"We must nurture and respect differences and appreciate the multitude of perspectives resulting from our differences. We must strive to provide an environment that is enriching to all. Along with recognizing differences, understanding and appreciating our shared humanity allows us to work and learn in an atmosphere where all are welcome and valued." - Aims Diversity Statement
This reading focuses on diversity, equity and inclusion. You'll learn about definitions of diversity, types of diversity, intersectionality, why diversity matters in college, and what you can do. The Center for Diversity & Inclusion (CDI) is a resource to you at Aims. We hope after learning more about the programming, you'll take advantage of opportunities to continually deepen your knowledge about diversity, equity and inclusion.
For the student perspective, check out the Words of Wisdom - Why So Many Questions? by Fatima Rodriguez Johnson
COLLEGE SUCCESS STRATEGY: Create your own identity wheel following the instructions at Personal Identity Wheel. Reflect on these questions.
What identities do you think about most often?
What identities do you think about least often?
What identities would you like to learn more about?
What identities have the strongest effect on how you perceive yourself?
What identities have the greatest effect on how others perceive you?
*This is a great activity to complete with others.
"Diversity: the art of thinking independently together." — Malcolm Forbes
There are few words in the English language that have more diverse interpretations than diversity. What does diversity mean? Diversity means different things to different people, and it can be understood differently in different environments.[2]
Differences among people may involve where a person was born and raised, the person’s family and cultural group, factual differences in personal identity, and chosen differences in significant beliefs. Some diversity is primarily cultural (involving shared beliefs and behaviors), other diversity may be biological (race, age, gender), and some diversity is defined in personal terms (sexual orientation, religion). Diversity generally involves things that may significantly affect some people’s perceptions of others—not just anyway people happen to be different. For example, having different tastes in music, movies, or books is not what we usually refer to as diversity.
Surface diversity and deep diversity are categories of personal attributes—or differences in attributes—that people perceive to exist between people or groups of people.
Surface-level diversity refers to differences you can generally observe in others, like ethnicity, race, gender, age, culture, language, disability, etc. You can quickly and easily observe these features in a person. And people often do just that, making subtle judgments at the same time, which can lead to bias or discrimination. For example, if a teacher believes that older students perform better than younger students, she may give slightly higher grades to the older students than the younger students. This bias is based on perception of the attribute of age, which is surface-level diversity.
Deep-level diversity, on the other hand, reflects differences that are less visible, like personality, attitude, beliefs, and values. These attributes are generally communicated verbally and nonverbally, so they are not easily noticeable or measurable. You may not detect deep-level diversity in a classmate, for example, until you get to know him or her, at which point you may find that you are either comfortable with these deeper character levels, or perhaps not. But once you gain this deeper level of awareness, you may focus less on surface diversity. For example: At the beginning of a term, a classmate belonging to a minority ethnic group, whose native language is not English (surface diversity), may be treated differently by fellow classmates in another ethnic group. But as the term gets underway, classmates begin discovering the person’s values and beliefs (deep-level diversity), which they find they are comfortable with. The surface-level attributes of language and perhaps skin color become more “transparent” (less noticeable) as comfort is gained with deep-level attributes.
The following video is a quick summary of the differences between surface-level and deep-level diversity.
Direct Link: https://youtu.be/4QsF8_IwmXs
The many layers of our multiple identities do not fit together like puzzle pieces with clear boundaries between one piece and another. Our identities overlap, creating a combined identity in which one aspect is inseparable from the next.
The term intersectionality was coined by legal scholar Kimberlé Crenshaw in 1989 to describe how the experience of Black women was a unique combination of gender and race that could not be divided into two separate identities. In other words, this group could not be seen solely as women or solely as Black; where their identities overlapped is considered the “intersection,” or crossroads, where identities combine in specific and inseparable ways.
Intersectionality and awareness of intersectionality can drive societal change, both in how people see themselves and how they interact with others. That experience can be very inward-facing, or can be more external. It can also lead to debate and challenges. For example, the term “Latinx” is growing in use because it is seen as more inclusive than “Latino/Latina,” but some people—including scholars and advocates—lay out substantive arguments against its use.
