My thoughts on homages

Homage Watches: My Love-Hate Affair (and Why I Changed My Mind)

Let's be honest, homage watches are a contentious topic. Just a few months ago, I was a huge advocate, chanting the mantra, "Paganis for the win! Why pay more for a Seiko with the same movement?"

In a way, I was right. Homages often boast better specifications and lower price tags than their well-known counterparts. It seemed like a no-brainer!

But my perspective has shifted. Here's why:

Value Retention: A Harsh Reality

I was initially captivated by the "value for money" proposition of homages. However, is it truly "good value" to invest in three $100 homages that depreciate like crazy? This hit me hard when I realized I could've bought a genuine Citizen Tsuyosa with the same amount spent on homages. My collection, worthless in resale terms, could've been something truly special.

Horology: Beyond Specs

Yes, specifications are important, but watches are steeped in rich history and innovation. As I delved deeper into the hobby, I discovered the fascinating stories behind established brands. These weren't just timepieces; they were testaments to horological advancements. Looking at my homages, I couldn't help but feel a pang of disconnect.

Let's face it, watches are mostly sentimental these days. While their practical function arguably pales in comparison to smartwatches, the emotional connection remains. Learning about a watch's history adds another layer to that connection, a layer missing with homages.

The Spark of Regret: A Slow Burn

It wasn't immediate, but a delayed sense of regret began to creep in. While the initial "value for money" argument held some weight, it gradually paled in comparison to the longing for something more. Unlike the instant gratification of ticking specs off a list, the appreciation for a watch's heritage and emotional weight builds over time. Think about it: would someone who owns an Orient Bambino ever regret not buying the San Martin homage? There's a certain soul missing in copycat designs. Additionally, owning a genuine piece, even an affordable one, often translates to a higher likelihood of repairing it in case of damage. Homages, on the other hand, might not inspire the same level of investment. 

Pride and Ownership

I wanted to feel proud of what I wore on my wrist. Sadly, with homages, I felt like an imposter. Sharing my watch collection felt awkward, and engaging in watch discussions was a constant struggle.

It's difficult to put into words, almost indescribable, but I lacked a sense of genuine connection with my homages. They were simply objects, devoid of the rich history and emotional weight that comes with owning a genuine piece.

Ironically, my Casio (my first watch) brings me immense comfort. I know its history and wear it with pride. The realization that most of my collection lacked that same emotional connection was a wake-up call.

Closing Thoughts

There's nothing inherently wrong with homages, but as my knowledge expands, I find myself increasingly disconnected from my own collection. This journey, from fervent supporter to cautious observer, has taught me valuable lessons about value, appreciation, and the unique allure of genuine watchmaking.