Image Source: Google Images
Students
Based on the research using user interview method, we found out few things that a student would need. One of the major things is safety. Students want to feel they're in a safe and friendly environment. They want to participate in activities where they won't be judged if they share their opinions. The research also indicates that a lot of students nowadays are feeling anxiety over their assignments and exams and they want to find ways to help them study in a less stressful way. As an example, Aryanaz during her interview mentioned "When I don’t understand what my teachers mean by explaining some things at the class it really stresses me out. What stresses me out even more is when I can’t get any help from anyone". Another student name Jared mentioned "I want to have teachers who are passionate about what they want to convey to their students and want their students to learn, not just to regurgitate information that is given to them”.
Using the user interview method, I consulted with Gizelle Thompson, who is a 4th grade Teacher/Mentor Teacher at Somerset Academy Skyway Campus, with a general focus on what can be changed about the classroom to most benefit her. She stated that she has had previous success with structuring her classroom around small groups, but that this was mostly contingent on student behaviors and that it “would be nice to have a teachers’ assistant in every classroom to help with either doing small groups or helping with behaviors depending on what is necessary”. She also had some ideas to help both students and teachers feel more energized at school where there would be “more movement, more hands-on activities.” Although she restated that there would be that need for an extra adult to supervise because along with more movement and hands-on activities it can quickly get out of control. I then questioned what she would change about the standard classroom set up. She expressed that students should have more comfortable chairs or some sort of alternative seating and that a larger classroom to section out the classroom for different purposes would be useful. She lamented that presently her room is so small that she cannot walk between the desks easily and that she tries to combat this lack of space by sending “kids out into the hall for small group time or independent study, but sometimes other teachers have the same idea and then kids become noisy with too many distractions”.
Engaged learning environments increase students' attention and focus while promoting meaningful learning experiences and encouraging them to practice higher level thinking and performance (The Importance of an Engaged Learning Environment). One of the benefits of an engaging learning environment is that it allows students to apply their knowledge in different ways that can be applied to daily life. Having better education provides stability within a student’s life by having better career opportunities that provide financial stability. Being well educated also can prevent someone from being taken advantage of (Why Is Education Important: All The Reasons To Stay In School).
The current workforce design is a reason for teacher isolation which impedes improved instruction and student learning (Mirel, et al.). The education system and conditions contribute to burnout and demoralization among teachers. This affects their ability to do their jobs and influence their decision on leaving the profession. As a result this can create negative consequences for schools in terms of teacher quality and student achievement. Teachers care about the education environment because they are directly affected and are asking for more mental and health resources for them and students. Studies have also shown that collaborative relationships improve teacher performance (Santoro).
Parents care about the education of not only their children but others as well. The federal and state law requires the A-F system of grading in Arizona. These scores are calculated using the testing scores of students to measure their student’s educational achievements (FAQ: How Arizona’s A-F Letter Grades for Schools Work ). Parents take these scores into consideration when choosing a school for their children. Parents want their children to develop a broad set of skills and care for their wellbeing. They also want them to have more experiential learning, better use of technology, more personalized learning, and more attention to their children’s emotional and mental health (Pittman, et al.).
Society cares about the education of students because they are the future of the world. Better education for everyone can provide equal opportunities and equal chances at higher paying jobs that can decrease the gaps between social classes. Having an education is believed to make a person a useful part of society with the right kinds of values. A strong and efficient workforce of educated people provide society with services needed for everyday life. By doing so, they also help in economic growth. In addition to that, people who continue to learn and research are more likely to be innovators. Well educated people are believed to become better citizens, knowing right from wrong. They know the importance of voting for a better society (Why Is Education Important: All The Reasons To Stay In School).
School districts are affected by education delivery because they are funded by the state and when an increase of funding is available that funding usually goes to schools with better performance (Education Funding and Budget ). What schools spend their money on affects student achievement. Quality of instruction is better when teachers receive competitive salary and resources (Burckbuchler).
Ethnicity of students in Mesa Public Schools District Totals in the last 20 years.
Source: Mesa Public Schools Demographics
Ethnicity of students in Mesa Public Schools for 2020-2021 school year.
Source: Mesa Public Schools Demographics
Ethnicity of students in Mesa Public Schools District Totals for 2020-2021 school year.
Source: Mesa Public Schools Demographics
Gender distribution of students in Mesa Public Schools for 2020-2021 school year.
Source: Overview of Mesa Unified District
Ethnicity of students in Arizona schools for 2020-2021 school year.
Source: The 2020 Arizona Teacher Workforce
Ethnicity of teachers in Mesa Public Schools District Totals for 2020-2021 school year.
