Original Facebook Posts / Aug 2014 / THE HOLY GHOST RECEPTION COMMITTEE #9

Previous

Next

UNDER APPRECIATED ROCK BAND OF MONTH FOR AUGUST 2014: THE HOLY GHOST RECEPTION COMMITTEE #9

One glance at the above album cover for Saved proves beyond doubt that Bob Dylan was serious with his Christian period. The songs were serious as well: “Covenant Woman”, “Pressing On”, “Saving Grace”, “Are You Ready”, etc. The opening track, “A Satisfied Mind” is a rare cover by Dylan of someone else’s song; “A Satisfied Mind” dates from the mid-1950’s and was first recorded by Porter Wagoner. (Interestingly, the debut solo album by folksinger Hamilton Camp, Paths of Victory – which, at the insistence of Elektra Records, has seven covers of mostly obscure Bob Dylan songs – also includes a cover of “A Satisfied Mind”). The album art is by a veteran in that field, Tony Wright; two of his designs – for Traffic’s The Low Spark of High Heeled Boys (1971) and Steve Winwood’s Arc of a Diver (1980) – were named among the 100 Greatest Album Covers by Rolling Stone magazine.

In order to downplay the Christian message in the Saved album (if that’s possible), the cover painting was later replaced with a painting of Dylan in performance.

Saved was the middle album of Dylan’s so-called Christian trilogy (the three albums were released within a two-year period); but really (as is usual with Dylan), it wasn’t quite that simple.

* * *

For one thing, Bob Dylan often used Biblical imagery in his songs. One obvious example is one of his loveliest songs, “Knockin’ on Heaven’s Door”, which is taken from the soundtrack album, Pat Garrett & Billy the Kid (1973). On his very first album, Bob Dylan (1962), the first song on Side 2 is “Gospel Plow”.

The title song on Highway 61 Revisited (1965) – the album which includes Dylan's signature song “Like a Rolling Stone” – includes a novel take on the Biblical story of Abraham, when God told him to kill his newborn, long-promised son Isaac. I had no idea what the album title meant, really, until I moved to Mississippi and found that U.S. Highway 61 runs through the heart of the Delta Blues country. (The city of Brookhaven, MS, where I first lived and worked, is located on U.S. Highway 51, and I also knew about a more obscure song by Bob Dylan called “Highway 51” on his debut album, Bob Dylan). Here are the lyrics for the first verse of “Highway 61 Revisited”:

Oh God said to Abraham, “Kill me a son”

Abe says, “Man, you must be puttin’ me on”

God say, “No.” Abe say, “What?”

God say, “You can do what you want Abe, but

The next time you see me comin’ you better run”

Well Abe says, “Where do you want this killin’ done?”

God says, “Out on Highway 61”

In the late 1970’s though, Dylan’s music went beyond imagery into true belief.

* * *

The best known of Bob Dylan’s Christian albums was the previous album Slow Train Coming, which produced the hit song “Gotta Serve Somebody”, the topical song “Slow Train” (relatively rare by this point in Dylan’s career) and the charming children’s song “Man Gave Names to All the Animals” – this one ends abruptly before naming the snake (and Dylan later verified that he meant the one in the Garden of Eden). But several of the songs didn’t pull any punches or seek shelter in allegory, notably “Precious Angel”, “When You Gonna Wake Up”, and “When He Returns”.

Following Saved, Shot of Love reintroduced secular themes into his music; but “Property of Jesus” is the center song on the first side. Additionally, Infidels was viewed as a return to the “old” Bob Dylan by most; however, the title clearly has religious connotations – and might even represent a dagger toward his critics. “Man of Peace” on this album – as in, “sometimes Satan comes as a man of peace” – could easily have fit onto one of the earlier albums.

Wikipedia says that “Infidels is seen as his return to secular music, following a conversion to Christianity, three evangelical gospel records, and a subsequent return to a secular, culturally Jewish lifestyle” (whatever that is supposed to mean).

* * *

Bob Dylan’s Christian hit song “Gotta Serve Somebody” is a litany of people in various fields and various places in their lives who have to make that choice. In this song, Dylan shows that he hasn’t lost his sense of humor: In the final verse, he lists names instead, including two of his own nicknames – “You may call me Bobby, you may call me Zimmy” (taken from his original surname Zimmerman) – and then two from a comedy shtick of the day – “You may call me R.J., you may call me Ray” – that is, the character Ray J. Johnson, Jr. that was created by Bill Saluga.

But this is no easy theology. The chorus of this song includes the lines, “Well, it may be the Devil, or it may be the Lord / But you’re gonna have to serve somebody”.

