How We Research
We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
If you want a thicker, more durable memory foam pad built specifically for the Sony WH-1000XM5, choose WC PadZ XM5; if you need memory foam over-ear replacement pads for a pair of Skullcandy Crusher, Hesh3 or Venue headphones, choose Hmoke Replacement Ear Pads. These two products don't really compete for the same buyer — they compete for the same need: bringing a tired pair of over-ear headphones back to life with fresh memory foam cushions. The catch is that each one only fits a specific family of headphones, so the compatibility question decides this comparison before comfort or materials even enter the picture.
• WC PadZ XM5 — biggest strength: extra-thick memory foam paired with a softer PU leather, plus reinforced seams (extra stitching and glue) aimed at the two classic failure points of worn-out pads — flat, mashed foam and splitting seams.
• WC PadZ XM5 — biggest trade-off: it fits the Sony WH-1000XM5 only. The manufacturer explicitly states it will not fit the XM6 or any other Sony model, so it's useless if you own anything else.
• Hmoke Replacement Ear Pads — biggest strength: high-density slow-rebound memory foam in a soft protein leather cover, with a plastic removal tool included so the swap takes minutes and needs no special skills.
• Hmoke Replacement Ear Pads — biggest trade-off: its compatibility list is narrow in a different direction — it's built for Skullcandy Crusher Wireless ANC/Evo/540, Hesh3/ANC/Evo and Venue ANC over-ear models, nothing else.
• Who each pick is for: WC PadZ XM5 is for Sony WH-1000XM5 owners who want maximum thickness and long-term durability; Hmoke is for Skullcandy owners who want an easy, no-fuss refresh on a budget-friendly pair of headphones.
The WC PadZ XM5 is a complete replacement ear cushion kit made by Wicked Cushions for one headphone and one headphone only: the Sony WH-1000XM5. Everything about the design points at the specific complaints XM5 owners tend to have after a year or two of daily use. The foam is memory foam, the cover is a new, softer grade of PU leather, and the pads are deliberately thicker than stock so your ears don't press against the drivers. That last point matters more than it sounds — when pads flatten, your ear sits closer to the driver housing, which is exactly when comfort drops off and the seal starts leaking.
Who should buy it: Sony WH-1000XM5 owners who wear their headphones for hours at a time, want the extra thickness, and care about a pad that holds its shape instead of collapsing in a few months. Who should skip it: anyone with an XM6, an XM4, a Bose, a Skullcandy, or literally any other model. The fit list is one entry long. If your headphones aren't the WH-1000XM5, this product simply isn't for you — no amount of spec appeal changes that.
Hmoke Replacement Ear Pads: Who It's For
The Hmoke pads take a different route. They're replacement cushions for a spread of Skullcandy over-ear models — Crusher Wireless ANC/Evo/540, Hesh3/ANC/Evo, and Venue ANC. The material spec is high-density slow-rebound memory foam wrapped in soft protein leather, which is the same broad recipe most decent aftermarket pads use: it conforms to the shape of your ear rather than pushing back against it, and it's designed to stay comfortable over long sessions without the swelling or pressure pain that worn pads cause.
What stands out in the feature set is the installation support. Hmoke includes a small plastic tool to pry off the old pads and seat the new ones, and the company says the job takes a few minutes with no special tools required. That's a genuinely useful detail if you've never replaced pads before, because the fear of breaking a plastic mounting ring is what stops most people from trying. Hmoke also positions this as a cosmetic and functional refresh — same fit as the originals, new look, new feel — which is the honest framing for any replacement pad.
Who should buy it: Skullcandy Crusher, Hesh3 or Venue ANC owners whose stock pads are flattened, peeling or uncomfortable, and who want a straightforward swap with a removal tool in the box. Who should skip it: Sony owners, and anyone whose headphone model isn't on that list. Hmoke explicitly asks buyers to confirm their model before ordering, and that's the right instinct — a pad that doesn't clip in properly is worthless no matter how good the foam is. The 1-year manufacturer warranty covers you if something goes wrong.
• Best for Sony WH-1000XM5 owners → WC PadZ XM5. It's the only one of the two that fits that headphone.
• Best for Skullcandy Crusher / Hesh3 / Venue ANC owners → Hmoke Replacement Ear Pads. Same logic in reverse.
• Best for maximum thickness and ear-to-driver clearance → WC PadZ XM5. The pads are intentionally thicker to stop your ears mashing into the drivers.
• Best for seam durability → WC PadZ XM5. Extra stitching plus glue reinforcement targets the splitting-seam failure directly.
• Best for an easier first-time install → Hmoke Replacement Ear Pads. The included plastic removal tool removes the riskiest step of the job.
• Best for long-session comfort → a tie. Both use memory foam and a soft leather cover; WC leans on thickness, Hmoke leans on slow-rebound density.
• Best for noise isolation via fit → WC PadZ XM5. Thicker foam that conforms and seals is the mechanism it's designed around.
• Best warranty coverage → WC PadZ XM5 on paper, with a 365-day full warranty versus Hmoke's 1-year manufacturer warranty — close enough that fit should decide it, not the warranty.
In my opinion, the right pick here is decided entirely by which headphones you own, not by which pad is "better." If you have a Sony WH-1000XM5, I'd buy the WC PadZ XM5 — the extra thickness, the softer leather and the reinforced seams address the exact ways XM5 pads wear out, and the 365-day warranty backs it. If you have a Skullcandy Crusher, Hesh3 or Venue ANC, I'd buy the Hmoke pads — the tool-included install and slow-rebound foam make it a clean, low-stress refresh. Neither is a universal upgrade. Check your model number first, then check the current price on Amazon before you commit.
FAQ
can you sleep with over ear headphones
how to wear over ear headphones
Put them on so the headband sits on the crown of your head and each pad fully covers an ear, with the pad's opening centered over your ear canal rather than pinched against it. Both pads here are designed to conform around the ear, so give the memory foam a second to settle before you judge the fit. Don't stretch the headband outward to force them on.
how to wear over ear headphones properly
Properly means the pads seal against your head all the way around with no gaps at the top or bottom. That seal is what makes memory foam do its job — WC PadZ XM5 relies on thickness to hold the seal, and the Hmoke pads rely on slow-rebound foam that shapes to your ear. Adjust the sliders evenly on both sides so the pressure is balanced.
how should over ear headphones fit
They should feel snug but not clamping — firm enough to stay put when you move your head, loose enough that you can wear them for a couple of hours without pressure pain. If your current pads feel tight or your ears touch the driver, that's usually flattened foam, not a bad headphone. Replacing worn pads restores the original fit.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.
See also: MMUSS Sleep vs Loluka Black Invisible Earbuds, Plantronics vs PLT Plantronics: Wireless Headset, Lavince Sleeping Headphones vs MMWOWARTS Hybrid Active Noise, Conambo Trucker vs EKSA H3: Bluetooth Noise Cancelling