INTRODUCTION
An estimated 840 million people in India use a solid-fuel cookstove (chulha) powered off wood or biomass, and forecasts indicate that by 2040 over 400 million people will still lack access to clean cooking facilities. Chulhas emit harmful pollutants and particulates that contribute to respiratory diseases, including chronic obstructive pulmonary disease and lung cancer. India has the second highest air pollution level worldwide and the largest number of people exposed to high levels of indoor air pollution (IAP) caused by solid-fuel cookstoves (Heath Effects Institute, 2019. State of Global Air 2019, Special Report, Boston). IAP, which disproportionally affects women and young children, was responsible for 482,000 deaths in India in 2017 alone, the largest number of deaths attributable to IAP worldwide. Furthermore around 100 million people in rural India do not have access to electricity. Despite a massive program of electrification of villages that has seen the number without electricity halve in the past five years, those without access remain among the most disadvantaged members of society. The average power consumption per capita of 50.5 W, remains well below that of developed countries. An Indian village is classed as electrified when only 10% of households and civic buildings have access to electricity. When electricity reaches a village, the cost of connection is often prohibitive, and the supply is unreliable. Chulhas operate at temperatures up to 600 °C, providing a ready supply of waste heat. A TE device is capable of converting this waste heat into useful electricity to power a fan for forced air circulation to improve combustion in the cookstove. In addition, a TE device affords a localized power source to fulfill basic needs in lighting, communication and mobile device charging.
We seek to bring the collective expertise of UK and Indian materials researchers to bear on this problem by developing materials for a TE generator that will use the heat from a cookstove to create 10 W of off-grid electrical power, sufficient to drive a 1.5 W fan for forced-air circulation and to power low-energy LED lighting (typically 5- 7 W). The project directly addresses UN Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) 3 (Good Health and Well-Being) and 7 (Affordable and Clean Energy) as it seeks to facilitate cleaner combustion and therefore reduce IAP, whilst simultaneously providing a large number of the population with a straightforward and accessible supply of electricity, without huge infrastructure costs. It offers the potential to make progress against Goal 3.4 (By 2030, reduce by one third premature mortality from non-communicable diseases...), 3.9 (By 2030, substantially reduce the number of deaths and illnesses from hazardous chemicals and air, water and soil pollution...), 7.1 (By 2030, ensure universal access to affordable, reliable and modern energy services) and 7.3 (By 2030, double the global rate of improvement in energy efficiency). In its potential to produce a step change in living conditions for those in rural communities in India, the project also impacts on other SDGs, in particular creating more sustainable communities (SDG 11) and resilience to environmental issues like climate change (SDG 13). There is also potential to create a new market for indigenous copper ores, thereby stimulating economic development.
A TE device consists of an array of n- and p-type semiconductors (Figure below) connected electrically in series and thermally in parallel. Performance is directly related to that of the component semiconductors, expressed in a dimensionless figure of merit, ZT = S2σT/κ, where S, σ and κ are the Seebeck coefficient, electrical and thermal conductivities, and S2σ is the power factor. The challenge in designing high-performance TE materials is the interdependence of each of the key parameters, S, σ and κ. The cost, abundance and safety of the materials are also important factors to consider. Proof-of-principle TE power generation in a (laboratory-constructed) cookstove using commercial Bi2Te3 devices has been demonstrated, but Bi2Te3 suffers from major disadvantages:
i. Scarcity of tellurium. Identified as one of the top 9 ‘at risk’ elements2 and on the US Government critical mineral list,3 tellurium is expensive ($82/kg). The amount of Te in the Earth crust (1 ppb) is insufficient for large-scale adoption of TE technology based on Bi2Te3.
ii. Inappropriate Temperature Range. The ZT of Bi2Te3 approaches unity around 100 °C but falls off sharply with increasing temperature, with material melting occurring at 580 °C. Consequently in a cookstove the device needs to be located where the heat is attenuated, meaning that the high-grade waste heat is not fully utilized.
iii. Toxicity. Tellurium and tellurium compounds are categorized as being of acute toxicity, which poses risks in a domestic setting.
