Some say that sports spectatorship is a civil religion, where hardcore supporters consecrate their favorite athletes, such as Derek Jeter, Kobe Bryant, Lionel Messi, Brett Favre, and Serena Williams, and canonize their teams’ success and achievements into scripture. Opposing teams are pilloried and their failures, certainly against our favorite teams, are readily derided. Losses are forgotten, treated as ignominy, or worse, compared to sin.
As a baseball fan, I am no stranger to this. At Yankee Stadium, I would join my fellow congregants in the navy blue colored pews praising every run scored by our team or every strikeout our pitchers would make. Between beers, supposedly the blood of Mickey Mantle, we have a proclivity of retelling stories about the late 1990s, when the New York Yankees won 4 World Series titles in 5 years, but would agree in unison, as if by commandment, that the 2004 AL Championship Series did not exist. We would demonize the Boston Red Sox, the Mets, and recently, the Houston Astros, regardless of the game’s opponent that night or the outcome. Ask Jose Altuve.
But in sports, beyond the pantheon of success and glory, there are lessons to be learned, a fact that fans often forget amid their raucous piety.
Sports are beyond achievements or individual achievements.
Sports are more than just success, but the acknowledgement of adversity.
Sports are about overcoming the self.
And in 2022, when the Yankees surged into the season with the pace to become the winningest team in modern baseball, and Aaron Judge defied reality with his home run count, I nearly lost sight of all that.
In September of that year, after having learned dragon boat steering for several months, I was competing for the first time. To steer a dragon boat means to keep the boat in its intended path, to mitigate the effects of wind or current, using a large wooden oar.
On a sunny afternoon in Long Island, with the water a crisp blue, I was about to steer my last race of the day. In a set of three races, with the first two being qualifiers, the last race was a “win or go home.” Translated in the language of sports fans, I understood that to be: “I gotta win this thing.”
My paddlers did a heck of a job the first two races. They surged ahead of the others with an unbridled passion ripping through their veins like a stormy current. I had kept my boat more or less on a straight course, but trusted that I could have done better. When the announcement came that the final race, which we qualified for, was a “win or go home” for us, I was transforming from a pious sports fan into a bona fide athlete.
Emotions rushed me with hurricane force energy. I gazed at the tent where my teammates huddled in, the space packing them as tightly as a rush hour subway train (before pandemic). This was a team of people I had practiced with, hung out with, dined with, and laughed with for three months. They had been more than teammates, but a second family, especially one led by a couple who jokingly refer to themselves as “mom and dad” of the team. “Win or go home” became a personal mandate: I had to steer ourselves into winning the final race.
As I walked up the docks for a third time, the wooden planks yawned and sighed as other teams returned: some in glory, some exhausted. The mounting pressure that I put on myself did not abate as the tired teams came back onto shore, even as I tried to reassure myself with a tune, or by steering into position to begin the race. And then the horn blew.
As an incarnation of a mythical creature, the twenty paddlers on our boat wrestled the water in rhythmic unison with their paddles. From head to toe, drummer in the front to steerer in the back, this “dragon” had one soul: the determination to win together. If I had the ability to face them, I would have seen twenty determined faces. Sure enough, the paddlers on my boat paddled with that collective mindset, as they propelled out of our start position, as though a piston was fired.
All went well, until I blew it. I lost control. I could not control the boat and allowed it to drift out of position to the left, coming dangerously close to the boat on the left. Frantically, to avert disaster, I overcompensated by steering to the right. The boat ended up going too far to the right. It all came about as a blur to me, until we drifted away from the course itself. I blew it. Hard. I became Mariano Rivera of the 2001 World Series (or Matt Ryan during the Super Bowl for football fans). I “choked.”
When we finally returned to shore, I trailed behind along the docks, plodding over its wooden boards in a walk of shame. I could not believe what happened. Neither did the teammates who I had just let down. I could not face them, even when they tried to console me or tried to defend me in front of the race officials.
Moments later, as I stared blankly and wondered what happened, the team’s other boat marched out to shore. Less than one minute after the horn sounded, they charged downwater and beat the next boat by at least half a boat’s length, apparently having been motivated to win even more after witnessing my predicament. Without a doubt, they were the rightful possessors of gold, a marked improvement over the previous year’s silver. I shared their glory, but as a witness, no different from my spectatorship of a certain baseball team in the Bronx, only eclipsed by my failure, something I, as a spectator, would find unacceptable.
My mistake continued to play in my head in the ensuing days. I became despondent, ashamed of what happened. I withdrew from my teammates, the coach, the manager, and even myself, in penance. I understood about “chokes” from watching sports, but had not ever, on the big stage, flop on epic proportions. At one point, I thought about hanging up my boating shoes: unable to continue any further under the burden of my flaw.
But failure is what makes an athlete.
Athletes thrive, but also fail. We cannot define success without first defining failure. And athletes, like other humans, from Achilles to Matt Ryan, are prone to mistakes, some more fatal than others. It is from the humility of having failed are we able to recollect ourselves from the ashes and rebuild into someone and something stronger.
True, I cost the team. But by focusing solely on MY failure, I had overlooked the achievements of MY PADDLERS who paddled like an unleashed demon (or dragon). I had overlooked that MY TEAM went to advocate and defend for me, a litigator, in a classic game of role reversal. I had overlooked that MY TEAM, in the companion boat, was turbocharged to win to make up for what happened, and defied all the odds. And what a disservice to the coach and manager it would have been for me to call it quits then, just because I could not resolve a question of my game-time EQ. This is not about ME. This is about dragon boating, where every summer we all turn the mythological dragon into corporeal reality.
That final race was one of pride immediately and certainly not when measured in terms of results. It was instead a humbling experience that I could not find as a sports fan, where success is premised upon concrete results. Instead, I have come to derive pride by understanding success in a different way, one premised on adversity and how one (or one’s team) overcomes that. And regardless of what happened, VAX Dragon Boat has been successful in growing together to overcome hardship together.
Over the next few months, I became clairvoyant about returning to the sport. I had gotten over my “choke job,” even poking fun of the incident as self-medicated mental anesthesia, if you will. I returned this year, picking up the steering oar where I left off in September. At each practice in 2023, it has been a constant pattern of making improvements and exploring new techniques and simulating different race situations. But returning to the sport this season is not about atoning for my mistake at the Port Jefferson race, rather it is about truly embracing what it means to be an athlete, to wit, a “VAXthlete,” going beyond the self for a better purpose.
And it’s okay to mess up.
You don’t have to be like Aaron Judge, Naomi Osaka, Patrick Mahomes, Stephen Curry.
You don’t have to be great.
Just do your part. Just be you.
But know you are on a team. Know that your team has your back.
Just learn from your mistakes and keep looking forward.
And “take it away.”