ assembly brings together a group of people selected through a civic lottery to reflect the diversity of a wider population. Members learn about a clearly defined public issue, hear different perspectives and deliberate with the support of trained facilitators.
The assembly develops recommendations for the government body or institution responsible for the issue. Its credibility depends on inclusive recruitment, balanced information, fair discussion and a clear commitment to respond to its recommendations.
Is every public dialogue or Samvad a citizens’ assembly?
No. Public deliberation can take several forms, including facilitated community dialogues, citizens’ juries and citizens’ assemblies.
A citizens’ assembly has specific features, particularly selection through a civic lottery, attention to representation, sufficient time for learning and deliberation, and a clear connection to a public decision. “Samvad” can describe a broader dialogue; the process should explain which approach it uses.
Why involve ordinary people in complex public decisions?
People have knowledge of everyday conditions that technical reports may miss. They experience how transport, waste management, public spaces and other services work in practice.
When people receive accessible information and sufficient time to discuss it, they can examine complex choices and contribute practical recommendations. Their experience complements the expertise of officials, researchers and other specialists.
Which issues are suitable for public deliberation?
Deliberation is especially useful when an issue affects different groups, involves competing needs or limited resources, or requires sustained public cooperation.
Possible topics include mobility, safer streets, waste management, climate action, public spaces, ward priorities and budgets. A useful question allows participants to examine meaningful choices and connects their recommendations to an authority that can act on them.
Does a citizens’ assembly replace elected representatives or existing participation processes?
No. It strengthens decision-making by adding informed public judgement. Elected representatives and public authorities retain their responsibilities.
An assembly can complement ward committees, public consultations, surveys and other participation processes. It does not remove the need to follow statutory procedures or fulfil legal obligations.
What is a civic lottery, or sortition?
A civic lottery is a method of selecting participants randomly rather than choosing only those who volunteer for public meetings or are nominated by organisations.
Typically, invitations go to a randomly selected set of people or households. Among those who agree to participate, a further selection creates a group that broadly reflects the population—for example, by age, gender, location and socio-economic background. The method and selection criteria should be explained publicly.
How can a small group reflect a much larger population?
Careful selection brings together people with different backgrounds and experiences, including those who are often absent from public meetings.
The aim is to create a broadly representative cross-section that can examine the issue in depth. An assembly is not an opinion poll, and its recommendations should not be presented as a statistical measure of what everyone thinks. Wider public submissions and consultations can add perspectives beyond those of assembly members.
How do you include people who face barriers to participation?
Inclusion requires support throughout the process. Depending on local needs, this may include invitations in local languages, outreach beyond digital platforms, accessible venues, transport support, compensation for time, childcare and suitable meeting times.
Learning materials and facilitation should also accommodate differences in literacy, language, disability and confidence. These arrangements help people participate meaningfully after selection.
Do participants need technical knowledge, formal education or digital skills?
No prior expertise should be required. Participants bring their experience and willingness to engage.
Information can be shared through local-language discussions, illustrations, demonstrations, maps, site visits and conversations with resource persons. People should have opportunities to ask questions and seek clarification. Design processes for those who do not use smartphones or read lengthy documents.
How is information made balanced and trustworthy?
The process should bring together relevant evidence, acknowledge uncertainties and present credible perspectives on the available choices. Participants should hear from people with different expertise and experience, including those affected by the issue.
Briefing materials should be reviewed for accuracy and fairness. Resource persons should disclose relevant interests, and participants should be able to question claims and request further information. Balance does not mean treating unsupported claims as equal to reliable evidence.
What do facilitators do?
Facilitators help participants listen, ask questions, examine choices and develop recommendations. They encourage quieter members to contribute and help prevent a few people from dominating the discussion.
They support a fair process without steering participants towards a preferred answer. They also help distinguish agreement, uncertainty and disagreement so that the final recommendations accurately reflect the discussion.
What is an oversight committee, and who should be on it?
An oversight committee helps protect the fairness, balance, transparency and credibility of the process.
