If you want a simple, snap-on cargo solution that keeps your gear organized and secure without complex hardware, choose Yakima; if you need a unified locking system that simplifies security across multiple roof rack components, choose Thule One-Key System 2.
• Yakima Stretch Net: Its biggest strength is the instant, tool-free installation that snaps directly onto crossbars for immediate storage expansion, but it offers no built-in locking mechanism of its own.
• Thule One-Key System 2: Its biggest strength is the ability to align all your locks with a single key, drastically reducing the fumbling of keys in the cold, though it requires existing Thule lock cylinders to function.
• Choose Yakima if you are an RV owner looking to instantly expand carrying capacity for bikes or boxes on any compatible bar.
• Choose Thule One-Key System 2 if you already own a fleet of Thule racks and want to streamline your security workflow into one keyhole.
The Yakima Stretch Net is designed for the practical problem of fitting gear into a roof basket when standard baskets leave gaps. This isn't a heavy-duty structural component like a crossbar; it is a specialized accessory meant to snap onto the front of your existing Yakima crossbar in seconds. The design philosophy here is purely about utility and speed. You do not need tools, wrenches, or hours of assembly time. The unit arrives as a single piece that fits one size, measuring roughly 3.25 inches in width and 14 inches in length, with a weight of just over one pound. That lightness matters because adding unnecessary weight to an RV roof rack can impact fuel economy and handling, and this net adds almost nothing to the overall load.
For the RV owner who frequently hauls oversized items like kayaks, large coolers, or camping furniture, this net provides a critical function: stable gear containment. When you throw a soft-sided bag or an irregularly shaped item into a wire basket, things tend to shift during highway driving. The stretch net acts as a tensioned barrier, holding everything in place so it doesn't slide off the back or bang against the vehicle sides. It creates a "limited lifetime warranty" sense of reliability for the owner who wants a setup they can trust for years without worrying about plastic clips breaking or metal parts corroding. It is a straightforward mechanical solution to a common physical problem.
However, you should skip this product if your primary concern is theft prevention through integrated locking. This specific model does not include a lock cylinder or a keyway. It relies entirely on the underlying structure of your basket or the tension of the net itself to keep items from falling out. If you are parking your RV in a remote campground where leaving gear unattended is a risk, you will need to pair this net with a separate padlock or rely on the inherent security of your basket. It is also worth noting that the release date of this product dates back to 2008, indicating a mature, proven design rather than a new feature-heavy experiment. If you need something flashy or high-tech, this utilitarian net might feel too basic, but for pure function, it hits the mark perfectly.
We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
Updated: 2026-11-07 · 7 min read · Independent comparison
The Thule One-Key System 2 Pack is a completely different beast, focusing entirely on the user experience of security rather than cargo space. This is not a cargo carrier or a net; it is a set of two lock cylinders designed to replace the existing locks on your Thule products. The core value proposition is the "One Key" concept. In the world of rooftop accessories, it is incredibly frustrating to carry three, four, or five different keys for your bike rack, your ski box, your cargo box, and your kayak carrier. With this system, you swap out the old lock cores for these new ones, and suddenly every piece of equipment uses the same grip-friendly Thule Comfort key. This is a massive convenience factor for anyone who has ever stood in the rain or snow trying to find the right key to unlock their gear.
The physical specifications tell us this is a compact, precision-engineered solution. The package dimensions are small—just under six inches long—and the individual lock cylinders weigh less than a quarter of a pound. This minimal footprint means you don't have to worry about them interfering with the aerodynamics of your rack or taking up valuable storage space in your glove box when not in use. The color scheme of silver and black blends seamlessly with most modern roof rack finishes, ensuring that the locks don't look like an afterthought. The release date of 2019 suggests a more recent iteration of Thule's locking technology, likely incorporating improved materials or tolerances compared to older generations.
This product is strictly for the owner of a multi-component Thule ecosystem. If you only have one Thule rack, buying a pack of two locks is redundant unless you plan to buy another Thule accessory soon. It is not a universal fit; it works specifically with Thule products that are compatible with their One-Key System. If you have a mix of brands—a Thule basket on a Yakima tower, for instance—this system cannot unify those locks. It is also important to understand that this does not add any new security features like a stronger alloy body or a higher pin count than what was previously available; it simply unifies the access point. It is a logistical upgrade, not necessarily a security upgrade, making it ideal for the busy family or professional who values time and convenience over complex mechanics.
• Best for expanding cargo capacity → Yakima, as it physically adds a containment layer to your existing basket.
• Best for streamlining key management → Thule One-Key System 2, as it consolidates all lock access into a single key.
• Best for quick installation → Yakima, which snaps on in seconds without tools versus the few steps required to swap lock cylinders.
• Best for RV owners with mixed gear → Yakima, since it solves the physical problem of shifting loads regardless of the brand of rack you own.
• Best for RV owners with a Thule-only fleet → Thule One-Key System 2, eliminating the hassle of managing multiple keys for different boxes and racks.
• Best for long-term durability → Yakima offers a Limited Lifetime Warranty, whereas Thule focuses on the longevity of the key-alignment mechanism.
• Best for versatility → Yakima, because it can be used on any compatible Yakima basket, whereas Thule locks require specific proprietary lock cylinders.
In my opinion, I would choose the Yakima Stretch Net for the average RV owner because it solves a tangible, daily physical problem that occurs every time you load up the car. The ability to snap on a net and immediately secure a shifting load is a functional necessity that improves the travel experience more than having a single key for a rack. However, if you are already deep into the Thule ecosystem with multiple boxes and racks, the Thule One-Key System 2 becomes the smarter choice to save you frustration at the campsite. Ultimately, if you are torn between the two, ask yourself: do I need to hold more stuff securely, or do I just need to stop losing keys? For me, the answer is usually the former, making the Yakima net the essential companion for the road.
No, the Yakima Stretch Net is a passive containment device made of durable webbing that snaps to the crossbar. It does not include a lock cylinder or keyway, so you must rely on the security of your existing basket or add a separate padlock.
No, this system is designed specifically to replace the lock cylinders on compatible Thule products. It will not work on racks from other manufacturers, nor will it convert a standard non-keyed rack into a keyed one.
This is a negligible addition to your overall roof load, making it safe for almost any vehicle roof rating.
Yes, the product description indicates that you can replace the locks in your Thule product in a few easy steps. It involves swapping out the internal lock cylinders rather than requiring complex tools or professional installation.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.