The substantial improvements in ZT values of non-telluride TEs achieved in recent years have been realized at temperatures well above those generated in a cookstove. We will apply design principles, formulated in conjunction with computer modelling, to create TE materials specifically tailored to the 200 – 400 °C range, appropriate to chulhas. Target materials are related to Earth abundant sulphide minerals, including chalcopyrite, bornite and chalcocite, substantial reserves of which exist in the Indian copper belts including the Khetri, Singhbuhum, and Malanjkhand copper belts. The program of work is thus well-aligned with the natural resources of the country. Unlike tellurides, sulphur and sulphides do not have associated problems of acute toxicity.
Minerals for a TE device, which with a fan, will be incorporated into cookstoves to improve combustion and generate electricity.
AIMS & OBJECTIVES
The aim is to deliver new non-telluride TE materials, containing Earth-abundant elements, based on Indian mineral resources, able to generate electricity from waste heat in the temperature range 200 – 400 °C. In order to address this aim, we have formulated the following objectives:
To design and produce efficient and cost-effective TE materials, to facilitate TE power generation using cookstoves.
To align the development of n- and p-type semiconductors to the natural resources of India, by focusing on materials derived from copper sulphide ores.
To combine state-of-the-art computational and experimental methods to engineer ultralow thermal conductivity and excellent electronic transport properties into mineral–related phases.
To identify optimal routes for the effective transformation of mineral samples into materials with good TE performance.
To engage with end users, NGOs and the Indian government to formulate a design for a TE generator for incorporation in a chuhla to improve combustion, reduce IAP and generate useful electrical power. We will identify and address barriers to implementation, including cultural issues, to develop a pathway towards exploitation of materials advances.
This proposal is at the forefront of current research in TE materials. The TE community is increasingly aware of the outstanding potential of copper-containing sulphide minerals, owing to the combination of excellent TE performance, abundance and low toxicity. This is reflected by the rapidly growing number of high-impact publications on minerals such as tetrahedrites and chalcocite. Here we will address key challenges in this field: discovery of an n-type sulphide with comparable performance to existing p-type candidates; stabilization of materials with phonon-liquid electron-crystal behaviour (e.g. chalcocite); and gaining predictive understanding of the effect of interfaces and nanostructuring across multiple length scales on both electrical and thermal transport properties.
MAXIMISING POTENTIAL IMPACT IN INDIA
The project brings together leading groups in India and the UK to develop a novel physical science-based solution to a problem of fundamental importance to health and development in rural India: the elimination of IAP arising from chulhas, whilst simultaneously providing electricity to remote communities. Although the project is one of fundamental materials research, this is an essential first-step to the development of TE generators. Progression from the creation of novel high-performance materials to the construction of a working generator would be overly ambitious, within the restricted timescale of the project. Therefore to maximise the long-term impact of the work, a follow-on project at a higher TRL, informed by the outcomes of WP5, will be formulated. We would seek to engage with industrial partners in executing the follow-on project. Wherever possible we will seek partners located in India, including companies in the supply chain (e.g. Hindustan Copper Ltd) and in the manufacturing sector (e.g. Tata Group). This is a particularly timely point in the development of the electricity supply infrastructure in India to be addressing this problem. A large investment program has reduced the number without access to a distributed supply to ‘only’ 100 million. Inevitably, many of the communities yet to benefit from this program are however, located in more remote (and therefore difficult and expensive) regions to bring onto the grid. The ability to generate electricity from a cookstove would help to fill this gap.
The project aligns closely with UK national priorities, given its focus on materials for Energy Recovery. Investments to catalyze progress on new energy solutions to support Clean Growth and multi-disciplinary research in new energy technologies are identified as priorities in the EPSRC 2019 Delivery Plan. TE materials capable of providing electrical power from waste heat, have the potential to contribute significantly to the targeted 80% reduction in CO2 emissions by 2050 set by the UK Climate Change Act (2008) and the EU target of 20% improvement in energy efficiency by 2020. In its contribution to sustainable energy, the outcome of this project is directly relevant to the Resilient Nation element of the Outcomes Framework of the RCUK 2016-20 Strategic Priorities, whilst also contributing to the Productive Nation element through development of advanced products. Achieving high-performance in TE materials also relates directly to the theme supporting emerging technologies of the UK Government Industrial Strategy.