"Firm-level Technology Adoption in Times of Crisis" (joint with Melanie Arntz, Michael Böhm, Georg Graetz, Florian Lehmer and Cäcilia Lipowski), Major Revision at European Economic Review.
Annualized investment rates in frontier technology before and during Covid-19
The figure shows the investment rates in office and production frontier technology before versus during the Covid-19 pandemic. Investments during the pandemic are further categorized based on whether
they were made due to the pandemic. Only main investments included. Annualized numbers from Table 3 in the paper are given that the period before (during) the pandemic was on average approximately 3.54 (2.11) years long.
Abstract: We investigate the diffusion of frontier technologies across German firms before and during the Covid-19 crisis. Our analysis tracks the nature, timing, and pandemic-related motivations behind technology investments, using tailor-made longitudinal survey data linked to administrative worker-firm records. Technologies adopted after the onset of the pandemic increasingly facilitated remote work and mitigated the negative employment effects of the crisis. Overall, however, investments in frontier technologies declined sharply, equivalent to a loss of 1.4 years of pre-pandemic investment activity. This procyclical adoption pattern is particularly striking since the pandemic created clear incentives to experiment with new technologies. Our findings highlight how short-run fluctuations may influence medium-run economic growth through their impact on technology diffusion.
Press: Der Spiegel, t3n, Heise Online, ZEW press release, Mannheimer Morgen, Markenartikel, IZA Newsroom.
Versions: Published as ZEW Discussion Paper No 24-057. See also ZEW Policy Brief No. 24-14.
“Minimum Wages and the Rise in Solo Self-Employment” (joint with Ulrich Zierahn-Weilage and Angelika Ganserer), updated January 2024, Major Revision at Industrial and Labor Relations Review.
Effects of a minimum wage introduction on the share of solo self-employed individuals (synthetic difference-in-differences)
The figure shows the estimates for East and West Germany based on the synthetic difference-indifferences outlined in Equation 1. The 95 % confidence intervals are based on bootstrapped standard errors with 100 replications. The dashed line represents the introduction of minimum wages in 1997.
Abstract: Within a quasi-experimental setting, we show that the first-time adoption of industry-specific minimum wages led to a doubling in the share of solo self-employment in areas with a strong bite. We explain this with the minimum wage-driven cost shock, which led to reduced labor demand and wages for dependent employment while creating incentives for independent employment. Our results suggest that dependent workers have been involuntarily pushed into more precarious alternative work arrangements, with poorer social security and lower incomes. Such unintended side effects are likely to occur when the minimum wage is set extraordinarily high, especially during an economic downturn.
Press: IZA Newsroom, ZEW News.
Versions: Earlier versions published as IZA Discussion Paper No. 15283 as well as ZEW Discussion Paper No. 22-024 .
“Frontier Technology Adopters and the Aggregate Decline of Routine Jobs” (joint with Melanie Arntz, Sabrina Genz, Florian Lehmer, and Ulrich Zierahn-Weilage), 2024, R&R at Journal of Economic Behavior & Organization.
De-routinization by adoption group between 2011 and 2016, Germany
The figure depicts the change in the share of occupations by task domain among the workforce employed at adoption group g. Weighted with time-varying employment-weighted firm stratification weights.
Abstract: This paper highlights the nuanced relationship between firms' technology adoption and the employment structure of the economy. Leveraging a novel firm survey that we link to German administrative employment records, we categorize firms based on their technology adoption status. We find that frontier technology adopters significantly contribute to the economy-wide decline in routine and rise of non-routine cognitive jobs, primarily through firms with complementary workforce skills. Our results suggest (1) a continued de-routinization with frontier technology adoption, (2) the importance of complementary skills for the decline of routine jobs, and (3) a fallacy of drawing economy-wide conclusions from within-firm workforce adjustments.
Press: IZA Newsroom
Awards: Best Poster Award 2018 of the European Association of Labour Economics (EALE) .
Versions: Earlier version published as IZA Discussion Paper No 16740 and ZEW Discussion Paper.
Share of AI-Involved Firms by Year and Country (2016-2024)
Note: The figure reports the cumulative share of firms mentioning AI on their websites between 2016 and 2024 based on the MAP-AI indicator. Once a firm is classified as using AI, it remains classified as using AI in all subsequent years, provided the website remains active.