While the debate continues, it serves as an important reminder of a key element of intersectionality: Never assume that all people in a certain group or population feel the same way. Why not? Because people are more than any one element of their identity; they are defined by more than their race, color, geographic origin, gender, or socio-economic status. The overlapping aspects of each person’s identity and experiences will create a unique perspective.
As this diagram shows, our identities are formed by dozens of factors, sometimes represented in intersection wheels. Consider the subset of identity elements represented here. Generally, the outer ring are elements that may change relatively often, while the inner circle are often considered more permanent. (There are certainly exceptions.)
Outer Ring - Work Experience, Education, Appearance, Religion, Income, Language & Communication Skills, Organizational Role, Family, Political Belief
Inner Circle - National Origin, Race/Ethincity, Mental/Physical Ability, Sexual Orientation, Age, Gender, Gender Identity or Expression
Reflection Question: How does each contribute to who you are, and how would possible change alter your self-defined identity?
“Intersectionality is a lens through which you can see where power comes and collides, where it locks and intersects. It is the acknowledgement that everyone has their own unique experiences of discrimination and privilege.”
– Kimberlé Crenshaw
This diagram depicts Sylvia Duckworth’s “wheel of power/privilege,” a visual representation of how power, privilege, and social identities intersect. The graphic below uses the imagery of a wheel, sectioned off by the following social identities and respective categories.
Privilege is a right or exemption from liability or duty granted as a special benefit or advantage. Oppression is the result of the “use of institutional privilege and power, wherein one person or group benefits at the expense of another,” according to the University of Southern California Suzanne Dworak Peck School of Social Work.
Reflection Question: How does your level of privilege shift as you place yourself in different identity categories?
Everyone has a certain amount of privilege. For example, consider the privilege brought by being a certain height. If someone's height is close to the average height, they likely have a privilege of convenience when it comes to many day-to-day activities. A person of average height does not need assistance reaching items on high store shelves and does not need adjustments to their car to reach the brake pedal.
There’s nothing wrong with having this privilege, but recognizing it, especially when considering others who do not share it, can be eye-opening and empowering.
Citizenship: citizen, documented, undocumented
Skin colour: white, different shades, dark
Formal education: post-secondary, high school, elementary
Ability: able-bodied, some disability, significant disability
Sexuality: heterosexual; gay men; lesbian, bi, pan, asexual
Neurodiversity: neurotypical, neuroatypical, significant neurodivergence
Mental health: robust, mostly stable, vulnerable
Body size: slim, average, large
Housing: owns property, sheltered/renting, homeless
Wealth: rich, middle class, poor
Language: English, Learned English, non-English monolingual
Gender: cisgender man; cisgender woman; trans, intersex, nonbinary
The Danger of a Single Story Ted Talk
“The single story creates stereotypes, and the problem with stereotypes is not that they are untrue, but that they are incomplete. They make one story become the only story.” - Chimamanda Ngozi Adichie
This Ted Talk by Chimamanda Ngozi Adichie is powerful for understanding intersectionality and the danger of a "single story."
It matters because when you are exposed to new ideas, viewpoints, customs, and perspectives—which invariably happens when you come in contact with diverse groups of people—you expand your frame of reference for understanding the world. Your thinking becomes more open and global. You become comfortable working and interacting with people of all nationalities. You gain a new knowledge base as you learn from people who are different from yourself. You think “harder” and more creatively. You perceive in new ways, seeing issues and problems from new angles. You can absorb and consider a wider range of options, and your values may be enriched. In short, it contributes to your education.
Consider the following facts about diversity in the United States:
More than half of all U.S. babies today are people of color, and by 2050 the U.S. will have no clear racial or ethnic majority. As communities of color are tomorrow’s leaders, college campuses play a major role in helping prepare these leaders.
