How We Research
We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
If you want a straightforward memory-foam refresh for a Logitech G Pro or G Pro X headset, choose XBERSTAR Replacement Ear Pads; if you need velour cushions that cut outside noise on an Audio Technica ATH-M series monitor, choose GEVO Ear Pads Replacement. These two look similar in a search bar, but they are aimed at different headphones, different materials, and different jobs. One is a bass-focused sponge swap for a gaming headset. The other is a velour comfort-and-isolation pad for studio monitoring. Pick by your headphone model first, then by feel.
• XBERSTAR biggest strength: memory foam pads built specifically for Logitech G Pro / G Pro X, with a football-net cover that the brand says lifts bass performance.
• XBERSTAR biggest trade-off: one pair of pads only, no wipes or extras, and it fits just the Logitech G Pro family — nothing else.
• GEVO biggest strength: velour surface plus high-density memory foam across a long list of Audio Technica ATH-M models, with noise isolation as the headline idea.
• GEVO biggest trade-off: velour feels warmer and needs more care than a wipe-clean surface, and it will not fit Logitech headsets at all.
• Who XBERSTAR is for: Logitech G Pro / G Pro X owners whose stock pads are worn, flaking, or lost.
• Who GEVO is for: Audio Technica ATH-M50x / M40x / M30x / M20x and MSR7 owners who want a softer, more isolating pad for long sessions.
XBERSTAR keeps this one simple. You get a pair of black replacement earpads made with memory foam, sized for the Logitech G Pro and G Pro X. The cover material is described as a football net plus sponge, and the brand's own pitch is that the pad is high-elasticity, durable, soft and comfortable. There is also a specific claim worth noting: the ear cotton is said to improve the bass performance of your headphones. That makes sense for a gaming headset — a tighter seal around the ear usually means more low-end energy reaching your ear instead of leaking away.
Who should skip it? Anyone whose headset is not a Logitech G Pro or G Pro X. The compatibility list is short and specific, and a pad designed for that mounting shape will not do you any favors on a different brand. If you own an Audio Technica monitor, this is simply the wrong product. Also skip it if you specifically want a velour or fabric feel — XBERSTAR's surface is the net-and-sponge type, not a soft textile.
GEVO Ear Pads Replacement: Who It's For
GEVO goes after the studio crowd. The pads are listed as compatible with a broad Audio Technica ATH range: M50, M50X, M50XBT, M40, M40X, M40XFS, M30, M30X, M35, M20X and MSR7. That is a lot of models under one pad, which is handy if you own more than one pair of M-series headphones or you are not sure which revision you have. GEVO does ask you to check your model before buying, and that is fair advice — compatibility is the one thing you cannot fix after the fact.
The material story is the differentiator. These are velour pads over high-density memory foam, and the brand describes the velour as warm and soft, "the comfort of being surrounded." The foam is described as slow-rebound, so it compresses gradually and keeps its shape. GEVO also builds the pads with tight stitching to reduce the chance of them separating or falling off. Noise isolation is the headline feature, and the intended use cases are professional: recording, mixing, broadcasting and live performance. On a monitor headphone, a pad that seals well and keeps outside noise out is genuinely useful, because it lets you hear detail instead of room rumble.
Who should skip it? Logitech owners, obviously, and anyone who wants a slick, wipe-down surface rather than fabric. If you hate warm ears in summer, velour may not be your favorite.
Side-by-Side: Which Should You Choose?
• Best for Logitech G Pro / G Pro X → XBERSTAR Replacement Ear Pads. It is the only one of the two built for that headset.
• Best for Audio Technica ATH-M50x, M40x, M30x, M20x or MSR7 → GEVO Ear Pads Replacement. The fit list is long and explicit.
• Best for bass emphasis on a gaming headset → XBERSTAR. The brand states the pad is meant to improve bass performance.
• Best for noise isolation and studio work → GEVO. Isolation is its core design goal, aimed at mixing, broadcasting and performance.
• Best for a soft, warm, textile feel → GEVO. Velour over slow-rebound memory foam is the softer combination on paper.
• Best for a simple one-pair swap → XBERSTAR. Two pads, nothing else, no fuss.
• Best for extras in the box → GEVO. You get two earpads and two wipe pads, plus a one-year manufacturer warranty.
• Best if you are unsure of your model → check first. Both products are model-specific; the wrong pad will not seat correctly on either headset.
In my opinion, the choice comes down to your headphone, not the pad. If you own a Logitech G Pro or G Pro X, I would buy the XBERSTAR Replacement Ear Pads — they are made for that exact headset, they restore the seal and shape, and the bass-focused design fits how most people use a gaming headset. If you own an Audio Technica ATH-M series monitor, I would buy the GEVO Ear Pads Replacement instead: the velour surface, the long compatibility list and the isolation-first design make it the more sensible pick for mixing, monitoring and long listening sessions. Neither is a universal upgrade, so match the pad to the model you actually have, then check the current price on Amazon before you commit.
FAQ
They are different, not better. Velour is soft and warm and works well for isolation and long studio sessions. The XBERSTAR pads use a net-and-sponge cover with memory foam, which suits a gaming headset and is easier to keep clean.
GEVO is the one built around noise isolation, and it is aimed at recording, mixing and broadcasting where outside noise matters. XBERSTAR's focus is comfort, durability and bass on a Logitech headset.
Check your headphone model name first. Logitech G Pro or G Pro X points to XBERSTAR; any of the listed Audio Technica ATH models points to GEVO. If your model is not on either list, neither pad is the right fit.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.