One of the verses in another song on the album, “Precious Angel” seems to echo the dialogue between Jesus and the Samaritan woman at the well; it lays it out in no uncertain terms:

Sister, lemme tell you about a vision I saw

You were drawing water for your husband, you were suffering under the law

You were telling him about Buddha, you were telling him about Mohammed

in the same breath

You never mentioned one time the Man who came and died a criminal’s death

* * *

Trying to uncover what was behind this dramatic change in Bob Dylan’s music was hard enough to figure out at the time, and there are several competing stories on the Internet from people who often seem to have an agenda. There is a film out there called Inside Bob Dylan’s Jesus Years: Busy Being Born Again, books such as Restless Pilgrim: The Spiritual Journey of Bob Dylan, and numerous magazine articles.

By all accounts, however, Bob Dylan has never renounced his “born again” Christian conversion, despite numerous reports that obliquely suggest otherwise. Dylan is well known for producing less than consistent quotes over the years, and that has only added to the confusion.

For instance, in Wikipedia, Dylan is quoted in 1984 as distancing himself from the “born again” label: “I’ve never said I’m born again. That’s just a media term. I don’t think I’ve been an agnostic. I’ve always thought there’s a superior power, that this is not the real world and that there’s a world to come.”

In a 1984 interview, Bob Dylan says: “The songs that I wrote for the Slow Train album [frightened me] . . . I didn’t plan to write them . . . I didn’t like writing them. I didn’t want to write them.”

Wikipedia highlights another Dylan quote from 1997: “Here’s the thing with me and the religious thing. This is the flat-out truth: I find the religiosity and philosophy in the music. I don’t find it anywhere else. Songs like ‘Let Me Rest on a Peaceful Mountain’ or ‘I Saw the Light’ — that’s my religion. I don’t adhere to rabbis, preachers, evangelists, all of that. I’ve learned more from the songs than I’ve learned from any of this kind of entity. The songs are my lexicon. I believe the songs.”

* * *

Bob Dylan was still a polarizing figure in the late 1970’s, and Slow Train Coming alienated at least as many fans as it attracted. Still, in its first year, the album outsold two of Dylan’s best albums, Blonde on Blonde and Blood on the Tracks in their first years; and “Gotta Serve Somebody” was a #24 hit single – his highest placement in the Billboard Hot 100 since “Knockin’ on Heaven’s Door” in 1973.

Since 2012 marked the 50th anniversary of the release of Bob Dylan’s first album, Bob Dylan, a re-examination of his multi-faceted career was taking place. Al Kasha, who takes credit for leading Dylan to Jesus, is a Messianic Jew (and that might be the best way to describe Dylan himself actually). He knew Dylan from his earliest days at Columbia Records, where he was their youngest record producer in 1960. On the blog Godreports, Kasha remarks that Dylan wrote the songs on Slow Train Coming at Kasha’s Beverly Hills home. Al Kasha also discusses Dylan’s 2012 album, Tempest (his most recent studio album): “I am absolutely thrilled that Bob has shown through this new record that he has never lost God’s calling in life. He’s never given up. I get upset when people think that he has because you don’t write all these songs just out there. It takes time to write them and they’re all about Christ, so I’ve said this in the past — the media has hurt rather than helped him.”

* * *

Bob Dylan has also released a Christmas album, Christmas in the Heart. Wikipedia mentions a 2009 interview with Bill Flanagan when he was promoting the album: “Flanagan commented on the ‘heroic performance’ Dylan gave of ‘O Little Town of Bethlehem’ and that he ‘delivered the song like a true believer’. Dylan replied: ‘Well, I am a true believer.’”

* * *

One clue to what was happening with Bob Dylan occurred about six months before Slow Train Coming was released in November 1979; as reported by Wikipedia: “Before the album was completed, Patty Valentine [who is mentioned by name several times during the song] had brought a defamation-of-character suit against Dylan, regarding the song ‘Hurricane’ from Desire; on May 22, [1979,] while giving a pre-trial deposition in his defense, Dylan was asked about his wealth. ‘You mean my treasure on earth?’ replied Dylan. He was asked about the identity of the ‘fool’ in ‘Hurricane’. Dylan said the ‘fool’ was ‘whoever Satan gave power to . . . whoever was blind to the truth and was living by his own truth.’ Five days later, Dylan’s pre-trial statement was reported in the Washington Post, which also interviewed Kenn Gulliksen, who revealed to the paper that Dylan had joined the Vineyard Christian Fellowship.”

Wikipedia mentions that the organization now known as the Association of Vineyard Churches (which was founded by Gulliksen) was formed in part by Christian contemporary music pioneers that I mentioned in my last post: “The first local church started when Kenn Gulliksen brought together two Bible studies, both meeting at the houses of singer/songwriters: Larry Norman and Chuck Girard [a founder of early CCM band Love Song]. In early 1975, thirteen groups met at the Beverly Hills Women’s Club. These Bible studies, and others like them, were attended by many popular actors/actresses and musicians including Bob Dylan.” Dylan also attended the Calvary Chapel discipleship courses in Southern California.