Source: Mesa Public Schools Statistics and Demographics
Gender distribution of teachers in Mesa Public Schools for 2020-2021 school year.
Source: Mesa Public Schools Statistics and Demographics
Ethnicity of teachers in Arizona schools for 2020-2021 school year.
Source: The 2020 Arizona Teacher Workforce
Gender distribution of teachers in Arizona schools for 2020-2021 school year.
Source: The 2020 Arizona Teacher Workforce
There are not enough qualified teachers. There are not enough highly qualified teachers because not all current teachers meet the education, experience and certification requirements. The number of students completing teacher preparation programs has fallen (García, et al.). Teachers leave the profession because they are not achieving career or life goals, are feeling burnout and/or want to increase earning potential. Teachers have been underpaid compared to similarly educated workers in other professions. Some of the competing careers of teachers are professions that require some of the skills teachers possess so it is easier for them to make the change. Some of these careers include principals, school counselors, human resources managers, etc (Alternative careers for teachers: 6 opportunities to leverage your existing skills) . High emotional demands teachers face and burnout lead to their decisions of leaving the profession, which creates challenges with increasing teacher quality, student achievement and overall academic achievement (Santoro, et al.). In addition to that teachers are not given the necessary resources and budget to provide engaging lectures.
There are several distractions in the classroom that can disrupt a students learning such as personal devices, unnecessary talking and tardiness (Leustig). Other distractions are personal distractions such as boredom, missing schools, failing classes, needing to get a job, parenthood, being caregivers for family members. These distractions lead to students dropping out of school. Potential solutions are incorporating a connection between school and work in the curriculum and ensuring that students have a relationship with at least one adult in school to talk about their personal problems (Azzam ). Studies have also shown that students do not pay attention to lectures due to engagement with non-lecture related activities in computers but also due to increase in mind wandering which lead to the conclusion that the main problem for lack of attention to lecture material is academic engagement (Risko, et al.).
Technology/Engineering
Most schools have embraced the digital age, but that classroom management and school discipline has been slow to follow suit. Prior research has focused on technologies' role for training teachers in classroom management, however, there has been less research that has addressed the tools used by educators or by students to promote positive behavior. These technology roles “include training teachers, supporting educators' day-to-day practices, and promoting self-discipline or self-regulation among students” with a variety of tools “including but not limited to videos, 3D simulations, and web-based apps” (Cho et al, 2020).
Technology used in the classroom were analyzed to determine if they were either Type I or Type II and how “successful” the student teachers thought that the technology used were. “Type I, which is more drill-and-practice applications, were found to be present at all grade levels but were most prevalent in K-2 classrooms, and Type II applications, which are those that require active intellectual involvement by the learner” (Brawner et al, 2006). The results of this investigation were not surprising as more student teachers reported Type I applications were their most successful use of technology in the primary grades as their curriculum is mostly memorization based, while Type II was more successful in the older grades as these applications “allow their students to explore, synthesize, and present information”.
Society Issues
Staffing issue has become a major problem nowadays. Studies show that teachers become exhausted of working on their weekends and nights to complete tasks such as grading papers and planning classes. Teachers often feel they have no time or energy to spend time with their families and they feel their job is taking over their lives. As a result, a lot of school workers now are reconsidering their jobs and careers to be more happy.
Staffing issue not only affect on schools, but they affect on the economy as well. Although there isn't a specific agreed answer for the overall staffing issue, studies indicate that what's happening in the economy can provide insight into what's happening in education. In addition, Nicole Smith noted that teacher shortages “can put an entire society at risk.”
