Photo: Public Domain West Virginia. (2021). Good Photos. Retrieved from https://www.goodfreephotos.com/united-states/west-virginia/
Historically, West Virginia has had a large dependency on coal, both for energy and wealth generation.1 Rural communities in the area often rely on coal industries for financial stability, as it traditionally has been one of the top suppliers of jobs in parts of West Virginia.2 This dependency on coal has created larger environmental and economic concerns which will need to be considered in the future. Political, economic, cultural, and social pressures in the area often make it difficult to find sustainable alternatives to fossil fuel industries, namely coal. This creates issues in terms of economic viability. Local communities sometimes rely on fossil fuel industries, which can create an unsustainable job market. This can create issues with job security, education, and health in these areas. Also, due to rapid technological advancement, workers specifically trained for coal jobs often do not have the vocational skills to transition to new technologies, including the technologies required for the green energy transition.
Photo: Public Domain West Virginia. (2021). Good Photos. Retrieved from https://www.goodfreephotos.com/united-states/west-virginia/
In West Virginia, education quality, especially in rural areas, often cannot compete with surrounding states. West Virginia ranks forty-fifth in primary education3.Public education in rural areas within West Virginia often do not receive the funding that larger schools in metropolitan areas receive, which can create difficulties in adequately preparing or educating students. This issue often contributes to a greater dependency on coal. As fewer students have been sufficiently prepared for college or given economic factors cannot pay for college, young people in this area are unable to capitalize on newer economic opportunities and therefore turn to coal industries for employment.4 Given the economic conditions of the area, students often do not receive the same opportunities given to their counterparts in larger or better-funded areas. Due to poverty, dropout rates, and low socioeconomic status, West Virginia has the lowest percentage of residents with bachelor’s degrees of any state.4This financial and educational reality can often lead students in the area to find jobs within the coal industries. Education is one of the largest factors that play a role in someone’s ability to migrate away from any state.5 Therefore, if economic factors make it difficult to obtain higher education, these factors also make it difficult for residents to leave the area and find employment in other industries. These factors help explain the economic reliance on fossil fuel industries, namely coal, within rural areas in West Virginia.
Photo: Public Domain West Virginia. (2021). Good Photos. Retrieved from https://www.goodfreephotos.com/united-states/west-virginia/
The long reliance on coal in West Virginia has led to political, social, and cultural implications of transitioning to sustainable employment alternatives. Coal industries often support politicians in West Virginia who vote on issues that favor fossil fuel companies.6 This leads to a sort of political gridlock in West Virginia amongst supporters of alternative, green energy, and establishment politicians who enjoy a fiscal partnership with these industries. Also, community members in these rural areas often lean Republican or Libertarian, this gives politicians a mandate to continue supporting these industries.7 This can create a hostile political environment for green energy amongst politicians in these rural areas. Also, the historical importance of energy in West Virginia, primarily coal, has led to a sort of social and cultural popularity amongst the industries. Families often develop familial legacies through these companies and thus have their heirs have built upon this family legitimacy in this industry. This creates an inability at the current time to recognize the economic and environmental implications of continued support of coal industries.
Photo: Public Domain West Virginia. (2021). Good Photos. Retrieved from https://www.goodfreephotos.com/united-states/west-virginia/
Long reliance on coal industries for employment in rural West Virginia can impact workers’ health and safety. As workers continue to labor for coal companies, especially in mines, it creates adverse health risks. This is not sustainable for the health and safety of workers. Coal mining carries inherent risks of mine collapse or failure; however, an often-unnoticed impact of this work is the long-term health risks. Coal miners are often diagnosed with long-term pulmonary conditions or lung cancer. This creates a health epidemic in rural areas in West Virginia, which already struggle with access to adequate health care and high poverty rates. Despite the growing rates of diseases such as black-lung disease, coal lobbying continues to fight against tax reform that would benefit miners.8
Photo: Public Domain West Virginia. (2021). Good Photos. Retrieved from https://www.goodfreephotos.com/united-states/west-virginia/
Coal mining can have detrimental effects on the environment. Surface mines can release chemicals into the environment and release methane gas. According to the US Energy Information Administration, 11% of total US methane emissions were attributed to coal mining.9 Another method of coal extraction is called mountaintop removal mining (MTR). MTR is almost exclusively practiced in the American Appalachian region and West Virginia is one state where it happens most often. MTR consists of using explosives to remove the top layers of rock and dirt above the coal. Such a process requires the deforestation, and thus potential loss of habitat, of the mining area. Moreover, sometimes the unneeded rock is stored in a neighboring valley, which damages the ecosystem in the valleys. The process of exploding tops of mountains also scars the Appalachian landscape, the site of some of the oldest mountains in the world.