* * *

Bob Dylan himself reports that someone threw a silver cross on the stage during a concert in San Diego in November 1978, leading directly to his conversion to Christ. It was much more dramatic than I had ever imagined. Again, from Wikipedia, Dylan recalls in a 1979 interview: “‘Towards the end of the show someone out in the crowd . . . knew I wasn’t feeling too well. I think they could see that. And they threw a silver cross on the stage. Now usually I don’t pick things up in front of the stage. Once in a while I do. Sometimes I don’t. But I looked down at that cross. I said, “I gotta pick that up.” So I picked up the cross and I put it in my pocket. . . . And I brought it backstage and I brought it with me to the next town, which was out in Arizona. . . . I was feeling even worse than I’d felt when I was in San Diego. I said, “Well, I need something tonight.” I didn’t know what it was. I was used to all kinds of things. I said, “I need something tonight that I didn’t have before.” And I looked in my pocket and I had this cross.’

“Dylan believed he had experienced a vision of Christ in his Tucson hotel room. ‘Jesus did appear to me as King of Kings, and Lord of Lords,’ he’d later say. ‘There was a presence in the room that couldn’t have been anybody but Jesus. . . . Jesus put his hand on me. It was a physical thing. I felt it. I felt it all over me. I felt my whole body tremble. The glory of the Lord knocked me down and picked me up.’

“[Clinton] Heylin writes that ‘his state of mind may well have made him susceptible to such an experience. Lacking a sense of purpose in his personal life since the collapse of his marriage, he came to believe that, when Jesus revealed Himself, He quite literally rescued him from an early grave.’

“‘[Dylan’s] conversion wasn’t one of those things that happens when an alcoholic goes to Alcoholics Anonymous,’ David Mansfield, one of Dylan’s band members and fellow born-again Christian, would later say. ‘The simplest explanation is that he had a very profound experience which answered certain lifelong issues for him.’ . . .

“Dylan wasn’t alone in his religious awakening. Band members Steven Soles and David Mansfield had already joined the Vineyard [Christian] Fellowship, a Christian organization introduced to them by T-Bone Burnett. Helena Springs, one of the singers in the band, was brought up Christian and still practiced her faith. Dylan was also romantically linked with Mary Alice Artes; raised as a Christian, she had strayed from her faith only to return to it after joining the Vineyard Fellowship (without the influence of Burnett, Soles, or Mansfield).”

* * *

Wikipedia also reports that for the past 20 years, Bob Dylan has been a supporter of Chabad Lubavitch movement, a prominent Orthodox Jewish group that I remember well from my days in New York in the early 1990’s for their subway ads reminding riders of upcoming Jewish holidays and festivals. Dylan has also participated in the Bar Mitzvahs of his sons and attended other Jewish services over the years.

* * *

Returning to the albums, Slow Train Coming and the albums that followed it are notable for the all-star assistance that Dylan received in putting them together. Bob Dylan heard the Dire Straits hit single “Sultans of Swing” and contacted guitarist and lead vocalist Mark Knopfler about working on an album together.

Dylan also asked Jerry Wexler to produce the record; a genuine legend in the recording industry, he is the man who coined the term “rhythm and blues”. Wexler recalls the encounter (as taken from Wikipedia): “Naturally, I wanted to do the album in Muscle Shoals — as Bob did — but we decided to prep it in L.A., where Bob lived. That’s when I learned what the songs were about: born-again Christians in the old corral. . . . I liked the irony of Bob coming to me, the Wandering Jew, to get the Jesus feel. . . . [But] I had no idea he was on this born-again Christian trip until he started to evangelize me. I said, ‘Bob, you’re dealing with a sixty-two-year-old confirmed Jewish atheist. I’m hopeless. Let’s just make an album.’”

For Shot of Love, other players include ex-Beatle Ringo Starr on drums, current Rolling Stone Ronnie Wood on guitar, bass guitarist Donald “Duck” Dunn – formerly of Booker T and the MG’s and also the Blues Brothers Band – and veteran sessionman Danny “Kootch” Kortchmar on guitar and electric guitar. Bumps Blackwell, who produced most of Little Richard’s most indelible songs, produced the title song “Shot of Love”.

Infidels marked a change in musical direction with the addition of Jamaican rhythm section Sly & Robbie; Mark Knopfler returned for that album, and the personnel also included Mick Taylor, who was a bandmember in the Rolling Stones from 1969 to 1974.

