CONTRACTS THAT CAN BE ENFORCED AND CONTRACTS WHICH CAN’T BE ENFORCED IN INDIA
-By Yashraj Bais (Advocate)
Introduction: All the affairs related to the Contracts and Agreements in India, is widely regulated and dealt according to the statutory provisions of Indian Contract Act, 1872. The Act very explicitly in detail explains the provisions in reference of each and every aspect of the Contracts registered in India, also it clears the ambiguity relating to it’s enforceability and non-enforceability. Now, the reader needs to understand that the enforceability and non-enforceability of a Contract, depends on the validity of the contract in it’s entirety. In simple words a Valid Contract is enforceable by law, whereas an invalid contract is not.
What is a valid contract?
The Section 10 of Indian Contract Act, 1872 gives the essentials of a valid contract, if a contract fulfills the criteria then, there is absolutely no hurdle in it’s enforceability according to law.
They are:
1. Free Consent: The consent of both the parties must be free, that means it should be absolute and un-qualified without any un-due influence, mis-representation, fraud or coercion. If the consent is not free, that the contract is voidable at the option of the either party whose consent is so caused according to Section 19 of the Act.
2. Lawful Consideration: The consideration as defined in Section 2(d) of the act, must be lawful consideration that means justifiable in the eyes of law, if the act or the consideration is un-lawful than the contract is not enforceable and is void-ab-initio.
3. Lawful Object: The object of the Contract must be lawful, that is not debarred or prevented by any law in force in India, if the object is unlawful or violates any law in force in India, then it will not be enforceable according to law.
4. Parties must be competent to Contract: Both the parties must be qualifiedly competent to contract that is to be legally entitled to enter into the Contract. They must of sound mound and must fulfill the criteria of age of majority, according to law of which they are subject to.
Enforceability of Contracts: All the contracts which are in compliance of Section 10 of the Act, are valid in the eyes of law and till not contrary to the same they are enforceable without any hurdle or issue otherwise.
Now, what makes a Contract unenforceable, it is important to understand the same. The conditions which makes a Contract unenforceable are as follows:
1. Lack of Capacity- If the party contracting are in-competent to contract or are in-capable of entering into a contract like minor, however he can only made a party to the contract for benefit, excluding which, such contract is not enforceable.
2. Undue Influence- According to Section 16 of the Act if the consent of either of the party is not free and obtained by undue influence, which means by exercising power, by misusing the apparent authority, by using pressure of un-necessary force on any party to the contract, than such contract is voidable at the option of the either party and thus not enforceable by law.
3. Mis-representation- According to Section 18 of the Act, if either party conceals any material fact from the contracting party, or manipulates any facts or figures which are material and is having direct nexus with the contract, and induces the contracting party to commit such a mistake which is ultimately detrimental in his interest, and makes him to enter into the contract believing that untrue assertion to be true, or positively conceals such a fact which may likely affect the decision of the contracting party is voidable at the option of that aggrieved party. Thus such contracts are also not enforceable.
4. Fraud: If the either party intentionally hides some material facts or fabricates some significant information from the contracting party, or makes any promise without an intention to perform it in order to deceive him or achieve his own vested interest is voidable at the option of the contracting party, whose consent is so obtained. Therefore thus contracts are not enforceable.
5. Illegal Contract_ - If the contract is made for some illegal purpose or by mistake-of -law has violated some law of the land, than under no circumstances that particular contract is enforceable.
CASE LAWS:
1. Sunil Chandra Mishra v. State of Bihar AIR 2016 Pat 47- It was duly held by Hon’ble Patna High Court that under the Rural Franchisee Scheme which was between the consumers and the Electricity Board, which is a bilateral agreement, been mutually agreed upon certain terms and conditions by both the parties. The Electricity Board unilaterally revised the Scheme without taking into confidence the consumers or their representatives, such revision is arbitrary in nature and thus are not enforceable by law.
2. U.N . Automobiles Pvt. Ltd. V. Bank of Baroda, AIR 2016 Raj 41- It was duly held by the Rajasthan High Court that in a hypothecation agreement, the bank was vested with such powers to refer the dispute to arbitration without the consent of the borrower, however it was ruled that a Bank being involved in collecting, investing and lending the funds are well within their rights to carve out the ways and means of settlement of their commercial transactions with their borrowers, there is nothing wrong or unfair in it. Therefore such contract is enforceable.