Abstract: We develop a novel firm-level indicator of Artificial Intelligence (AI) adoption in Europe by applying a Large Language Model to more than three million firm websites from Belgium, France, Germany, and Luxembourg (2016–2024). The method detects not only whether firms adopt AI, but also their role in the AI ecosystem and the type of AI technology they employ. The share of AI-active firms grew from 1\% in 2016 to 12\% in 2024, with acceleration after 2022. We document a structural transformation: the ecosystem is shifting from specialized AI core technology providers toward broader AI adopters, signaling widespread diffusion. While adoption is concentrated among larger, younger, knowledge-intensive firms in urban innovation clusters, workforce skills emerge as a key factor associated with AI adoption. Our skill-level analysis suggests that foundational Data skills form the necessary base for adoption, while specialized AI skills act as strong complements.
Versions: IZA Discussion Paper No 18434
Data: https://github.com/MAP-AI-data/data
Panel shows the evolution of the index of demand for each skill group over the same period. All values are aggregated across occupations and industries using EU-LFS employment weights.
Abstract: The capabilities of AI have expanded rapidly in recent years; yet, our understanding how AI affects labor demand remains very limited. We use 31 million online job ads from four European countries to investigate how the demand for skills and occupations has shifted in response to AI. Our analysis relies on advanced ML models to extract and classify skills from job ads in multiple languages. We document a significant growth in the demand for AI, data and prediction skills in exposed occupations, but a decline in social skills since 2018. We also observe significant shifts in the skill sets of exposed occupations pointing towards greater skill specialization. Finally, we show that there is some indication that there is exposed occupations become less labor-intensive, but that employers demand more workers in these occupations.
"Impact of Firm-Level Technology Adoption on Workers" (joint with Sabrina Genz and Florian Lehmer), 2025, currently in revision.
Figure shows 2sls coefficients for the accumulated number of days employed. All models are weighted with firm stratification weights. All models control for demographic, employment and firm characteristics and sector and region fixed effects. Whiskers show the 90% confidence intervals
Abstract: We study how firm-level technology adoption affects worker outcomes using linked employer–employee data for Germany that combine administrative records with a survey of 2,032 establishments (2011–2016). We classify technologies into established digital and frontier technologies (e.g., AI, AR, 3D printing) and estimate their causal effects using an instrumental-variables strategy that exploits firms’ pre-adoption technological readiness, measured by the historical share of workers with technology-related skills. Technology adoption increases employment stability and wages, with substantially larger gains from established digital technologies. Effects are highly heterogeneous: workers in occupations undergoing task restructuring and those performing complex tasks benefit most. Crucially, returns depend on firms’ deployment strategies. Technologies that augment labor generate sizable gains, whereas substitutive adoption yields limited benefits. These results highlight that the effects of technological change depend on how technologies are integrated into production.
Press (based on older version): IZA Newsroom, NBC
Versions: earlier version published as IZA Discussion Paper No 14626 and ZEW Discussion Paper No. 21-073.
Abstract: This paper examines how the adoption of Artificial Intelligence (AI) affects employment, workforce composition, and productivity in European firms. We combine a novel firm-level measure of realized AI adoption, derived from large-scale analysis of firms’ website content, with administrative employer--employee records and firm balance-sheet data. To identify the effects of AI adoption, we exploit variation in the timing of adoption across firms and implement an event-study design that traces firm outcomes before and after the first observed adoption of AI. This approach allows us to characterize the dynamic adjustment of firms and to assess whether adopters and non-adopters exhibit similar pre-trends prior to adoption. We study how AI adoption changes total employment, the composition of the workforce by skill, and firm performance measures such as productivity and revenues. By providing firm-level evidence on the timing and consequences of AI adoption, the paper contributes to the emerging literature on technological change, skill demand, and firm dynamics in Europe.
Abstract: This project investigates how technological change reshapes labor demand and the content of work over the long run. Using a novel dataset of digitized newspaper job advertisements from Luxembourg spanning nearly two centuries, we apply large language models and natural language processing techniques to extract structured information on job titles, tasks, and skills. We link these data to historical measures of technological breakthroughs to analyze how occupations emerge, evolve, or disappear in response to innovation. Our approach allows us to trace changes in job content, identify shifting skill requirements, and quantify the extent to which different occupations are exposed to technological change. By providing a detailed, task-level perspective on labor market transformation, the project offers new evidence on how technological progress reshapes the nature of work and informs current debates on automation and skill demand.
Abstract: Much of the literature on the labor market impact of minimum wages has focused on employment or displacement effects. We investigate instead whether the adoption of minimum wages encourages firms to invest in capital intensity or outsource some of their production steps. Our analysis exploits rich balance sheet data, matched with administrative data, on firms that became exposed to industry-specific minimum wages in Germany. The data allows us to investigate whether incumbent firms with more scope for capital-labor substitution increase their capital intensity, and/or whether firms entering the treated industries raise their capital intensity after the minimum wage introduction. We also look at the effect of minimum wages on outsourcing, and show how firms adjust their workforce alongside changes in capital expenditures.