* * *

For a time, Bob Dylan only sang his gospel songs in concert; he was often heckled, but that certainly wasn’t the first time that happened to him. When his older material was brought back into the performances, there were changes in the lyrics in some cases. In “Tangled up in Blue”, the mysterious woman who originally quoted “an Italian poet from the 13th Century” began quoting from the Bible; sometimes it was the Book of Matthew, but eventually Dylan settled on Jeremiah 31:31 – “Behold, the days come, sayeth the Lord, that I will make a new covenant with the house of Israel, and with the house of Judah.” This Biblical quotation was included in the liner notes for Saved.

Another time (from Wikipedia), Dylan connected up some of his early songs with the Second Coming: “You know we’re living in the end times. . . . The scriptures say, ‘In the last days, perilous times shall be at hand. Men shall become lovers of their own selves. Blasphemous, heavy and highminded.’ . . . Take a look at the Middle East. We’re heading for a war. . . . I told you ‘The Times They Are A-Changin’’ and they did. I said the answer was ‘Blowin’ in the Wind’, and it was. I’m telling you now Jesus is coming back, and He is! And there is no other way of salvation. . . . Jesus is coming back to set up His Kingdom in Jerusalem for a thousand years.”

* * *

There was a noticeable dip in the ratings given by rock critics of Bob Dylan’s Christian recordings. That was not true so much for Slow Train Coming – Robert Christgau of The Village Voice gave the album a B+ and wrote: “The lyrics are indifferently crafted. Nevertheless, this is his best album since Blood on the Tracks. The singing is passionate and detailed.” Allmusic and Rolling Stone both rated the album ***.

For Saved, the Rolling Stone rating stood, but Allmusic gave the album only **, and Christgau scored it as C+. Entertainment Weekly showed a C–. Shot of Love had ** from both Rolling Stone and Allmusic; Christgau and Entertainment Weekly showed B–.

With Infidels though, all was forgiven: Rolling Stone and Allmusic were both at ****.

* * *

To put these ratings in context, Self Portrait (1970) is the only Bob Dylan album to get just ** before Saved, other than some live albums (Allmusic shows low ratings for most of the Rolling Stones live albums also). To this day, no one seems to understand Self Portrait – I certainly don’t. The music seems as off-putting as the splashes of color in the cover art. The first few times I played it, I really only enjoyed the live version of “Like a Rolling Stone”; I have heard several others since that I enjoy more. Some years later, the opening track “All the Tired Horses” stood out, but probably only because I couldn’t discern a hint of Bob Dylan anywhere in the song.

* * *

There is a Bob Dylan album that scores even lower in Allmusic, and here I need to put on my “Under Appreciated” hat – the 1973 release Dylan yields just *. Allmusic mentions that this LP is “[c]ommonly regarded as the worst album in Bob Dylan’s catalog”. The album is described in both Rolling Stone Record Guide and Allmusic as a collection of outtakes from Self Portrait – i.e., songs that didn’t make the cut for that head-scratcher – and that just sent chills up my spine. As I recall, it was also the last release on Columbia Records before Bob Dylan jumped ship to Asylum Records; and record companies are often spiteful in such cases, untold millions of dollars of earnings for the corporation notwithstanding.

Dylan is a recent rescue from Katrina, however, and I found it surprisingly easy to listen to. The album is entirely cover songs, many of them quite familiar; and if Dylan’s performance of Joni Mitchell’s “Big Yellow Taxi” leaves no impression at all, that is not true of the lesser-known songs.

The opening track, a traditional folk song called “Lily of the West” is beautifully performed; and the album is well worth owning for that song alone. Personally, I am at least as big a fan of Bob Dylan as a folksinger as I am of Bob Dylan as a rocker, and this song was a welcome return to the performances that I remember so well from his early albums and bootleg albums.

* * *

Some of the criticism of Dylan’s Christian albums is quite harsh. Wikipedia mentions: “Critic Charles Shaar Murray wrote, ‘Bob Dylan has never seemed more perfect and more impressive than on this album. He has also never seemed more unpleasant and hate-filled.’ Greil Marcus wrote, ‘Dylan’s received truths never threaten the unbeliever, they only chill the soul’ and accused Dylan of ‘sell[ing] a prepackaged doctrine he’s received from someone else’.”

For what it’s worth, a 2013 readers’ poll in Rolling Stone magazine ranked “Gotta Serve Somebody” as Bob Dylan’s second worst song, with “Man Gave Names to All the Animals” as the fourth worst.

