How We Research
We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
If you want to rescue the fit and seal of your AirPods Pro without buying new earbuds, choose WC TipZ; if you need to bring a worn-out pair of JBL Live 500BT over-ear headphones back to life, choose Sumugaric Live 500BT.
That's the short version. The longer version matters, though, because these two products get lumped together under the same search phrase — memory foam over ear — even though they solve completely different problems for completely different people. One is a set of foam tips for in-ear buds. The other is a set of replacement cushions for a full-size wireless headphone. If you don't sort that out before you buy, you'll end up with the wrong part in your hand and a return label in your future.
So let's sort it out properly.
• WC TipZ — biggest strength: Memory foam tips built specifically for the Apple AirPods Pro and AirPods Pro 2, with the improved foam rebound and tighter seal that silicone tips often can't hold onto during long listening sessions.
• WC TipZ — biggest trade-off: It only fits the AirPods Pro and AirPods Pro 2. It does not fit AirPods Pro 3, and it does not fit any other AirPods model at all.
• Sumugaric Live 500BT — biggest strength: A two-piece replacement cushion set in memory foam with a faux leather cover, made specifically to fit JBL Live 500BT and Live 500BTNC over-ear headphones.
• Sumugaric Live 500BT — biggest trade-off: It's a repair part, not a headphone. You need to already own the JBL Live 500BT to get any use out of it.
• WC TipZ is for you if you own AirPods Pro or AirPods Pro 2 and the stock silicone tips keep slipping, aching, or losing their seal.
• Sumugaric Live 500BT is for you if your JBL Live 500BT pads have flattened, cracked, or started flaking and you'd rather replace the cushions than the whole headphone.
WC TipZ is a comfort and fit upgrade for one specific earbud. It's a three-size kit — one pair of Small, one pair of Medium, one pair of Large — so you're not gambling on a single size and hoping it lands. You get instructions in the box, which matters more than it sounds like it should, because foam tips go in differently than silicone ones. The whole thing is designed to seat ergonomically and stay put longer, and the foam rebound is tuned so the tip recovers its shape between wears instead of collapsing into a lump after a week.
Who should skip it? Anyone who doesn't own an AirPods Pro or AirPods Pro 2. That's not a soft warning. It's the single most important line on the whole product: these tips are built for those two models only, they won't fit any other AirPods earbuds, and they don't fit the AirPods Pro 3. If you're on any other model, this is not the product you're looking for, and no amount of squeezing will change that. Skip it too if you've never had a problem with your stock silicone tips — you'd be spending money to solve something that isn't bothering you.
One more thing worth knowing: the brand donates 10% of profits to a different charity each month. That's not why you'd buy a set of ear tips, but it's a nice detail to have in the back of your mind.
Sumugaric Live 500BT: Who It's For
Sumugaric Live 500BT is a repair part, and it should be judged as one. It's a pair of replacement ear cushions — two of them in the package — designed to be compatible with the JBL Live 500BT and the Live 500BTNC wireless over-ear headphones. The headphones themselves are not included. You're buying the cushions only, and that's the entire point: if the rest of your JBL headphone still works fine, replacing the pads is a far more sensible move than replacing the headphone.
The cushions use memory foam under a faux leather cover, which is the combination most people actually want on an over-ear. The foam gives you the soft, conforming pressure distribution across the ear, and the faux leather cover keeps it durable and easy to wipe down. The listed color is red, so this is a visible change, not a stealth one — worth checking against your taste before you commit. Installation is described as straightforward, and the pads are meant to fit snugly around the ear so long listening sessions don't turn into a pressure headache.
Here's the honest trade-off. This product is only useful to a narrow group: people who own JBL Live 500BT or Live 500BTNC headphones. If you own any other brand or model, it does nothing for you. It also won't change how your headphones sound in any dramatic way — it restores comfort and brings back a proper seal, which can absolutely improve what you're hearing, but it isn't a sound upgrade in a box. And if your headphone's actual problem is a dead battery, a snapped hinge, or a failed Bluetooth connection, new cushions won't touch any of that. There's a one-year warranty listed, which is a reasonable safety net for a wear-and-tear item.
Who should buy it? Someone with a working JBL Live 500BT whose pads are flat, cracked, flaking, or just uncomfortable after an hour. That's the whole audience, and for that audience it's a very direct solution.
• Best for AirPods Pro owners chasing a tighter seal → WC TipZ. Foam molding to the ear canal is the whole reason this product exists.
• Best for reviving a pair of JBL Live 500BT headphones → Sumugaric Live 500BT. It's a targeted replacement part for that specific model.
• Best for fit flexibility → WC TipZ. Three sizes in the box (Small, Medium, Large) means you can actually dial in each ear.
• Best for long listening sessions on a full-size headphone → Sumugaric Live 500BT. Over-ear memory foam with a faux leather cover spreads pressure across the ear instead of pressing on it.
• Best for easy installation → Sumugaric Live 500BT. A two-piece cushion swap is about as simple as headphone maintenance gets.
• Best for travel and charging-case convenience → WC TipZ. The tips are designed to stay on and fit inside the charging case.
• Best if you don't want to think about compatibility → neither, unless you check first. WC TipZ is AirPods Pro and AirPods Pro 2 only; Sumugaric is JBL Live 500BT and 500BTNC only.
• Best small upgrade with a charitable angle → WC TipZ. The brand gives 10% of profits to a different charity each month.
If I had to pick one, I'd buy the WC TipZ — but only because I'm assuming you're an AirPods Pro or AirPods Pro 2 owner reading this. In my opinion, foam tips are one of the highest-impact, lowest-effort changes you can make to earbuds you already like, and the three-size kit plus case compatibility makes it a genuinely practical purchase rather than a fiddly one.
If you own a JBL Live 500BT, flip that entirely. The Sumugaric Live 500BT is the right call, and replacing worn cushions instead of worn headphones is just good sense. Check the current price on Amazon before you commit to either — the page has a button for that — since what's worth it to you depends on what you're paying.
FAQ
You can, but it's not ideal. Over-ear headphones are built for upright listening, and lying on one side presses the cushion into your ear and the headband into your head. If you specifically want something for sleep, in-ear foam tips like the WC TipZ are the more sensible route, since they don't get crushed against a pillow.
how to wear over ear headphones
Slide the headband over the top of your head with the cushions sitting flat against your ears, then adjust the sliders on each side until the band rests comfortably without pressing down. The cushions should surround your ears, not sit on top of them. If the seal feels loose, that's usually a sign the pads are worn — which is exactly what the Sumugaric replacement cushions address.
how to wear over ear headphones properly
Properly means the ear sits fully inside the cushion opening, the band is centered and not tilted, and there's even pressure on both sides. If one side feels tighter, adjust that slider. For in-ear foam tips, it's the opposite idea: compress the foam, insert, and let it expand to fill the canal — which is what the WC TipZ memory foam is designed to do.
how should over ear headphones fit
Snug but not tight. You want the cushions to seal around the ear without clamping, and you should be able to wear them for a couple of hours without soreness at the top of your head or around your ears. If your current pads have gone flat and the fit has loosened up, new memory foam cushions will bring that seal back.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.
See also: BLLQ Memory Foam Ear vs BEXILOR Ear Plugs: Noise Isolating, Boytond AI Translation Earbuds vs Yechiry Over Ear Headphones, YunYiYi MDR-M1 vs Generic Computer Headphone Hanger/over-ear