Its membership may include officials, independent experts, stakeholders and community representatives, with attention to different perspectives and potential conflicts of interest. It can review the remit, recruitment approach, information and process arrangements. It should not direct participants’ conclusions or rewrite their recommendations.
What happens if participants disagree?
Disagreement is expected when people discuss difficult public choices. Facilitators help participants understand the reasons behind different positions and look for common ground.
Unanimity is not essential. A process can use an agreed method to establish support for recommendations and record significant alternative views. The final report should make remaining differences visible rather than imply that everyone agreed.
How is an assembly's question decided?
The question—often called the remit—should be clear, understandable and open to more than one reasonable answer. It should identify a real public decision without assuming the solution in advance.
Framing the question involves clarifying the problem, who is affected, the available choices and the authority’s scope to act. Public inputs can help identify priorities. Participants should also know which constraints are fixed and which choices remain open for discussion.
What are the main stages of a citizens’ assembly?
A typical process involves:
Defining the question and securing a commitment from the responsible authority.
Establishing oversight and gathering evidence and wider public inputs.
Preparing accessible information and selecting participants through a civic lottery.
Convening participants to learn, question resource persons and deliberate.
Developing and submitting recommendations.
Publishing the authority’s response and tracking follow-up.
Some stages overlap. Oversight, inclusion and transparency need attention throughout the process.
Can people contribute if they are not selected for the assembly?
Yes. Wider participation can include surveys, neighbourhood discussions, public submissions, interviews and meetings with affected groups.
These inputs should be summarised fairly and made available to assembly members. Publishing information about the process, recommendations and official response also helps the wider public understand and discuss the assembly’s work.
What happens to the recommendations? Are they binding?
Recommendations are generally advisory unless a specific arrangement gives them a different status. Explain their intended role before recruitment begins.
The responsible authority should commit to a public response: which recommendations it accepts, how it will take them forward, and why it cannot accept others. Recommendations may inform plans, budgets, policies or service improvements. Public reporting and follow-up help connect deliberation to action.
How much time and funding does an assembly need?
This depends on the issue, geographical area, number of participants and depth of learning required. Some focused processes may involve several sessions; more complex questions may require meetings over several weeks or months.
Budgets need to cover preparation, recruitment, participant support, accessible information, facilitation, venues, documentation and follow-up. Adequate learning and discussion time is essential. CEE Samvad can help develop a design and budget suited to the purpose and context.
What is CEE Samvad, and how can it support a deliberative process?
CEE Samvad is a Centre for Environment Education programme that promotes meaningful public participation in civic governance.
It builds capacity and works with governments, institutions, civil society organisations and communities to design and facilitate inclusive citizens’ assemblies and other public deliberation processes. It also undertakes research and nurtures a community of practice.
Support can include defining the remit, designing the process, recruitment and civic lottery, preparing learning materials, facilitation, documentation, and follow-up planning.
What examples are there of CEE’s work in public deliberation?
The Harit Setu Jan Sabha in Pimpri Chinchwad examined how to encourage cycling alongside infrastructure improvements.
The Pune Metro Jan Samvad examined ways to improve access to Metro services, public outreach, and service information, aiming to increase use.
These examples show how deliberation can bring everyday experience into discussions about infrastructure and public services. Each process should be understood through its own remit, recruitment method, recommendations and follow-up.
What is the Indian Community of Practice for Public Deliberation?
The Community of Practice brings together people interested in developing public deliberation in India, including practitioners, researchers, facilitators, civil society organisations and public officials.
It provides a space to exchange experience, discuss challenges, develop approaches suited to India’s diverse contexts and learn from practice. It also supports connections among people working to make public participation more inclusive and meaningful.
How can my organisation or I get involved?
Government bodies and institutions can approach CEE Samvad to explore a deliberative process around a public decision. Civil society organisations and community groups can collaborate on outreach, local knowledge and inclusive participation. Practitioners and researchers can contribute to learning, research and the Community of Practice.
Participation in a particular citizens’ assembly depends on its recruitment process. Expressing interest does not guarantee selection through the civic lottery.
To explore a collaboration or learn more, visit the Get Involved page or write to ceeurban@ceeindia.org.