Waitress - 04/24/16 (Broadway - Opening Night)Jessie Mueller (Jenna), Drew Gehling (Pomatter), Keala Settle (Becky), Kimiko Glenn (Dawn), Eric Anderson (Cal), Nick Cordero (Earl), Christopher Fitzgerald (Ogie), Dakin Matthews (Old Joe)
Waitress - 09/11/16 (Broadway)Jessie Mueller (Jenna), Drew Gehling (Pomatter), Keala Settle (Becky), Jenna Ushkowitz* (Dawn), Eric Anderson (Cal), Nick Cordero (Earl), Christopher Fitzgerald (Ogie), Dakin Matthews (Old Joe), Claire Keane (Lulu)Notes: Claire Keane’s last performance as Lulu.
Waitress - 02/18/17 (Broadway)Molly Jobe* (Jenna), Drew Gehling (Pomatter), Charity Angel Dawson (Becky), Caitlin Houlahan (Dawn), Eric Anderson (Cal), William Popp (Earl), Christopher Fitzgerald (Ogie), Dakin Matthews (Old Joe), Cate Elfante (Lulu)
Waitress - 03/26/17 (Broadway)Jessie Mueller (Jenna), Drew Gehling (Pomatter), Charity Angel Dawson (Becky), Caitlin Houlahan (Dawn), Joe Cassidy (Cal), William Popp (Earl), Christopher Fitzgerald (Ogie), Dakin Matthews (Old Joe) Notes: Jessie Mueller's final performance.
Waitress - 03/30/17 (Broadway - Evening) [MASTER]Stephanie Torns (Jenna), Drew Gehling (Pomatter), Anastacia McClesky* (Becky), Caitlin Houlahan (Dawn), Eric Anderson (Cal), William Popp (Earl), Christopher Fitzgerald (Ogie), Dakin Matthews (Old Joe), Olivia Phillip* (Nurse Norma), Cate Elefante (Lulu)Notes: Drew Gehling and William Popp's last performances. Includes BCEFA & goodbye speeches.
Waitress - 06/08/17 (Broadway)Sara Bareilles (Jenna), Chris Diamantopolous (Pomatter), Charity Angel Dawson (Becky), Caitlin Houlahan (Dawn), (Cal), Will Swenson (Earl), Christopher Fitzgerald (Ogie)
Waitress - 12/17/17 (Broadway - Matinee)Stephanie Torns* (Jenna), Jason Mraz (Pomatter), Natasha Yvette Williams (Becky), Caitlin Houlahan (Dawn), Eric Anderson (Cal), Will Swenson (Earl), Christopher Fitzgerald (Ogie), John Cullum (Old Joe), Katie Grober (alt. Lulu) Notes: Eric Anderson's last performance.
Waitress - 01/09/18 (Broadway)Betsy Wolfe (Jenna), Jason Mraz (Pomatter), NaTasha Yvette Cullum (Becky), Caitlin Houlahan (Dawn), Will Swenson (Cal), Joe Tippett (Earl), Christopher Fitzgerald (Ogie), Dakin Matthews (Old Joe), Anastacia McCleskey (Nurse Norma), Victoria Collett (Lulu)Notes: Betsy Wolfe's final performance.
Waitress - 01/21/18 (Broadway)Sara Bareilles (Jenna), Jason Mraz (Pomatter), Natasha Yvette Williams (Becky), Caitlin Houlihan (Dawn), Benny Elledge (Cal), Joe Tippett (Earl), Christopher Fitzgerald (Ogie)
Waitress - 02/11/18 (Broadway)Sara Bareilles (Jenna), Jason Mraz (Pomatter), Caitlin Houlahan (Dawn), NaTasha Yvette Williams (Becky), Joe Tippett (Earl), Benny Elledge (Cal), Christopher Fitzgerald (Ogie), Dakin Matthews (Joe), Anastacia McClenskey (Nurse Norma), Danya Jarae Dantzler* (Francine), Victoria Collett (Lulu)Notes: Jason Mraz's final performance. Includes the cast singing 'I'm Yours' after curtain call.
