How We Research
We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
Updated: 2026-09-25 · 7 min read · Independent comparison
• Toastmaster Air Frying Toaster — biggest strength: it's built like an air fryer first, with an 1800-watt convection system, a 23-quart cavity and a flow-through air fry basket included, so wings, fries and a 4-pound chicken come out crisp without preheating drama.
• Toastmaster Air Frying Toaster — biggest trade-off: it's the simpler machine. Knob control, one temperature dial up to 450°F, a single rack, and no dehydrate, slow cook or rotisserie modes — so if you want one appliance to do everything, you'll feel the ceiling.
• Beelicious Pro 28QT — biggest strength: capacity and automation. A 28-quart, 3-layer rack design (up to 36 wings or a 12" pizza in one pass), 6 heating elements with Next-Gen HeatWave Convection, and 12 one-touch functions from Air Fry to Dehydrate.
• Beelicious Pro 28QT — biggest trade-off: it's a toaster oven that air fries, not a fryer that toasts. It's heavier (22.7 lbs vs 15.7 lbs), takes more counter space in a boxier footprint, and button controls mean more steps than turning a dial.
• Who each pick is for: Toastmaster for the cook who wants fast, crispy air frying in a compact stainless package; Beelicious Pro for the household cooking for several people who wants one box to replace a fryer, a toaster and an oven.
The Toastmaster Air Frying Toaster (TM-220AFO) is the appliance you reach for when you want air-fried food and toast from the same box, without learning a control panel. Toastmaster gives you knob control and an adjustable temperature up to 450°F with a 60-minute timer. Turn the temperature dial, turn the timer, walk away. That's the whole interface, and for a lot of people that's the point.
The 23-quart interior is the interesting part. Toastmaster frames it around 6 slices of bread, 3 pounds of wings, or a 4-pound whole chicken — which tells you this is genuinely a mid-size cooking cavity, not a two-slice novelty. The 1800 watts and multiple heating elements drive the convection, and the included flow-through air fryer basket is what makes the air frying mode actually work rather than just circulating warm air around a solid pan. You also get a baking rack, a non-stick coated baking pan, a drip tray and a basket removal tool, so you can air fry, bake, broil, toast and warm from day one.
Buy it if you want crisp results fast, a stainless finish that reads clean on the counter, and five functions you'll actually remember. Skip it if your cooking leans toward large-batch meal prep, dehydrating, or slow cooking — the Toastmaster doesn't claim those modes, and with a single drop-down door and one rack level you're cooking in one layer at a time. The 1-year limited warranty is also on the short end, which is worth knowing before you commit. In my opinion, this is the pick for a small household, a couple, or anyone replacing a basket air fryer with something that can also make breakfast.
The Beelicious Pro 28QT (BAF811) plays a different game entirely. Where the Toastmaster is a fryer with oven duties, this is a toaster oven with fryer duties — and it leans hard into volume. The 3-layer rack design is the headline: up to 36 wings, a 12" pizza, and vegetables all at once. If you've ever stood over a basket fryer doing three batches while everyone else eats, that single sentence is the whole argument.
The cooking hardware backs it up. Six heating elements plus Next-Gen HeatWave Convection are aimed squarely at the classic toaster oven complaint — cold spots that force you to rotate trays halfway through. Beelicious Pro says no flipping trays, no cold zones. Whether it fully delivers is something you'll judge in your own kitchen, but the spec sheet is at least aimed at the right problem. The 12 one-touch functions are the other half of the pitch: Air Fry, Toast, Bake, Broil, Roast, Reheat, Warm, Slow Cook, Preheat, Rotate, and Dehydrate. That list covers jobs the Toastmaster simply doesn't offer, and button control is what makes a 12-mode menu usable.