The Wikipedia article on Slow Train Coming also states (with no footnotes), in apparent violation of their NPOV (neutral point of view) policy: “In a year when Van Morrison and Patti Smith released their own spiritual works in Into the Music and Wave, respectively, Dylan’s album seemed vitriolic and bitter in comparison.” Neither album is particularly Christian, from what I can tell; the title track of the Patti Smith album “Wave” is dedicated to the nearly forgotten Pope John Paul I, but evidently only because it was recorded during his brief papacy. Also, Patti Smith’s previous album Easter, as might be expected from the title, has more Christian imagery; and Smith opened her acclaimed debut album Horses with a spoken-word introduction that might be described as “vitriolic and bitter” (I certainly don't think of it that way myself): “Jesus died for somebody’s sins, but not mine”.

* * *

Why did Bob Dylan quit recording Christian albums if he retains his Christian beliefs? There are any number of explanations: Many Christian recording artists perform all or mostly secular music, the drive to evangelize that attends a powerful conversion often fades after a while, Dylan might have said all that he felt that he needed to say, etc.

One factor is likely that all of this criticism directed at Bob Dylan stung – he is not as above it all as it might appear. A quotation from Wikipedia that I read some months ago that is no longer in the article on Infidels states: “It has been reported that reviews like these of Dylan’s religious works depressed the musician profoundly, inspiring Dylan’s comment at one concert that he was only referred to as a ‘prophet’ when he was a ‘secular prophet’ (paraphrased).”

* * *

The CD by this month’s Under Appreciated Rock Band, THE HOLY GHOST RECEPTION COMMITTEE #9 is a recent acquisition; I actually didn’t hear it at all until this month. I saw the CD listed sometimes in the Bomp! emails that I get two or three times a week, and I finally ordered it when I had the money.

This CD reminds me of stock liner notes that appeared on several of the compilation albums in the Pebbles Series and in the Highs in the Mid-Sixties Series, which collected obscure 1960’s garage rock and psychedelic rock songs. The concluding paragraph applies to this music, in a slightly different connotation: “Truly, this was the pinnacle of rock & roll, and until something comes along that can match it, these obscure artifacts of a vanished golden age stand as a reminder of just how great innocence can be!”

* * *

The music came about when one student at the Catholic Regis High School in New York City wrote a song that he wanted to sing at their weekly Mass meetings in place of the boring traditional hymns. Others soon followed and (as the CD liner notes proclaim): “The result was a revival, a whole new spirit with music, a kind of song prayer. The words were loud and clear. The beat made sense.”

One student came up with the name, the Holy Ghost Reception Committee #9 – the numeral I figure came from the Ed Wood cult classic horror film Plan 9 from Outer Space, but I’m just guessing. (Their first album predates The Beatles – the so-called White Album – that included the avant garde track “Revolution 9”, so that wasn’t it).

The students were encouraged in this work by one of the teachers, Anthony Meyer (who is a Jesuit). He assembled a group of musicians from the school to be the Holy Ghost Reception Committee #9: Dennis Blair (bass guitar), Bob Kearney (guitar), Mark Puleo (lead guitar), and Larry Johnsen (bass guitar and organ). The liner notes describe their sound as “unique, Christian yet with a Beatle-esque psychedelic sound”.

All of the songs are original, but many were written by students who were not in the actual band, the Holy Ghost Reception Committee #9: Edward Donion, John Goeke, Steve Mader, Joseph Piecora, and Joseph Sclafani. All have religious themes of course, but for the most part, the preaching is pretty subtle. In keeping with the times, some songs deal with hypocrisy – “He’s a Christian”, delivered the way that the Kinks would have – and misguided fear – “Them’s a Comin’”.

The music by the Holy Ghost Reception Committee #9 is amazing – Byrds-style folk-rock, straight-up rockers, garage rock, and early CCM. The opening song, “The Resurrection” is a particular favorite, but the whole album flows wonderfully. That the songwriters and players are just 15 and 16 years old just adds to the wonder of what they have accomplished.

At least one song mentions LSD, and the name of the song “The Magic Ice Cube” might refer to the frequent delivery medium of that drug on sugar cubes. The liner notes admit: “It probably didn’t hurt that some of the boys may have been experimenting with other things that God may or may not approve of; the Church definitely wouldn’t. But that’s a tale we won’t tell, at least for now.”

* * *

The Holy Ghost Reception Committee #9 did so well that they were signed by the Paulist Press to produce an album in 1968. Paulist Press is primarily a publisher of religious books and was clueless as to what to do with this music; they gave the album a description rather than a name, Songs for Liturgical Worship. The album is primarily songs of praise, with some retelling Bible stories. The music though is straight psych.

The psychedelic cover that they chose for the album shows that someone was paying attention, however.

* * *

Two years later, a second, tougher album, The Torchbearers followed, still under the Paulist Press umbrella. Rich Esposito on guitar joins the line-up of the Holy Ghost Reception Committee #9 for this album; Norman Grossman provides “guest percussion” on both LP’s. The back cover features advertisements for Paulist publications, including a series directed at teenagers called Discovery. The album was later reissued in 1996 on Void Records.