Waitress - 03/06/18 (Broadway)Sara Bareilles (Jenna), Drew Gehling (Pomatter), NaTasha Yvette Williams (Becky), Caitlin Houlahan (Dawn), Benny Allege (Cal), Ben Thompson (Earl), Christopher Fitzgerald (Ogie), Lee Wilkon (Old Joe), Dayna Jarae Dantzler (Nurse Norma) Victoria Collett (Lulu)
Waitress - 04/10/18 (Broadway)Katharine McPhee (Jenna), Drew Gehling (Pomatter), NaTasha Yvette Williams (Becky), Caitlin Houlahan (Dawn), Benny Elledge (Cal), Ben Thompson (Earl), Christopher Fitzgerald (Ogie), Steve Vinovich (Old Joe), Tiffany Mann (Nurse Norma)Notes: Katharine McPhee's first performance.
Waitress - 04/11/18 (Broadway - Evening) [MASTER]Katharine McPhee (Jenna), Drew Gehling (Pomatter), NaTasha Yvette Williams (Becky), Caitlin Houlahan (Dawn), Benny Elledge (Cal), Ben Thompson (Earl), Christopher Fitzgerald (Ogie), Steve Vinovich (Old Joe), Tiffany Mann (Nurse Norma), Katie Grober (Lulu) Notes: Act two only (due to recording device failure), includes BCEFA speech.
Waitress - 07/05/18 (Broadway - Evening)Katharine McPhee (Jenna), Erich Bergen (Pomatter), NaTasha Yvette Williams (Becky), Caitlin Houlahan (Dawn), Benny Elledge (Cal), Ben Thompson (Earl), Tyrone Davis, Jr.* (Ogie)
Waitress - 08/19/18 (Broadway)Katharine McPhee (Jenna), Henry Gottfried (Pomatter), NaTasha Yvette Williams (Becky), Katie Lowes (Dawn), Benny Elledge (Cal), Ben Thompson (Earl), Adam Shapiro (Ogie), Bill Nolte (Old Joe)Notes: Katharine McPhee's last performance (of this run). Includes goodbye speech by Jessie Nelson.
Waitress - 09/04/18 (Broadway - Evening)Nicolette Robinson (Jenna), Drew Gehling (Pomatter), Natasha Yvette Williams (Becky), Katie Lowes (Dawn), Benny Elledge (Cal), Ben Thompson (Earl), Adam Shapiro (Ogie), Bill Nolte (Old Joe) Notes: Nicolette Robinson's Broadway debut.
Waitress - 11/19/18 (Broadway)Nicolette Robinson (Jenna), Drew Gehling (Pomatter), Tiffany Mann* (Becky), Lenne Klingaman (Dawn), Ben Elledge (Cal), Ben Thompson (Earl), Alex Wyse (Ogie), June Squibb (Old Josie), Tiffany Denise Hobbs* (Nurse Norma)Notes: June Squibb’s debut as Old Josie. During “Lipstick Smudger”, June flubs her lines and Nicolette improvises.
Waitress - 12/09/18 (Broadway)Nicolette Robinson (Jenna), Drew Gehling (Pomatter), Charity Angél Dawson (Becky), Lenne Klingaman (Dawn), Benny Elledge (Cal), Dan Tracy* (Earl), Alex Wyse (Ogie), June Squibb (Old Josie), Tiffany Mann (Nurse Norma), London Skye Gilliam (Lulu), Brandon Kalm* (Father)Notes: Nicolette Robinson, Alex Wyse and London Skye Gilliam's final performances.
Waitress - 12/30/18 (Broadway)Stephanie Torns (Jenna), Brandon Kalm* (Pomatter), Anastacia McCleskey* (Becky), Jessie Hooker-Bailey* (Dawn), Benny Elledge (Cal), Dan Tracy* (Earl), Christopher Fitzgerald (Ogie), June Squibb (Old Josie), Tiffany Denise Hobbs* (Nurse Norma), Skyler Adams* (Father), Molly Jobe* (Francine)Notes: Jessie Hooker-Bailey's second performance and the last show of 2018.