Buy it if you're feeding a family, you want one appliance where there were three, or you actually want to dehydrate and slow cook in a countertop oven. Skip it if counter space is tight or you hate menus. At 22.7 pounds with a 16.3"D x 16.85"W x 13.23"H footprint, it's a chunkier machine than the Toastmaster, and it's a bigger commitment to leave sitting out. It also ships with just the power cord and a recipe — no baking pan, rack set or air fry basket listed in the box — so budget for accessories if you don't already own oven-safe pans that fit.
Side-by-Side: Which Should You Choose?
• Best for fast, simple air frying → Toastmaster Air Frying Toaster. Knob control, 1800 watts, 450°F max, and the flow-through basket included. No menu diving.
• Best for feeding a crowd in one pass → Beelicious Pro 28QT. 28 quarts, 3 rack layers, up to 36 wings or a 12" pizza at once.
• Best for small kitchens → Toastmaster Air Frying Toaster. It's lighter (15.7 lbs), lower-profile at 12.76"H, and stainless rather than a black box.
• Best for even browning without babysitting → Beelicious Pro 28QT. Six heating elements and HeatWave Convection are designed to eliminate the tray-flipping routine.
• Best for a straightforward breakfast-and-dinner machine → Toastmaster Air Frying Toaster. A 60-minute timer, a 23-quart cavity and 6 slices of toast capacity cover everyday basics.
• Best for replacing multiple appliances → Beelicious Pro 28QT. It's explicitly built to stand in for a fryer, toaster and oven at once.
• Best for accessories out of the box → Toastmaster Air Frying Toaster. Baking rack, non-stick baking pan, drip tray, air fry basket and basket removal tool are all included.
In my opinion, the Beelicious Pro 28QT is the better buy for most people, because it does nearly everything the Toastmaster does plus slow cooking, dehydrating and three-layer batch cooking — and the 3-layer design solves the real problem of air frying for more than two people. That said, I'd steer you to the Toastmaster Air Frying Toaster if you want the simplest possible crispy-food machine in a lighter, stainless, dial-controlled package and you don't care about dehydrate or slow cook. Pick based on how many people you cook for, not on features you'll never press. Either way, check the current price on Amazon before you commit, since that's the one number that can flip this decision.
what is an air fryer vs toaster oven
An air fryer is a compact convection oven built around a basket, so hot air moves through and around the food for fast crisping — that's the Toastmaster's approach, with its flow-through air fry basket and 1800 watts. A toaster oven is a larger, flatter cavity for baking, broiling and toasting. The Beelicious Pro sits in between: a 28QT toaster oven with convection and air fry modes built in.
how to air fry in toaster oven
Use the air fry setting and the basket or a perforated pan so air can circulate underneath. Keep food in a single layer where you can, set the temperature, and use the timer — the Toastmaster gives you a dial up to 450°F and a 60-minute timer; the Beelicious Pro has a dedicated Air Fry one-touch function and a 3-layer rack if you're cooking more than one batch.
how to clean air fryer toaster oven
Let it cool, pull out the rack and basket, and wash those in warm soapy water — the Toastmaster's baking pan is non-stick coated, which makes that easier. Wipe the interior with a damp cloth and clear crumbs from the bottom. The Beelicious Pro's 12 one-touch modes include Preheat, but neither brand lists a self-clean cycle, so this is a manual job either way.
how to air fryer toaster oven
Treat it as one appliance with two jobs: use the air fry mode and basket for wings, fries and chicken, and the toast/bake modes for bread, casseroles and reheating. The Toastmaster covers air fry, bake, broil, toast and warm with knob controls; the Beelicious Pro goes further with Air Fry, Toast, Bake, Broil, Roast, Reheat, Warm, Slow Cook, Preheat, Rotate and Dehydrate.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.
See also: SharkNinja Foodi Pro 5-in-1 vs Cosori Air Fryer Pro, TeamFar Toaster Oven Pan vs SIUDANGKA 100Pcs: Air Fryer, Hamilton Beach Quantum Toaster Oven vs OVENTE 8L: Air Fryer