Analogies

Idea 1: Understanding Electricity

Students often struggle with grasping the concept of current, resistance and (especially) voltage.

Sometimes, a simple cartoon helps a lot.

A similar example, using water flowing in pipes, to help them understand the relationship between these 3 quantities:

Another example that helps relate current and voltage to power.

Idea 2: Understanding the Cell

Cells - Analogy Groupwork.pdf
A simple worksheet for students to fill up

Students often have fun identifying different parts of the factory to relate them to various cell structures (based on their functions).

As an extension, challenge students to:

  1. Build an actual model (with Lego or Plasticine) of the cell factory, and do a video recording / live presentation

  2. Think of another analogy of their own (such as the school, or a corporate office, or their homes, etc as example), and explain it to their classmates

Other examples from the internet:

The cell as a... School

The cell as a... Ship

The cell as a... Handbag

TIP: These online examples may not seem perfect / completely accurate, thus when students are coming up with their own analogies, it is paramount that they:

  1. Include justifications for each organelle (which will allow the teacher to identify misconceptions and address them promptly)

  2. Realise no analogy is perfect (hence, an add-on activity could be for students to identify the limitations of their peers' analogy)

Idea 3: Understanding Kinetic Particle Theory

Solid

An impromptu idea of mine to help students grasp the arrangement + movement of particles easily.

TIP: Challenge them to think of other real-life scenarios involving people, and also draw their attention to the limitations of such analogies.

Liquid

Gas

Idea 4: Solubility VS Rate of Dissolving

(Students often are confused between the two, esp when they first learn this)

Fun idea gleaned from my online research:

Solubility = A Person's Appetite

Rate of Dissolving = How Fast Someone Is Eating

Idea 5: Factors affecting Solubility

Fun idea shared by a colleague of mine:

Type of Solvent = Single Vs Double-Decked Bus
Compare the number of passengers (i.e. solute) each can carry

Type of Solute = Wheelchair-Bound Adult VS Small Kids on a bus
Compare the speed at which they move about + the amount of space they occupy

Higher Temperature = Hot weather
Compare the speed at which passengers would get up an air-conditioned bus

Idea 6: Groups in the Periodic Table

Fun idea shared by a colleague of mine:

Important:

Challenge students to find alternative analogies; and always remember to probe further so students can find limitations of each analogy (which also serves as an indicator of their conceptual understanding)