Both albums by the Holy Ghost Reception Committee #9 have been collected by Hallucinations Records on a 2009 CD called The Collected Works, and am I happy to have this unknown classic of Christian rock music years before the Jesus movement and the first glimmerings of CCM.

* * *

Only Dennis Blair has remained in show business apparently. Blair is a stand-up comedian who was mentored by Rodney Dangerfield and was a featured actor in two of his HBO specials; he also appears in Dangerfield’s 1983 film, Easy Money. Blair opened for George Carlin for 18 years and wrote a book about these experiences called Me First. He has a website, www.dennisblair.com as well as a short Wikipedia article; the Holy Ghost Reception Committee #9 is mentioned in passing on the website.

* * *

FLASHBACK: The Under-Appreciated Rock Band of the Month for August 2012 – Phil and the Frantics

Phil and the Frantics are best known for their evident plagiarism of a Zombies song for their minor hit “I Must Run”, though, to these ears, it isn’t nearly as obvious as everyone else seems to think. See what you think of this song on YouTube (audio only) as taken from the LP where I first heard the song, the Pebbles, Volume 2 LP: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gLK9wV-NfzQ. Here is another song called “What’s Happening”: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EDC-6wWl7bs. One more, from the flip side of “I Must Run”, called “Pain”: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cm_nRU-lYWc.

* * *

PICTURE GALLERY: The Under-Appreciated Rock Artist of the Month for August 2011 – Andy Colquhoun

Actually, I recently loaded up this UARA, Andy Colquhoun on my website, https://sites.google.com/site/underappreciatedrockbands/, so I have plenty of photos. Here is the album that I have, Pick up the Phone, America!:

Here is his second album, String Theory that I do not yet own:

This is a photo from the inside sleeve of my CD, showing Andy:

This is the Deviants reunion CD, Eating Jello with a Heated Fork, where Andy collaborated with the late, great Mick Farren:

* * *

STORY OF THE MONTH: “Scientific Proof of the Existence of God” (from December 2009)

This analysis is based primarily on scientific discoveries during my lifetime, including many from just the past 10 years. This will take some time to lay out, but I think it is worth it.

You are probably aware of the special features of the Solar System and the Universe that allow for the existence of life as we know it. What you might not know is that they go far beyond the so-called “Goldilocks” position of Earth around the Sun: not too hot, not too cold, but just right!

For instance, the fusion reaction that powers the Sun combines four hydrogen nuclei into one helium nucleus, converting 0.7% of the mass into energy (per Albert Einstein’s famous equation, E = MC²); yet if the amount of mass being converted to energy were 0.6% or 0.8% instead, the Universe would either be entirely hydrogen or would have no hydrogen at all (and thus no water), respectively – neither of which would permit the existence of life.

One of the constituent particles in the atoms of ordinary matter is the proton (a hydrogen nucleus consists of a single proton); if they were just 0.2% more massive, protons would be unstable and would decay into other particles. If the mass of another constituent particle, the electron (which has a very tiny fraction of the mass of a proton or neutron) were doubled, atoms would not exist either. There are many more examples like this, but one has been discovered lately that calls our very existence into question without outside help.

Careful observation of galaxies outside our own Milky Way showed that the stars were orbiting so quickly that they should be flying out of the galaxies. Over time, after accounting for all of the ordinary matter in a typical galaxy (shining stars, burned-out stars, planets, black holes, dust, etc.), scientists realized that some other form of matter must be present in great quantities that provides additional gravitational force to hold the galaxies together. Since it is invisible, and no one really knows what it is, scientists refer to it as “dark matter”. Dark matter is not composed of atoms and does not appear to interact with ordinary (baryonic) matter at all, but there is evidently much more dark matter than ordinary matter. Dark matter that is known to be present in enormous quantities includes particles known as neutrinos, but they appear to have virtually no mass and don’t really solve the problem. Recent experiments and observations have verified the existence of dark matter beyond any reasonable doubt.

In the late 1990’s, using new orbiting observatories and detailed scientific investigation, the age of the Universe was ultimately determined to a remarkably high degree of accuracy: 13.7 billion years. The same measurements and observations that allowed for this estimate also confirmed the rate of expansion of the Universe. The prevailing theories about the Big Bang that formed the Universe had been either that the rate of expansion of the Universe is gradually slowing down due to the force of gravity, or that the rate of expansion would remain about the same and would continue indefinitely. Instead, scientists unexpectedly found that the rate of expansion of the Universe is accelerating.

