Universal Design is a process of designing that allows for variability, diversity, and differences. A common example from architecture is the curb cut on a sidewalk. Curb cuts provide accessibility for wheelchair users. They also benefit parents using strollers, skateboarders, and workers with delivery carts. The sidewalk’s purpose and function do not change with the addition of curb cuts, but the sidewalk is now accessible to many who might not otherwise be able to use it.
Universal Design for Learning (UDL) applies this concept to the classroom. It is a framework for designing learning experiences that allow for variability in how our students learn. In 2009, the Center for Applied Special Technology (CAST) developed guidelines to help instructors apply universal design to learning.
As CAST describes it, "UDL is an approach to improve and optimize teaching and learning for all by setting clear, rigorous goals; anticipating barriers; and proactively designing to minimize those barriers."
In each classroom, there are a wide variety of learners in terms of their background with the material, their unique ways of processing new material, and their preferred methods of communicating acquired knowledge. UDL seeks to minimize the barriers and maximize the opportunities to access the new information, rather than insisting that each student learn in precisely the same way. When we design a class in a way that anticipates and breaks down barriers for students, the course is more accessible and inclusive. Even making minor changes in the way students access material and demonstrate learning can make very large differences in how accessible a course is for students.
Designing a course with accessibility in mind is different from complying with the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA). Compliance is a requirement, and institutions are required to provide reasonable accommodations to students with documented disabilities. However, when accessibility is considered as part of the course design, it can benefit all students, whether or not they have a documented disability. Like the curb cuts, many can benefit.
There are three main pillars of a universally designed curriculum (OCALI):
Multiple means of engagement to challenge appropriately, to motivate, and to allow learners to express and participate in their interests
Multiple means of representation to allow various ways of acquiring information and knowledge
Multiple means of expression to allow alternatives for demonstrating knowledge
As the two brief videos below demonstrate, UDL is one framework that can help you build inclusivity into the design of your classes. It can also help promote student retention and success.
When first learning about UDL and considering the UDL guidelines, the new possibilities for course design can feel overwhelming. As the brief video below describes, it can help to choose just one class assignment or one barrier students may face. Apply UDL principles to this, and see how it goes in the classroom.
Students have different reasons for pursuing a degree. Your students will be motivated and inspired by different things, and they will find connection to the material in different ways. Designing for multiple means of engagement means providing students with many different ways to engage with your course’s content and feel connected to the class.
Considerations:
How do students find a sense of belonging in the class?
How can students connect with others?
How might students experience joy or a sense of play?
What opportunities are there to experience empathy?
Possible Ways to Address:
Vary activities and sources of information.
Examine bias in the classroom and your expectations.
Provide opportunities for creativity and curiosity.
Co-create classroom agreements with students.
Allow students opportunities to connect with each other.
Especially when working with adult learners, it is important to provide choice and autonomy, while considering the relevance and value of the material for students. The updated UDL 3.0 guidelines include a call to nurture joy and play for students (CAST, 2024).
Each student comes to Antioch with a unique set of intersectionalities, skills, abilities, and experiences that influence how confident they are in expressing their ideas and knowledge in various ways. To be truly accessible, we want to be sure that course content, assignments, and discussions represent diverse identities, that we deeply consider the perspectives and perceptions of people, cultures, and languages, and we are intentionally not only recognizing, but valuing, multiple ways of knowing and making meaning.
The new CAST guidelines ask that instructors consider if:
students are able to customize the display of information to suit their needs
students have ways to access the information for the class through means that go beyond just text and image (videos, audio files, live conversations)
students can connect prior knowledge to new learning
students can transfer their learning to new contexts
instructors highlight patterns, big ideas, and relationships as connected to learning gorals
instructors address linguistic biases and honor wide varieties of forms of language
Multiple Means of Expression for Demonstrating and Assessing Learning
Every learner approaches their learning according to their backgrounds, preferences, strengths, and weaknesses. There is no singular or magical assignment that will be perfect for all learners to demonstrate the knowledge and skills they've gained through a course. To add accessibility to your courses, you can ensure that students have a variety of ways to show their learning across a course.
The new CAST guidelines ask that instructors consider if:
students can use a variety of tools to access the information, with a focus on physical accessibility and alternative ways to respond or interact in class
their syllabus allows for tools and technologies that enhance access to learning
students have the opportunity to use multimedia to communicate how they have achieved an objective, outcome, or goal
students have the opportunity to digital tools to enhance their communication & expression
Definition of UDL
List of Universal Design ideas for teaching (Academic Ableism: Disability and Higher Education by Jay Timothy Dolmage)
Resources for accessibility (a wealth of links and Open Access Resources)
www.beyondaccommodation.wordpress.com
UDL in Higher Education
UDL was an offshoot of the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) and IDEA. It was initially applied to K-12 education, but has been expanding into higher education also. The ADA became law in 1990 as a civil rights law that prohibits discrimination against people with disabilities in all facilities, public or private, that are open to the public. IDEA has gone through several re-authorizations and is also intended to guarantee that students with disabilities receive the full benefit of a Free and Appropriate Public Education. As teachers began to understand that their classrooms were going to include, and be accountable for, students with different abilities and learning styles, UDL was born, and soon migrated to higher education.
