How We Research
We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
Updated: 2026-10-04 · 6 min read · Independent comparison
• Top Stage 3 — biggest strength: three pairs of 50mm / 2-inch memory-foam covers in one pack, so you get spares and a low-commitment way to refresh tired earpads.
• Top Stage 3 — biggest trade-off: it is a flat 3mm foam cover, not a full cushion, and it only fits headphones that measure 2 inches across — you must measure before buying.
• YDYBZB Ear Pads Replacement — biggest strength: protein-leather and memory-foam cushions with a model-specific fit list, designed for long-term comfort and better sound isolation.
• YDYBZB Ear Pads Replacement — biggest trade-off: it is one pair, and it only fits the Sony and JBL models named in its compatibility list — nothing else.
• Who each pick is for: Top Stage 3 for the tinkerer with generic 50mm headphones who wants cheap spares; YDYBZB for anyone replacing worn pads on a listed Sony or JBL model, especially for long calls.
Top Stage 3 is the no-frills option. You get three pairs of black 50mm (2-inch) foam ear pad covers, each about 3mm thick, made from memory foam. That is the whole pitch. There is no leather, no stitched cushion, no mounting ring. It is a flat disc of foam that sits over your existing earpad.
What it does best is exactly what that design implies: it adds a soft foam layer between your ear and the headphone, and it protects or refreshes whatever pad is already there. The manufacturer states it enhances the fidelity of music, and in practice a fresh foam layer can tighten up the seal on tired, flattened pads. The three-pair pack is the real selling point — if you own several pairs of cheap on-ear headphones, this covers them all in one go.
Who should skip it? If you own a Sony MDR-ZX110NC or a JBL Tune, skip it — you have a better, model-specific option below. And if you want a genuine cushion with leather and real padding, this is not that. This is foam, and 30 days of warranty tells you how the brand views its own lifespan.
YDYBZB Ear Pads Replacement: Who It's For
YDYBZB is the opposite approach: a purpose-built replacement cushion rather than a generic cover. Each pad pairs protein leather with memory foam, and the fit list is specific — Sony MDR-ZX110, ZX110NC, ZX310, ZX330BT, WH-CH500, CH510, CH520, V150 and V250, plus JBL Tune 510BT, 500BT, 450BT, 660NC and 600BTNC. If your headphones are on that list, this is a direct swap.
The design story matters more than the spec sheet here. Protein leather over memory foam is the standard recipe for a cushion that holds its shape instead of collapsing after a few weeks. YDYBZB says the leather is built for long-term, crack-free use, and that the firmer memory foam creates an ear-conforming fit that isolates sound from your surroundings. That is the sentence that matters most if you are living in video meetings all day.
Think about what that means for a work-from-home setup. A firmer cushion presses evenly around the ear, which cuts down on the clamping pressure that makes cheap pads ache after an hour. It also blocks more of the room — a fan, a keyboard, a housemate — from bleeding into your mic. If you are hunting for the best earphones for zoom calls and you already own one of the listed Sony or JBL models, new cushions are often the cheapest real upgrade you can make, far more sensible than replacing the whole headphone.
Side-by-Side: Which Should You Choose?
• Best for zoom calls and long meetings → YDYBZB. Firmer memory foam and a leather surface are designed for hours of wear and better isolation, which is exactly what call audio needs.
• Best for sound isolation → YDYBZB. An ear-conforming seal around the ear blocks more room noise than a flat 3mm foam disc.
• Best for durability → YDYBZB. Protein leather over memory foam is engineered for long-term, crack-free use; Top Stage is bare foam with a 30-day warranty.
• Best for spares and value-per-piece → Top Stage 3. Three pairs in one pack means you can refresh several headphones or keep backups.
• Best for generic or off-brand headphones → Top Stage 3. If your headphones measure 2 inches across but are not on any compatibility list, this is your only option of the two.
• Best for Sony MDR-ZX110 / ZX110NC and JBL Tune owners → YDYBZB. It is built for those exact models, so installation is a straight swap.
• Best for a quick, low-commitment refresh → Top Stage 3. No fitting questions beyond the 50mm measurement.
• Best for comfort over a full workday → YDYBZB. Relieving clamp pressure is the whole reason those pads exist.
I would buy the YDYBZB Ear Pads Replacement — provided my headphones are on its compatibility list. For zoom calls, the cushion is the part doing the work: firm memory foam holds a seal around your ear, protein leather keeps it comfortable past the one-hour mark, and better isolation means your voice sounds cleaner to everyone else on the call. The Top Stage 3 pack is a fine, cheap way to cover generic 50mm headphones or keep spares around, but it is foam, not a cushion. If you own a listed Sony or JBL model, the YDYBZB is the upgrade I recommend.
Only if your pads measure 2 inches (50mm) across, which is the sole fit criterion. It is a generic foam cover, not a model-specific cushion, so it will not match the shape or mounting of a Sony pad the way the YDYBZB does.
They do not add active noise cancelling — that lives in the headphones. What the firmer memory foam does is create a tighter seal around your ear, which improves passive isolation and stops more room noise from reaching you.
By design, the YDYBZB. Protein leather over memory foam is made for long-term, crack-free use, while the Top Stage covers are bare foam with a 30-day warranty. Foam flattens; a stitched cushion holds its shape.
Prices change often and I do not quote them here. Use the "Check latest price on Amazon" button on this page for both options and compare before you commit.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.
See also: Logitech G435 vs Corsair Virtuoso MAX: Wireless Headset, SOL REPUBLIC Shadow Fusion vs MSHUKCOE Smallest Invisible Mini, Logitech Z207 vs RoomyRoc Headphones: Wireless Stereo, Logitech Pro X vs Kensington Noise Cancelling H