But in 2009, while 28 percent of Americans older than 25 years of age had a four-year college degree, only 17 percent of African Americans and 13 percent of Hispanics had a four-year degree. More must be done to adequately educate the population and help prepare students to enter the workforce.
Today, people of color make up about 36 percent of the workforce (roughly one in three workers). But by 2050, half the workforce (one in two workers) will be a person of color. Again, college campuses can help navigate these changes.[3]
All in all, diversity brings richness to relationships on campus and off campus, and it further prepares college students to thrive and work in a multicultural world. Diversity is fast becoming America’s middle name.
While diversity exists in most places, not everyone automatically understands differences among people and celebrates the value of those differences. Students who never think about diversity and who make no conscious effort to experience and understand others gain less than others who do. There are many ways you can experience the benefits of diversity on your college campus, however, beginning with your own attitudes and by taking steps to increase your experiences with diverse individuals.
Acknowledge your own uniqueness, for you are diverse, too. Diversity doesn’t involve just other people. Consider that you may be just as different from other people as they are to you. Don’t think of the other person as being the one who is different, that you are somehow the “norm.” Your religion may seem just as odd to them as theirs does to you, and your clothing may seem just as strange looking to them as theirs is to you—until you accept there is no one “normal” or right way to be. Look at yourself in a mirror and consider why you look as you do. Why do you use the slang you do with your friends? Why did you just have that type of food for breakfast? How is it that you prefer certain types of music? Read certain books? Talk about certain things? Much of this has to do with your cultural background—so it makes sense that someone from another cultural or ethnic background is different in some ways. But both of you are also individuals with your own tastes, preferences, ideas, and attitudes—making you unique. It’s only when you realize your own uniqueness that you can begin to understand and respect the uniqueness of others, too.
Consider your own (possibly unconscious) stereotypes. A stereotype is a fixed, simplistic view of what people in a certain group are like. It is often the basis for prejudice and discrimination: behaving differently toward someone because you stereotype them in some way. Stereotypes are generally learned and emerge in the dominant culture’s attitudes toward those from outside that dominant group. A stereotype may be explicitly racist and destructive, and it may also be a simplistic generalization applied to any group of people, even if intended to be flattering rather than negative. As you have read this chapter so far, did you find yourself thinking about any group of people, based on any kind of difference, and perhaps thinking in terms of stereotypes? If you walked into a party and saw many different kinds of people standing about, would you naturally avoid some and move toward others? Remember, we learn stereotypes from our cultural background—so it’s not a terrible thing to admit you have inherited some stereotypes. Thinking about them is a first step in breaking out of these irrational thought patterns.
Do not try to ignore differences among people. Some people try so hard to avoid stereotyping that they go to the other extreme and try to avoid seeing any differences at all among people. But as we have seen throughout this chapter, people are different in many ways, and we should accept that if we are to experience the benefits of diversity.
Don’t apply any group generalizations to individuals. As an extension of not stereotyping any group, also don’t think of any individual person in terms of group characteristics. People are individuals first, members of a group second, and any given generalization simply may not apply to an individual. Be open-minded and treat everyone with respect as an individual with his or her own ideas, attitudes, and preferences.
Develop cultural sensitivity for communication. Realize that your words may not mean quite the same thing in different cultural contexts or to individuals from different backgrounds. This is particularly true of slang words, which you should generally avoid until you are sure the other person will know what you mean. Never try to use slang or expressions you think are common in the cultural group of the person you are speaking with. Similarly, since body language often varies among different cultures, avoid strong gestures and expressions until the responses of the other person signify he or she will not misinterpret the messages sent by your body language.
Take advantage of campus opportunities to increase your cultural awareness. Your college likely has multiculturalism courses or workshops you can sign up for. Special events, cultural fairs and celebrations, concerts, and other programs are held frequently on most campuses. There may also be opportunities to participate in group travel to other countries or regions of cultural diversity.
