How We Research
We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
If you want a self-contained surround-sound gaming headset that does its own 7.1 processing and works across PS5, PS4, PC and mobile, choose Turtle Beach Elite Pro; if you need to add real 7.1-channel surround output and cleaner audio to a desktop PC you already own, choose Creative Sound Blaster Audigy.
• Turtle Beach Elite Pro — biggest strength: a complete amplified headset system, with 50mm Nanoclear drivers, DTS Headphone:X 7.1 surround, a noise-cancelling TruSpeak mic and app-controlled tuning through the SuperAmp.
• Turtle Beach Elite Pro — biggest trade-off: it's a headset, not a PC component, so the surround processing lives inside Turtle Beach's own hardware and app rather than in your computer, and PS5 surround needs an optical connection routed from your TV, receiver or an HDMI-to-optical converter.
• Creative Sound Blaster Audigy — biggest strength: it puts discrete 7.1-channel analog output, 32-bit/384 kHz playback and a 120 dB SNR into a PC through a PCIe card, with SPDIF, mic-in and line-in on board.
• Creative Sound Blaster Audigy — biggest trade-off: it's a Windows PC upgrade only, it needs a free PCIe slot and a speaker or headset setup to feed, and it does nothing for a console or a phone.
• Who each pick is for: the Turtle Beach headset suits console and cross-device players who want chat, mic monitoring and surround in one box; the Creative card suits desktop builders and movie watchers who want better sound out of the PC they already have.
The Elite Pro 2 + SuperAmp is best understood as an audio system rather than a plain headset. The over-ear enclosure holds 50mm Nanoclear dynamic drivers covering 20 Hz to 20,000 Hz, tuned for Turtle Beach's esports-style sound. Around your ears sit Aerofit cushions that combine cooling comfort with passive noise isolation and a bit more bass weight. The frequency range is ordinary on paper; the point is the tuning and the amp behind it.
That amp is the SuperAmp, and it's what makes this pick interesting for surround sound. It's a Bluetooth-connected, app-controlled controller that adds amplification and supports DTS Headphone:X 7.1 channel surround on PS5 and PS4. On PS5 you'll need an optical connection from your TV, receiver or an HDMI-to-optical converter, which is worth planning for before you buy. Bluetooth 4.2 also lets you stream music or take calls while you game, and the Audio Hub app is where you shape the sound.
Buy it if you play on PlayStation or PC, want surround plus a serious mic in one package, and like the idea of app-based tuning. Skip it if you're strictly a desktop user who wants to upgrade the sound of speakers you already own — this is a headset, and it can't do that job.
Creative Sound Blaster Audigy: Who It's For
The Audigy Fx Pro is a completely different kind of product: a low-profile PCIe sound card, 10.5 cm long, that slots into a desktop PC and takes over audio duties from your motherboard. Its headline numbers are strong for the category — playback up to 32-bit/384 kHz, a 120 dB signal-to-noise ratio, and discrete 7.1-channel analog output. In plain terms, that's cleaner, quieter background than typical onboard audio and a real multi-channel feed for a surround speaker set.
Connectivity is where it earns its place. It drives multi-channel PC speaker systems, offers SPDIF output, and includes headset output, mic-in and line-in, so a headset, a mic and a source device can all live on the card. The redesigned Creative Nexus app adds AutoEq, which simulates the frequency response of various headphones so you can tailor what you hear. A half-height bracket is included for smaller cases, and it ships with the full-height bracket already mounted. It's a Windows 10-compatible card.
Two things to be clear about. First, this is a PC part — it does nothing for a PS5, a phone or a laptop without a PCIe slot. Second, it's a source, not a speaker: you still need a 7.1 speaker system or a good headset to hear the benefit. If your PC already has a decent speaker set and you want to feed it properly, that's exactly the gap this fills.
Buy it if you're building or upgrading a desktop and want clean 7.1 surround, SPDIF and headset support from one card. Skip it if you game mainly on console or want a single all-in-one solution.
• Best for console gaming → Turtle Beach Elite Pro. DTS Headphone:X 7.1 surround is built for PS5 and PS4, with the optical caveat on PS5.
• Best for PC-only surround → Creative Sound Blaster Audigy. Discrete 7.1-channel analog output straight from a PCIe card.
• Best for team chat → Turtle Beach Elite Pro. TruSpeak noise cancellation, Dynamic Chat Boost and Variable Mic Monitoring are all chat-focused.
• Best for clean playback specs → Creative Sound Blaster Audigy. 32-bit/384 kHz and 120 dB SNR are the stronger numbers here.
• Best for multi-device use → Turtle Beach Elite Pro. Wired 3.5mm plus Bluetooth 4.2 covers console, PC and mobile.
• Best for compact PC builds → Creative Sound Blaster Audigy. The 10.5 cm card and half-height bracket fit small cases.
• Best for headphone tuning → Creative Sound Blaster Audigy. Nexus AutoEq simulates different headphone responses; Turtle Beach counters with its Audio Hub app on mobile.
• Best for positional audio cues → Turtle Beach Elite Pro. Superhuman Hearing is designed to surface quiet in-game sounds.
In my opinion, most people searching this comparison are gamers who want surround sound without rebuilding a PC, and for them I'd buy the Turtle Beach Elite Pro 2 + SuperAmp. It delivers surround, a strong mic and cross-device flexibility in one box, and the PS5 optical requirement is a setup detail rather than a dealbreaker. I'd only pick the Creative Sound Blaster Audigy if the goal is specifically to upgrade a desktop's 7.1 output and clean up onboard audio for a speaker system. Check the current price on Amazon before deciding, since the two solve different problems at very different scopes.
how to get surround sound headphones
Surround sound headphones either process virtual multichannel audio internally or receive a multichannel feed from a source. The Turtle Beach Elite Pro does the first — its SuperAmp handles DTS Headphone:X 7.1 on PS5 and PS4, with an optical connection required on PS5. The Creative card does neither for headphones on its own; it outputs discrete 7.1 analog for speakers.
how to test surround sound headphones
Play content with clear directional cues — a game with footsteps or a film with panning effects — and listen for front-to-back and left-to-right placement. On the Turtle Beach set, try Superhuman Hearing and compare with it off to judge how well quiet sounds come through. On a PC with the Creative card, switch between stereo and 7.1 output in Windows and compare.
how to fix surround sound headphones
Most surround problems trace back to the source, not the headset. On PS5, the Elite Pro needs optical from your TV, receiver or an HDMI-to-optical converter — without it, you won't get DTS Headphone:X. On PC, confirm Windows is set to the correct output and that the Creative card's 7.1 mode matches your speaker layout.
how to make surround sound headphones
You can't convert plain stereo headphones into true surround ones, but you can get close. Pair a headset with a source that processes multichannel audio — the Elite Pro's SuperAmp does this for consoles, and the Creative Audigy Fx Pro's Nexus app with AutoEq lets you tailor headphone response on a PC. Matching the right source to the right headphones is the real trick.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.
See also: Wewow Sleep Headphones vs Scozkc Sleep Earplugs, Sephia SP3060 vs SIMOLIO Manyshare Series, Bokexing Earbuds vs Generic Air31: HIFI Stereo Earbuds, Raycon Everyday vs ROEL-PLAY Earbuds