Schools contribute to nearly 10,000 gallons of wastewater each year. Old faucets can lead up to 3000 gallons of wastewater a year. Irrigation leaks can cause up to 6,300 gallons of water waste a month. In Arizona water is a big problem and ensuring our schools have up to date equipment and repairs will save money and help alleviate water scarcity issues. (US EPA)
The United States spends more than $6 billion on energy for K-12 schools. This adds up to more money than the amount spent on computers and textbooks. Most of the energy wasted is used on technology or lights that aren’t in use. The other issue is most of these schools are old buildings that have poor insulation and old equipment that increase the amount of energy needed to keep the building a certain temperature. Seaford school district, DE, replaced boilers, upgraded lighting and installed improved dehumidification equipment. All of these improvements helped reduce their energy use by 16% a year. Simple improvements can help reduce energy use which in turn saves schools money that can be used elsewhere. (Energystar.gov)
Schools produce tons of trash a day and the cafeteria is responsible for half of the waste. Everyday schools waste about $5 million dollars in food waste everyday. Most of the kids in schools don’t eat half of the meal provided. Most of the fruit and vegetables are thrown away and most of it stays in the garbage. Kids also tend to be picky and if anything looks “wrong” then it’ll get thrown away. Oaklands K-12 schools have implemented programs to combat waste issues. One of them is the “take it and go” program where students are able to take the food, they didn’t finish back to class to eat. There are also new food share guidelines that teach kids what food can be donated and what can’t. This encourages sharing, less waste, and provides for those who can use the food like the homeless. In Phoenix, the homeless have started to grow and are in need of cheap, nutritious food. School can provide that with the wasted fruit and vegetables that kids discard. (Grist 2021)
For our actionable insights, we used the critical findings from our research topics of Users, Business/Market, Technology, and Society/Environment. Our main actionable insights for Users focus heavily on the social needs of the students and teachers including managing stress, creating a wholesome learning environment, and setting up a schedule that can incorporate multiple breaks as that is what our research on Users supports. The actionable insights for our Business/Market were also centered on creating an educational environment where students and teachers can be more engaged. This logically makes sense that this would be similar because our Users are our Market (Stakeholders). While our Technology focuses on how we could optimize the current technologies and what new technologies could potentially be more in the classroom to further promote educational learning with a sub-focus on how we could combat the current disadvantages of technology in the classroom (less memorable learning, distracting, cheating, etc.). Then conclusively our Society/Environment critical findings also tie into our Technology focus goals in that rather than spending an excessive amount of money on new sustainable technology, we could instead improve upon the current sustainable technology being used and consequently possibly use the saved money for other school expenses like teacher salaries.
The main priority of students is a safe and respectful learning environment. To help them with their academic achievements, students want more interactive and engaging lectures and activities. They also want more support and tutors to help them overcome any personal or academic problem. Students do not receive enough personalized learning, hence this is something they are asking for. Both teachers and students ask for more comfortable furniture that can be rearranged to fit the needs for the class activities. Last but not least, students want more access to technology that can enhance their learning experience.
Whiteboard tables/desks are tools used in learning spaces that can help anyone take quick short notes and brainstorm ideas without the need to look for a piece of scrap paper. I believe this is an innovative use of desks because many of the current desks in classrooms are already written on. So having a whiteboard desk allows students to be creative and they can easily erase their notes or doodles after they are done. This relates to the topic of personalized learning because students can use their own personal space to write their own ideas or topics of their liking. Whiteboard tables also allow collaboration among students which increases their engagement in the classroom. The author of the article, Whiteboard Tables: Everything You Need to Know, Dylan Meikle, noted that the use of whiteboard tables create spaces that enrich collaboration and empower visible thinking. He also points out that this tool helps reduce the use of paper. The article also mentioned flip-up tables which allow other students in the classroom to see what is written on the table from different areas in the classroom. The article, Collaborative Whiteboard Tables: A Versatile Learning Tool, makes similar remarks about whiteboard tables. It stated that whiteboard tables “encourage impromptu brainstorming and notetaking” and “make for a ‘greener’ classroom by reducing the need for paper.” Some of the major benefits listed in this article are that whiteboard tables have great value because they serve as school furnishing and an effective learning tool, they are reusable which correlates to the reduction of paper use and being better for the environment, they can be easy to move around and adjust their height, and they are not messy and mistakes can be easily erased.
Education institutions are increasingly adopting the use of virtual reality (VR) to provide students with the same opportunity to have a more immersive and engaged learning experience. Virtual reality (VR) is a useful tool for education because it gives students new ways to engage with and understand the material being taught, which relates to our team's research. Some of the more complex areas of mathematics can be better understood and learned with the aid of virtual reality. Because of VR's interactive nature, students can experience their research without breaking the bank. Learning science equips students with the analytical and problem-solving abilities necessary to succeed in the modern world. Learners can conduct chemical experiments in a virtual lab environment using virtual reality technology. Student interest and enjoyment in mathematics can be increased by providing them with more opportunities to apply their knowledge in concrete situations. It's useful for learning subjects that aren't easily taught from a book, like physics or biology. Students studying Geography can use VR to travel to any location on Earth. Use virtual reality to simulate a visit to a physical bank for use in teaching economics. As seen, there are several ways in which virtual reality (VR) technology can be used to enhance the learning process immensely.
https://design-resource.com/news/biophilic-design/
https://www.officelovin.com/2020/12/a-look-inside-nordeas-biophilic-office-in-gdynia/
Biophilic Design
When applied to the built environment, biophilic design improves human well-being on all levels such as physical, emotional, and intellectual. Pictures of trees, flowers, mountains, and other beautiful landscapes provide the same calming effects on minds as being outside in actual natural settings. When biophilic design principles are used, stress levels are decreased, recovery times for patients are accelerated, and creativity is improved. I'm interested in this topic because I've experienced personally how beneficial biophilia is in workplaces. In typical work spaces with artificial lighting, small windows, boxy shape interiors, I usually feel exhausted and worn out. On the other hand, I enjoy working in greenhouses and areas with natural light because it makes me feel energized and comfortable. I believe bringing biophilic design to schools and work spaces can definitely help students and teachers around the world to feel more energized and happy. In addition to their aesthetic effect, plants in classrooms can have some surprising sensory advantages. Stress relief and mood improvement might result from the scents and sounds of a blooming garden or irrigation systems. With Biophilia, classrooms will become a rich sensory environment for learning.
