1970 24-0 Trimble (officially Glouster High School at the time)
1971 58-0 Nelsonville-York
1972 45-0 Nelsonville-York
1973 48-0 Nelsonville-York
1974 0-0 Tie
1975 12-2 Trimble
1976 20-6 Nelsonville-York
1977 7-0 Trimble
1978 21-20 Nelsonville-York
1979 7-6 Trimble
1970s series record - Nelsonville-York 5-4-1
1980 41-0 Trimble
1981 40-12 Nelsonville-York
1982 28-12 Nelsonville-York
1983 6-6 Tie
1984 7-6 Trimble
1985 41-6 Trimble
1986 34-0 Nelsonville-York
1987 51-12 Nelsonville-York
1988 28-14 Nelsonville-York
1989 7-2 Trimble
1980s series record - Nelsonville-York 5-4-1
Overall series record - Nelsonville-York leads 10-8-2
1990 27-0 Nelsonville-York
1991 25-13 Nelsonville-York
1992 34-14 Nelsonville-York
1993 50-14 Nelsonville-York
1994 58-0 Nelsonville-York
1995 18-6 Nelsonville-York
1996 35-13 Nelsonville-York
1997 54-0 Nelsonville-York
1998 29-25 Nelsonville-York
1999 33-7 Nelsonville-York
1990s series record - Nelsonville-York 10-0
Overall series record - Nelsonville-York 20-8-2
2000 28-7 Nelsonville-York
2001 14-6 Trimble
2002 49-13 Nelsonville-York
2003 21-18 Nelsonville-York
2004 19-13 Trimble
2005 27-21 (ot) Trimble
2006 35-0 Nelsonville-York
2007 7-6 Trimble
2008 41-13 Nelsonville-York
2009 7-6 Nelsonville-York
2000s series record - Nelsonville-York 6-4
Overall series record - Nelsonville-York 26-12-2
2010 14-6 Nelsonville-York
2011 42-6 Nelsonville-York
2012 21-14 Trimble
2013 40-0 Trimble
2014 34-14 Trimble
2015 26-20 Nelsonville-York
2016 27-7 Nelsonville-York
2017 21-0 Nelsonville-York
2018 34-7 Trimble
2019 35-0 Trimble
2010s series record - Split - 5-5
Overall series record - Nelsonville-York 31-17-2
2020 34-28 Trimble
2021 7-6 Trimble
2022 16-0 Nelsonville-York
2023 14-12 Trimble
2024 21-14 Nelsonville-York
2025 34-8 Nelsonville-York
Series record to date - Nelsonville-York 34-20-2