Spain asks U.S. to begin cleanup of nuclear accident site

BY CIARÁN GILES (AP NEWS)

Published 5:24 PM CEST, March 6, 2023

Madrid (AP) — Spain said Monday it has asked the United States to begin procedures to remove soil contaminated with radioactivity after a mid-air collision dumped four U.S. hydrogen bombs near a southern Spanish village nearly 60 years ago.

None of the bombs had exploded, but the plutonium-filled detonators on two went off, spreading several kilograms (pounds) of highly radioactive plutonium 239 across the landscape around Palomares.

The Foreign Ministry said there would be no more details given on the petition until there is an official reply from the U.S.

Spain and the U.S. signed a statement of intent in 2015 to negotiate a binding agreement to further restore and clear up the Palomares site and arrange for the disposal of the contaminated soil at an appropriate site in the U.S. But for several reasons no agreement was ever signed.

The bombs fell on Jan. 17, 1966, when a U.S. B-52 bomber and a refueling plane crashed into each other, killing seven of 11 crew members. There were no fatalities on the ground.

The accident happened during the height of the Cold War when it was U.S. policy to keep nuclear-armed warplanes in the air constantly near the Soviet border.

The 2015 statement said that immediately following the accident both countries set about securing the area, removing contaminated soil and decontaminating the land. It said that they have since been monitoring and analyzing contamination levels.

The Spanish state news agency EFE said some 50,000 cubic meter (1,76 million cubic feet) of land over 44 plots were affected. The government has since been renting the land from its owners to keep it protected and now hopes to expropriate it.

Leading Spanish daily El País, which published the story on the petition Monday, said the request had been presented several months ago and that the U.S. reaction so far had been positive.

The newspaper said Spain was pushing for a quick agreement as the country will be holding general elections in December.

Spain's half-forgotten search for a long-term nuclear waste solution

Radioactive waste remains a partially unresolved problem in Spain. Intermediate-level, low-level and very low-level waste - whose activity drops by half within 30 years - is sent to a facility at El Cabril, in Córdoba, but the issue of spent fuel from nuclear power plants has yet to be adequately addressed.

For now, each of Spain's six operating power stations stores its own waste. Some of it even ends up in France; the waste produced from the decommissioning of the Vandellòs I plant in Catalonia was sent to the southeastern French nuclear site of Marcoule - the same one where a furnace for treating low-level waste exploded on Monday, killing one worker and injuring several others.

The waste that is treated at El Cabril comes mostly from Spanish nuclear power plants, although the site also stores medical material and waste from hospitals, research centers and certain industrial sectors. Its history as a waste storage facility began in 1961, when the Nuclear Energy Commission started taking drums of radioactive waste there to store them in a uranium mine.

Low and very low-level waste can occasionally be incinerated, either to reduce its volume before storage or as a final treatment solution. But the real headache is posed by high-level waste management, including spent fuel from nuclear power plants, which remain radioactive for thousands of years.

In the more than 40 years that Spain has had nuclear technology, nobody has come up with a solution for at least the next 100 years. In the early 1980s, spent fuel from Santa María de Garoña, Burgos province, was sent to Britain. In 1989, when a fire led to the shutdown of Vandellòs I (Tarragona), the residue was dispatched to France, since Spain lacked a disposal facility. That particular shipment - 13 cubic meters of high-level waste and 665 cubic meters of intermediate-level waste - should have returned to Spain this year, but in two decades no government has been able to build a unified storage site to keep all of Spain's discarded radioactive material. A year ago, Prime Minister José Luis Rodríguez Zapatero made a public request for volunteer municipalities willing to play host to a storage facility for the next 70 years.

At the present time, each nuclear plant stores its own waste. Most facilities keep it inside spent fuel pools that are permanently cooled. But because these pools are saturated, the National Radioactive Waste Company (Enresa) has been building individual dry storage areas in Trillo and Zorita (Guadalajara) and is completing another one at Ascó (Tarragona).

In 2009, the Industry Ministry said it was extending Garoña's operating license until 2013 because that was the time that was needed to build a single nuclear storage site to take care of its radioactive waste. But two years have passed since then, and the storage site selection process remains forgotten in a drawer.

It is not a problem of volume, since all high-level waste put together would only take up 12,800 cubic meters, or 1/100th of the size of Santiago Bernabéu stadium, home to Real Madrid. It is simply a matter of political will.

The municipal and regional elections of May 22 provided support for the mayors who had volunteered to host a nuclear storage site, since all of them were reelected. Meanwhile, towns closest to nuclear power stations are demanding that the spent fuel pools be emptied out as soon as possible. They claim that the accident in Fukushima has proven the vulnerability of this type of facility. But environmentalists oppose building any storage site at all until a calendar for phasing out nuclear energy in Spain is produced.