Waitress - 01/07/19 (Broadway)Sara Bareilles (Jenna), Gavin Creel (Pommater), Charity Angel Dawson (Becky), Lenne Klugmann (Dawn), Benny Elledge (Cal), Ben Thompson (Earl), Tyrone Davis Jr.* (Ogie), Larry Marshall (Old Joe)Notes: Sara Bareilles, Gavin Creel, and Larry Marshall’s first performances (of this run).
Waitress - 02/16/19 (Broadway)Stephanie Torns (Jenna), Joey McIntyre (Pomatter), Charity Angel Dawson (Becky), Lenne Klingaman (Dawn), Benny Elledge (Cal), Ben Thompson (Earl), Eddie Jemison (Ogie), Larry Marshall (Old Joe), Anastacia McCleskey (Nurse Norma)
Waitress - 03/03/19 (Broadway - Matinee)Stephanie Torns (Jenna), Joey McIntyre (Pomatter), Charity Angél Dawson (Becky), Molly Jobe* (Dawn), Benny Elledge (Cal), Ben Thompson (Earl), Eddie Jemison (Ogie), Larry Marshall (Old Joe), Anastacia McCleskey (Nurse Norma), Regan Ciccarelli (Lulu), Jessie Hooker-Bailey* (Francine), Brandon Kalm* (Father)
Waitress - 03/18/19 (Broadway)Shoshana Bean (Jenna), Joey McIntyre (Pomatter), Dayna Jarae Dantzler (Becky), Molly Jobe* (Dawn), Benny Elledge (Cal), Ben Thompson (Earl), Eddie Jemison (Ogie), Larry Marshall (Old Joe), Melody A. Betts (Nurse Norma), Everleigh Rottuno (Lulu), Jessie Hooker-Bailey* (Francine), Arica Jackson* (Ensemble Swing)Notes: Shoshona Bean’s first performance. Includes a blooper in the second doctors visit scene which leads to some ad-libbing.
Waitress - 03/25/19 (Broadway - Evening) [MASTER]Shoshana Bean (Jenna), Joey McIntyre (Pomatter), Charity Angel Dawson (Becky), Lenne Klingaman (Dawn), Benny Elledge (Cal), Ben Thompson (Earl), Eddie Jemison (Ogie), Larry Marshall (Old Joe), Melody A. Betts (Nurse Norma), Everleigh Rottuno (Lulu)
Waitress - 04/08/19 (Broadway)Shoshana Bean (Jenna), Jeremy Jordan (Pomatter), Charity Angel Dawson (Becky), Jessie Hooker-Bailey* (Dawn), Benny Elledge (Cal), Ben Thompson (Earl), Eddie Jemison (Ogie), Larry Marshall (Old Joe), Melody A. Betts (Nurse Norma), Tess Murphy (Lulu)Notes: Jeremy Jordan's first performance.
Waitress - 04/26/19 (Broadway)Shoshana Bean (Jenna), Brandon Kalm* (Pomatter), Melody A Betts* (Becky), Jessie Hooker-Bailey* (Dawn), Benny Elledge (Cal), Ben Thompson (Earl), Eddie Jemison (Ogie), Larry Marshall (Old Joe), Melody A. Betts (Nurse Norma)
Waitress - 05/06/19 (Broadway)Shoshana Bean (Jenna), Jeremy Jordan (Pomatter), Charity Angel Dawson (Becky), Caitlin Houlahan (Dawn), Benny Elledge (Cal), Ben Thompson (Earl), Noah Galvin (Ogie), Larry Marshall (Old Joe)
Waitress - 06/01/19 (Broadway - Matinee)Shoshana Bean (Jenna), Jeremy Jordan (Pomatter), Charity Angel Dawson (Becky), Caitlin Houlahan (Dawn), Benny Elledge (Cal), Ben Thompson (Earl), Noah Galvin (Ogie), Larry Marshall (Old Joe)
Waitress - 12/14/19 (Broadway)Katharine McPhee (Jenna), Brandon Kalm* (Pomatter), Dayna Jarae Dantzler* (Becky), Jessie Hooker-Bailey* (Dawn), Christopher Fitzgerald (Ogie), Benny Elledge (Cal), Larry Marshall (Joe), Ben Thompson (Earl), Arica Jackson* (Nurse Norma), Scarlett Sher (Lulu)Notes: Jessie Hooker-Bailey's last performance as Dawn.