Again, there is no explanation for this as yet, so the concept of “dark energy” was introduced as the force that is pushing the galaxies in the Universe apart at an increasing rate. (The existence of galaxies outside our own galaxy was proved conclusively by the renowned astronomer Edwin Hubble in the 1920’s, and he is also credited with the discovery of the expanding Universe, i.e., that these galaxies are rapidly speeding away from each other; the Hubble Space Telescope is named in his honor). Dark energy is even more mysterious than dark matter, but the general consensus at present is that there is much more dark energy than there is dark matter. An estimate that I saw this month said that the ratio of dark energy to ordinary matter is 15 to 1.

If you are keeping track, you might have noticed that all of a sudden, scientists know a lot less about what the Universe is made of than they thought they did. When I was young, it seemed almost certain that the stars in the various galaxies made up nearly all of the material in the Universe. This seemed reasonable, since the Sun constitutes 99.86% of the mass of the Solar System – and we weren’t even sure of the existence of other planets until the 1990’s, although the presence of other objects like black holes and interstellar and inter-galactic dust is more appreciated now than it used to be. (Dust can be beautiful as well: Those gorgeous photographs from the Hubble Space Telescope, more often than not, are composed mostly of dust). In any case, recent calculations suggest that less than 1% of the Universe is actually made up of stars.

Now, the curious thing about dark energy is that it, too, is finely tuned so as to allow for the existence of the Universe and life: The amount of dark energy is just enough to accelerate the expansion of the Universe, but not enough to make the Universe tear itself apart. In this instance, however, the “just right” aspect of dark energy involves more than one half of the entire Universe. The Nobel Prize-winning physicist Steven Weinberg of the University of Texas has been quoted as saying: “This is the one fine-tuning that seems to be extreme, far beyond what you could imagine just having to accept as a mere accident.”

There is an alternate theory, in case you wonder why you are hearing so much lately about multiple universes (also known as the “multiverse”) – and not just a couple of thousand universes either. The idea is that the Universe only seems to be special because we happen to be living here; and that there are or were many, many, many more universes where things are not hospitable to life at all (or even matter). One estimate I have read is that there would have to be a googol times a googol other universes before the truly special nature of the Universe starts to become something that could really happen by chance. For those who don’t know where Google got its name, it is taken from the “googol” that was named decades ago by the child of a famous mathematician for a very large number: a 1 followed by 100 zeroes, which is also expressed as 10 to the 100th power. Thus, a googol times a googol would be 10 to the 200th power. To give you an idea of how many universes that is, the number of electrons in the Universe is estimated to be less than 10 to the 90th power.

So, if you would prefer to “believe” in untold numbers of other universes rather than believe in God, be my guest. Either way, the answer to this enigma lies outside of the Universe.

Far be it from me to tell you how you should react to this information. I am a Catholic convert, and that works for me. However, if you think that the wonders of modern science have somehow made the idea of God obsolete, you should realize that precisely the opposite is true.

References: Most though not all of this information came from an article in the December 2008 issue of Discover magazine that is posted on line at:

http://discovermagazine.com/2008/dec/10-sciences-alternative-to-an-intelligent-creator/article_view?searchterm=multiverse&b_start:int=1.

* * *

The Honor Roll of the Under Appreciated Rock Bands and Artists follows, in date order, including a link to the original Facebook posts and the theme of the article.

Dec 2009 – BEAST; Lot to Learn

Jan 2010 – WENDY WALDMAN; Los Angeles Singer-Songwriters

Feb 2010 – CYRUS ERIE; Cleveland

Mar 2010 – BANG; Record Collecting I

Apr 2010 – THE BREAKAWAYS; Power Pop

May 2010 – THE NOT QUITE; Katrina Clean-Up

Jun 2010 – WATERLILLIES; Electronica

Jul 2010 – THE EYES; Los Angeles Punk Rock

Aug 2010 – QUEEN ANNE’S LACE; Psychedelic Pop

Sep 2010 – THE STILLROVEN; Minnesota

Oct 2010 – THE PILTDOWN MEN; Record Collecting II

Nov 2010 – SLOVENLY; Slovenly Peter

Dec 2010 – THE POPPEES; New York Punk/New Wave

Jan 2011 – HACIENDA; Latinos in Rock

Feb 2011 – THE WANDERERS; Punk Rock (1970’s/1980’s)

Mar 2011 – INDEX; Psychedelic Rock (1960’s)

Apr 2011 – BOHEMIAN VENDETTA; Punk Rock (1960’s)

May 2011 – THE LONESOME DRIFTER; Rockabilly

Jun 2011 – THE UNKNOWNS; Disabled Musicians

Jul 2011 – THE RIP CHORDS; Surf Rock I

Aug 2011 – ANDY COLQUHOUN; Side Men

Sep 2011 – ULTRA; Texas

Oct 2011 – JIM SULLIVAN; Mystery

Nov 2011 – THE UGLY; Punk Rock (1970’s)

Dec 2011 – THE MAGICIANS; Garage Rock (1960’s)

Jan 2012 – RON FRANKLIN; Why Celebrate Under Appreciated?