Image Source: Google Images
STEM is short for Science, Technology, Engineering and Math education. It is an interdisciplinary subject with a focus on hands-on, problem-based learning. Educating the students in STEM early in their educational careers can open opportunities that can lead the way for future innovations. By allowing students to explore how to problem solve can promote self-efficacy, because the method of exploration rewards and builds their confidence when they accomplish a task with persistence. This can also promote engagement, motivation, independent learning, and collaboration and has been long recognized as a vital component in contributing to the common good of society and improving communities and national prosperity. STEM education interests me personally because STEM jobs are the future of our society and I believe it starts too late for most students as only some high school and/or college classes teach the concepts. STEM is the foundation to teaching students how to think critically. This relates to our team project (and my honors thesis) because STEM education plays an important role in improving student engagement and societal concerns.
Image Source: Google Images
Biomimicry is innovation inspired by nature. It uses interdisciplinary knowledge to address human design problems and looks through the lens of life’s principles to come up with sustainable products. To me it is the future of sustainable designs that will help address the environmental issues we have today. It relates to our research because it can be used to create modular classrooms, provide cross disciplinary thinking in education and give value to nature for students to appreciate/notice the world around them. Students can not only learn from nature but it also can be used by art teachers, science teachers and even english teachers to blend the different subjects students have to learn. A great website is Asknature.com that has scientific research about organisms' basic functions in the world and how they use that to their advantage. The research is broken up into different categories that relay the basic function of an organism. For example a dolphin would be under “moves through liquid”. This website can be used for design classes to learn from nature's movement/structures. Art classes can learn how different animals use camouflage to blend different colors. The possibilities are endless and it can give students a base understanding of sustainability, design, and the knowledge nature has to provide.
University of Central arkansas: UCA. Art and Design. (n.d.). Retrieved October 18, 2022, from https://uca.edu/art/2021/03/30/ways-biophilic-design-promotes-human-health-and-well-being/
5 ways that biophilic design can boost social-emotional learning. (n.d.). Retrieved October 18, 2022, from https://ideas.demco.com/blog/5-ways-that-biophilic-design-cac-boost-social-emotional-learning/
Cho, Vincent, et al. “The Past and Future Technology in Classroom Management and School Discipline: A Systematic Review.” Teaching & Teacher Education, vol. 90, Apr. 2020, p. N.PAG. EBSCOhost, https://doi-org.ezproxy1.lib.asu.edu/10.1016/j.tate.2020.103037.Impact of teacher shortages in most states far-reaching. Southern Regional Education Board. (2015, December 10). Retrieved October 21, 2022, from https://www.sreb.org/blog-post/impact-teacher-shortages-most-states-far-reaching
Energy Star | the Simple Choice for Energy Efficiency. https://www.energystar.gov/sites/default/files/buildings/tools/SPP%20Sales%20Flyer%20for%20Supermarkets%20and%20Grocery%20Stores.pdf.
EPA, Environmental Protection Agency, https://www.epa.gov/watersense/fix-leak-week#:~:text=The%20average%20household's%20leaks%20can,faucets%2C%20and%20other%20leaking%20valves.
Marsh, Jane. “Environmental Problems in Schools and How to Address Them.” Environment Co, 14 Oct. 2022, https://environment.co/environmental-problems-in-schools-and-how-to-address-them/#:~:text=Environmental%20Problems%20in%20Schools%20and%20How%20to%20Address,Water%20Management%20...%205%20Communication%20Is%20Key%20.
mcraft2016. “Schools Waste $5 Million a Day in Uneaten Food. Here's How Oakland Is Reinventing the Cafeteria.” Grist, 1 Apr. 2021, https://grist.org/article/schools-waste-5-million-a-day-in-uneaten-food-heres-how-oakland-is-reinventing-the-cafeteria/.
Digital, Careful. “Why Teach Biomimicry?” Why Teach Biomimicry?, https://natent.eu/en/why-teach-biomimicry/.
“Innovation Inspired by Nature - Asknature.” Innovation Inspired by Nature -, https://asknature.org/.