Take the initiative in social interactions. Many students just naturally hang out with other students they are most like—that almost seems to be part of human nature. Even when we’re open-minded and want to learn about others different from ourselves, it often seems easier and more comfortable to interact with others of the same age, cultural group, and so on. If we don’t make a small effort to meet others, however, we miss a great opportunity to learn and broaden our horizons. Next time you’re looking around the classroom or dorm for someone to ask about a class you missed or to study together for a test or group project, choose someone different from you in some way. Making friends with others of different backgrounds is often one of the most fulfilling experiences of college students.
Work through conflicts as in any other interaction. Conflicts simply occur among people, whether of the same or different background. If you are afraid of making a mistake when interacting with someone from a different background, you might avoid interaction altogether—and thus miss the benefits of diversity. Nothing risked, nothing gained. If you are sincere and respect the other, there is less risk of a misunderstanding occurring. If conflict does occur, work to resolve it as you would any other tension with another person, as described earlier.
Be an ally to people victimized by intolerant behavior: No one knows when a racist or sexist attack is coming. The Barnard Center for Research on Women has created a video suggesting ways to be an ally to people victimized by intolerant behavior.
Expand your understanding through continual training and educational opportunities on campus: The Multicultural Office for Student Affinity, Inclusion and Community (MOSAIC) at Aims provides students with opportunities to connect with peers; discuss issues of diversity, equity, inclusion, and justice; and to foster action and change through workshops, events, and gatherings.
The Multicultural Office for Student Affinity, Inclusion and Community (MOSAIC) serves as a resource for Aims Community College students to build community and to learn about and advocate for issues of equity and justice. Students have many identities that influence and shape their college experience, and the MOSAIC fosters a culture of support, community, sharing, and acceptance.
Learn more about the following resources and programs MOSAIC at https://www.aims.edu/departments/multicultural-office-student-affinity-inclusion-community
Student Involvement and Leadership
Community Space
Diversity and Inclusion Resources
Latinx Students
Military Affiliated Students
All-Gender Bathrooms
REFERENCES:
University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill: School of Public Health. (n.d.). How would you define diversity? [public survey]. Retrieved from https://sph.unc.edu/files/2013/07/define_diversity.pdf
National Public Radio. (2010). Defining diversity: beyond race and gender. Retrieved from http://www.npr.org/templates/story/story.php?storyId=122327104
Center for American Progress. (2016). 10 reasons why we need diversity on college campuses. Retrieved from https://www.americanprogress.org/issues/race/news/2012/10/09/41004/10-reasons-why-we-need-diversity-on-college-campuses/.
National Institutes Health. (n.d.). Answering diversity questions during an interview. [Blog]. Office of Intramural Training & Education. Retrieved from https://oitecareersblog.wordpress.com/2017/08/22/answering-diversity-questions-during-an-interview/
LICENSES AND ATTRIBUTIONS
CC LICENSED CONTENT, SHARED PREVIOUSLY
Derivative from College Success. Provided by: Lumen Learning. Located at: https://courses.lumenlearning.com/suny-collegesuccess-lumen1/chapter/diversity-and-accessibility/#footnote-256-1 License: CC BY: Attribution
Derivative from College Success. Provided by: Saylor. Located at: https://saylordotorg.github.io/text_college-success/s12-02-living-with-diversity.html License: CC BY: Attribution
9.2 Categories of Diversity, College Success. Authored by: Amy Baldwin. Located at: https://openstax.org/books/college-success/pages/9-2-categories-of-diversity. License: CC BY: Attribution
Universal Design for Learning (UDL) for Inclusion, Diversity, Equity, and Accessibility (IDEA). Authored by: Darla Benton Kearney Located at: https://ecampusontario.pressbooks.pub/universaldesign. License: CC BY: Attribution
ALL RIGHTS RESERVED CONTENT
Surface Level vs. Deep-Level Diversity. Authored by: Ken Harris. Located at: https://youtu.be/4QsF8_IwmXs. License: All Rights Reserved. License Terms: Standard YouTube License
Chimamanda Ngozi Adichie: The danger of a single story. Authored by: TED. Located at: https://youtu.be/D9Ihs241zeg License: All Rights Reserved. License Terms: Standard YouTube License