For general information about UDL visit OCALI’s website or CAST’s website.
For specific information about UDL visit CAST’s higher education website.
CAST Frequently Asked Questions visit Frequently Asked Questions about UDL
Podcast (40 minutes long) that gives background on UDL
UDL in Practice
Think about your assignments - Have you considered UDL Guidelines in writing this assignment?
Thomas J. Tobin, & Kirsten T. Behling. (2018). Reach Everyone, Teach Everyone : Universal Design for Learning in Higher Education: Vol. First edition. West Virginia University Press.
Executive Functioning in Online Classes (CAST)
Supporting Executive functioning in Online classes (video link)
Face to Face
Hybrid or synchronous through Zoom or other conferencing:
Web Conferencing Resources (CAST)
Assessment of Learning in UDL (Useful tips for assessing student learning)
Resource for developing UDL-compliant syllabi:
This is a section of the UDL on Campus website that speaks specifically about developing accessible syllabi.
The video linked here introduces the 2024 updates to the UDL Guidelines. The UDL Guidelines are continuously developed based on new research and feedback from practitioners. This new update addresses barriers rooted in biases and systems of exclusion.
UDL Section and Course Accessibility Section on Antioch DSS Faculty Resource LibGuide Site.
Other resources for UDL from Bonnie Powers and the UDL Google Group:
Antioch UDL Sakai Site - https://sakai.antioch.edu/portal/site/UDL/tool/ed85c473-0e9f-41c9-9bd0-1b6063d4c607
Antioch also has a UDL Google Group for people who want to share and receive resources and conversation on UDL: au-udl-group@antioch.edu
If anyone wants to join they can email Bonnie Powers at bpowers@antioch.edu. There are currently 53 members of the group.
Here is a AU-AT Wakelet Collection of resources on Accessibility and Universal Design for Learning
Here is an assortment of UDL books, articles, and other resources you might find interesting:
Cracks in the Foundation: The Past and Future of the UDL Guidelines (UDL Center Blog)
Webinar Chat Doc: Mission Accomplice: Practicing Antiracism with UDL
UDL Guidelines (CAST)
Quantum 10 Equity in Education (10 Frameworks, theories and practices that promote equity in education) (Quantum 10)
Short UDL-specific video (Quantum 10)
Universally Designing in Universal Chaos (Faculty Focus)
Creating Inclusive Learning Opportunities in Higher Education: A Universal Design Toolkit (PDF). (Disabilities, Opportunities, Internetworking, and Technology)
Remote or Not, UDL Lessons Still Apply (Kim Schiefelbein, Novak Education)
Books:
Addy, T., Dube, D., Mitchell, K., & SoRelle, M. What inclusive instructors do: Principles and practices for excellence in college teaching. (Ebook version)
Burgstahler, Sheryl, and Cory, Rebecca. (2008) Universal design in higher education: from principles to practice. (Ebook version)
Fitzgerald, A. (2020). Antiracism and universal design for learning. (In print at Bookshop.org)
Thomas J. Tobin, & Kirsten T. Behling. (2018). Reach Everyone, Teach Everyone : Universal Design for Learning in Higher Education: Vol. First edition. West Virginia University Press.
Zaloudek, J., Chandler, R., Carlson, K., Howarton, R. (eds.). (2018). Universal design for learning: Teaching to all college students. Available as a print book only.
Language
Does my syllabus list Standard American English as an expectation for student writing or do I recognize multiple languages/grammars as acceptable in student writing and presentations?
Do I explicitly address the problem with SAE as an expectation in my syllabus?
Accessibility
To what extent is my course material accessible to all students, including those with disabilities?
Are all online readings recognizable by screen readers (can highlight the text on the pdf?
Do my visual media have subtitles?
Variety
Have I provided students a variety of ways to show what they know?
To what extent does the format of the course material respond to a broad range of learning preferences (reading written text, visual and audio media preferences, etc.)?
Formative Assessment
Do I have a variety of assignments that provide students with immediate feedback and opportunities to improve?
Are mistakes expected, respected, and used to elevate students’ understanding of the subject?
Do I offer opportunities for students to resubmit or submit missed or late work?
What opportunities do students have to catch up if they are behind due to technological barriers or other personal deterrents?
Divergent Thinking
Is divergent, creative thinking rewarded or do assessments require students to conform to one common norm?
Flexibility
Does my course design allow for some flexibility so that the class can respond to unexpected discussions and opportunities that may arise?
Instructor Availability
Can students contact me through multiple methods and with flexibility in communication times?