Photo: Public Domain West Virginia. (2021). Good Photos. Retrieved from https://www.goodfreephotos.com/united-states/west-virginia/
Apart from the political and social difficulties of transitioning from coal industries, workers possess technical and soft skills, but often do not have the vocational or technological skills to switch to other employment industries.10 Technology advances rapidly and coal mining is a highly specialized occupation with little overlap with other industries. Also, new technology can serve to make workers obsolete in the coal industry without further technological or mechanical training. This creates a system wherein- with a lack of higher education- workers would be unable to find sustainable employment after leaving coal industries. This does little to serve the surrounding communities, especially as coal and other fossil fuel industries are beginning to be replaced with green energy. It also serves to create further dependency on these coal industries. Without adequate access to educational attainment or vocational training programs, it could make it more difficult to find sustainable employment.
Infographic
Click on our section headers to find more information!
EIA. (2020, October 15). West Virginia state profile and energy estimates. eia.gov. Retrieved March 25, 2021, from https://www.eia.gov/state/analysis.php?sid=WV.
Butowsky, H. (1994, June 18). Rethinking labor history: The West Virginia/Virginia coal mining industry. The George Wright Forum, 11(2), 11-16. Retrieved March 25, 2021, from http://www.jstor.org/stable/43597366.
U.S. News. (n.d.). Overview of West Virginia. usnews.com. Retrieved March 25, 2021, from https://www.usnews.com/news/best-states/west-virginia
Arcadipane, B. (2014, September 21). West Virginia’s low percentage of population with at least a four-year college education. Marshall University. Retrieved April 10th https://mds.marshall.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1853&context=etd
Williams, N (2009, August 14). Education, gender, and migration in the context of social change. Health and Human Services. Retrieved April 10th, https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3418604/#:~:text=In%20general%2C%20the%20literature%20appears,may%20appear%20in%20different%20studies.
Young, C. (2021, January 11). West Virginia energy industry groups forming legislative agendas. wvnews.com. Retrieved March 25, 2021, from https://www.wvnews.com/statejournal/news/west-virginia-energy-industry-groups-forming-legislative-agendas/article_05d4f184-9d06-5dc5-8974-6800f37a62f3.html.
Chinni, D., & Rivera, M. (2016, December 18). West Virginia: how the bluest state became the reddest. nbcnews.com. Retrieved March 25, 2021, from https://www.nbcnews.com/meet-the-press/west-virginia-how-bluest-state-became-reddest-n697491.
Volcovici, V. (2018, June 1). Coal lobby fights black-lung tax as disease rates surge. Reuters.com. Retrieved March 25, 2021, from https://www.reuters.com/article/us-usa-coal-blacklung-insight/coal-lobby-fights-black-lung-tax-as-disease-rates-surge-idUSKCN1IX4EG.
Energy Information Administration. (2020, December 1), Coal explained: coal in the environment. US Energy Information Administration. Coal and the environment - U.S. Energy Information Administration (EIA).
McIntosh, T. (2020). The impact of technological advances on older workers. Walden University. Retrieved April 10th. https://scholarworks.waldenu.edu/cgi/view content.cgi?article=10679&context=dissertations