Feb 2012 – JA JA JA; German New Wave

Mar 2012 – STRATAVARIOUS; Disco Music

Apr 2012 – LINDA PIERRE KING; Record Collecting III

May 2012 – TINA AND THE TOTAL BABES; One Hit Wonders

Jun 2012 – WILD BLUE; Band Names I

Jul 2012 – DEAD HIPPIE; Band Names II

Aug 2012 – PHIL AND THE FRANTICS; Wikipedia I

Sep 2012 – CODE BLUE; Hidden History

Oct 2012 – TRILLION; Wikipedia II

Nov 2012 – THOMAS ANDERSON; Martin Winfree’s Record Buying Guide

Dec 2012 – THE INVISIBLE EYES; Record Collecting IV

Jan 2013 – THE SKYWALKERS; Garage Rock Revival

Feb 2013 – LINK PROTRUDI AND THE JAYMEN; Link Wray

Mar 2013 – THE GILES BROTHERS; Novelty Songs

Apr 2013 – LES SINNERS; Universal Language

May 2013 – HOLLIS BROWN; Greg Shaw / Bob Dylan

Jun 2013 (I) – FUR (Part 1); What Might Have Been I

Jun 2013 (II) – FUR (Part 2); What Might Have Been II

Jul 2013 – THE KLUBS; Record Collecting V

Aug 2013 – SILVERBIRD; Native Americans in Rock

Sep 2013 – BLAIR 1523; Wikipedia III

Oct 2013 – MUSIC EMPORIUM; Women in Rock I

Nov 2013 – CHIMERA; Women in Rock II

Dec 2013 – LES HELL ON HEELS; Women in Rock III

Jan 2014 – BOYSKOUT; (Lesbian) Women in Rock IV

Feb 2014 – LIQUID FAERIES; Women in Rock V

Mar 2014 (I) – THE SONS OF FRED (Part 1); Tribute to Mick Farren

Mar 2014 (II) – THE SONS OF FRED (Part 2); Tribute to Mick Farren

Apr 2014 – HOMER; Creating New Bands out of Old Ones

May 2014 – THE SOUL AGENTS; The Cream Family Tree

Jun 2014 – THE RICHMOND SLUTS and BIG MIDNIGHT; Band Names (Changes) III

Jul 2014 – MIKKI; Rock and Religion I (Early CCM Music)

Aug 2014 – THE HOLY GHOST RECEPTION COMMITTEE #9; Rock and Religion II (Bob Dylan)

Sep 2014 – NICK FREUND; Rock and Religion III (The Beatles)

Oct 2014 – MOTOCHRIST; Rock and Religion IV

Nov 2014 – WENDY BAGWELL AND THE SUNLITERS; Rock and Religion V

Dec 2014 – THE SILENCERS; Surf Rock II

Jan 2015 (I) – THE CRAWDADDYS (Part 1); Tribute to Kim Fowley

Jan 2015 (II) – THE CRAWDADDYS (Part 2); Tribute to Kim Fowley

Feb 2015 – BRIAN OLIVE; Songwriting I (Country Music)

Mar 2015 – PHIL GAMMAGE; Songwriting II (Woody Guthrie / Bob Dylan)

Apr 2015 (I) – BLACK RUSSIAN (Part 1); Songwriting III (Partnerships)

Apr 2015 (II) – BLACK RUSSIAN (Part 2); Songwriting III (Partnerships)

May 2015 – MAL RYDER and THE PRIMITIVES; Songwriting IV (The Rolling Stones)

Jun 2015 – HAYMARKET SQUARE; Songwriting V (The Beatles)

Jul 2015 – THE HUMAN ZOO; Songwriting VI (Psychedelic Rock)

Aug 2015 – CRYSTAL MANSION; Martin Winfree’s Record Cleaning Guide

Dec 2015 – AMANDA JONES; So Many Rock Bands

Mar 2016 – THE LOVEMASTERS; Fun Rock Music

Jun 2016 – THE GYNECOLOGISTS; Offensive Rock Music Lyrics

Sep 2016 – LIGHTNING STRIKE; Rap and Hip Hop

Dec 2016 – THE IGUANAS; Iggy and the Stooges; Proto-Punk Rock

Mar 2017 – THE LAZY COWGIRLS; Iggy and the Stooges; First Wave Punk Rock

Jun 2017 – THE LOONS; Punk Revival and Other New Bands

Sep 2017 – THE TELL-TALE HEARTS; Bootleg Albums

Dec 2017 – SS-20; The Iguana Chronicles

(Year 10 Review)