Matthew Harrison Brady: Joseph Pryor
Drummond: Stefania Gonzalez
Bertram Cates: Joe Singh
E. K. Hornbeck: Kylee Smith
Rachel Brown: Maggie Lupton
Reverend Jeremiah Brown: Ryan Moore
The Judge: Wesley Welt
Melinda Loomis: Eliza Larsen
Davenport:Téa Hajratwala
The Mayor: Ayla Tighe
Meeker: John Harrell
Mrs. Sarah Brady: Emma Crisenbery
Mrs. Krebs: Alayna Musson
Mr. Bannister: Jake Edwards
Elijah: Ethan Schmaltz
Esterbrook: Claudia Curcione
Jesse Dunlap: Eddie Ozor
George Sillers: Collin Wagner
Phil: Ellie Bauer
Organ Grinder: Kimberly Schamberger
Howard Blair: Tomi Byrd
Mrs. Loomis: Dee Covey
Mrs. Blair: Delia Leon
Photographer/Reporter: Willow Symonds
Bollinger: Jade Hartman
Mr. Goodfellow: Brooklyn McLean
Vendor: Hannah Weatherly
Mrs. McClain: Cristina Gonzalez
JURORS:
Sayoni Bandyopadhyay
Ellie Bauer
Dee Covey
Jake Edwards
Jade Hartman
Brooklyn McLean
Kimberly Schamberger
Collin Wagner
Allison Wall