Reactivity, Prediction and Intervention

Call for Papers/Abstracts:

Workshop: Reactivity, Prediction and Intervention in the Human Sciences

August 18-20, 2021 in Helsinki

https://sites.google.com/view/thereactivityproject/home

The workshop Reactivity, Prediction and Intervention in the Human Sciences is the third of a series of three workshops on Reactivity in the Human Sciences generously funded by The Joint Committee for Nordic Research Councils in the Humanities and Social Sciences (NOS-HS). Its focus is on the effects of reactivity on human sciences’ ability to predict and intervene effectively on the social world - a phenomenon variously discussed under the labels of reactivity, reflexivity, self-fulfilling prophecies, and performativity.

Both philosophers and social scientists have been worrying about social scientific predictions whose truth value might change by becoming known, about the usefulness and legitimacy of social measures when people change their behaviour as a reaction to being measured and about the epistemic and moral dangers posed by models and theories of social phenomena becoming true simply in virtue of being performed as such. Yet, in spite of the long history of several of these debates, it still remains unclear whether reactivity is in fact a phenomenon unique to the human sciences, whether it is an insurmountable problem for such sciences, and more generally, what its methodological, epistemic and moral implications are.

Questions to be addressed include, but are not limited to:

  • Is reactivity a problem for theory confirmation?

  • To what extent is reactivity a problem for prediction and/or intervention?

  • Are the concepts of performativity, reflexivity, self-fulfilling prophecies, etc., just different labels for the same phenomenon, or do they refer to genuinely different kinds of phenomena?

  • Are there ways of mitigating the possible unintended effects of reactive measures?

  • What responsibilities do scientists have for the performative effects of their theories or models?

Confirmed speakers:

Anna Alexandrova (Cambridge University)

Carsten Bergenholtz (Aarhus University)

Jacob Bush (Aarhus University)

Caterina Marchionni (University of Helsinki)

Uskali Mäki (University of Helsinki)

Robert Northcott (Birkbeck College)

Uwe Peters (University of Bonn)

Ekaterina Svetlova (University of Leicester)

Call for abstracts

Up to four contributed papers will be accepted for presentation at the workshop. We invite submission of abstracts of maximum 1000 words.

Please send an abstract no later than April 16, 2021 to Caterina Marchionni at Caterina.marchionni@helsinki.fi. Travel expenses within Europe and accommodation will be covered. Submissions from early career scholars and/or from scholars in the Nordic countries are encouraged. If you have any questions, please do not hesitate to contact Caterina at Caterina.marchionni@helsinki.fi

Dates and Deadlines


Submission Deadline: April 16, 2021


Notifications: May 14, 2021

Workshop: August 18-20, 2021

Conference Venue

https://www.hanaholmen.fi - a hotel conference center located in the immediate surroundings of Helsinki with a view on the Finnish archipelago.

EJPS Topical Collection

On the same theme of the workshop series we are also organising a Topical Collection for the European Journal of Philosophy of Science. The full call for papers can be found here: https://philsci.eu/Reactivity/. Submission to the Topical Collection is open to anyone interested in reactivity, including of course participants at our workshops.

Organizers:

Caterina Marchionni (University of Helsinki)

Marion Godman (Aarhus University)

Julie Zahle (University of Bergen)