Summary; Discussion & Completion

After presenting the rich data from oral histories and archival documents, this chapter now turns to synthesizing the primary findings of the study before entering a broader discussion of their meaning and application. This research, which combined oral history with archival investigation, yielded several significant findings that both enrich and complicate the historical record of Telford. These results can be grouped into two main categories: specific historical discoveries and overarching thematic interpretations.

Key Historical and Factual Findings:

·         The single most significant discovery was the unearthing of primary evidence for the Franklin Academy, a nearly forgotten 19th-century institution whose students debated remarkably progressive topics, including the rights of Native Americans.

·         Through archival cross-referencing, this study corrected the misidentification of a widely circulated photograph of the Embree House.

·         Court documents provided the official names and leadership for several key community entities previously known only through oral history, including the Telford Hosiery Mills, the Ladies Aid Society, and the Junior O.U.A.M. Council #139.

.

Key Thematic and Interpretive Findings:

·         The oral histories revealed a powerful and consistent narrative of decline among lifelong residents, who overwhelmingly associate the community’s downturn with the loss of the railroad and the construction of Highway 11 East.

·         However, a deeper analysis of the data suggests that this narrative is more accurately framed as one of evolution. Telford transformed from a self-contained production and commercial hub into a residential community, trading local economic autonomy for greater regional access and convenience.

·         The central argument of this research paper is that the most profound loss for Telford was not economic, but the erosion of its community "conscience"—the spirit of intellectual and moral inquiry embodied by the forgotten Franklin Academy, which represents a deeper, more significant heritage than lost storefronts alone.

With these findings established, the question remains: 

How are we to make sense of these past events for the benefit of the Telford community as a historically significant place today?

Part of the answer, perhaps, lies in our perception of and definition of the past which “...is not something fixed and unalterable...” as surmised by famed author Aldous Huxley ((1954) 2009, 171). He explains that, from his perspective, the facts of the past “...are rediscovered by every succeeding generation, its values reassessed...” and “...its meanings redefined in the context of present tastes and preoccupations.” With that said, as we move forward with a more critical examination of facts, after much gnashing of teeth, we may agree that, regardless of origin, all residents of Telford today may be regarded as “transplants.” Prior to the arrival of Europeans and their African slaves, indigenous peoples lived on these lands. There is no doubt. What of their history here in Telford? What about the history of the slaves who were forcibly transplanted to our area? The lack of historic documentation for these “no people,” as referred to by longtime professor of English at Vanderbilt University, Donald Davidson, put them “...in danger of losing their history, and in losing this, their identity and their citizenship (Van West, 2001, 335).” He was also referring to all the people displaced in the aftermath of all those massive dam-building projects from the 20th century by the Tennessee Valley Authority (TVA). By comparing the plight of indigenous, enslaved, and disenfranchised people of more modern times, and grouping them as “no people,” with a common plight (no history), we can see the effects of past economic practices and imply that this approach may not have resulted without intent. After all, “Where there is no vision, the people perish (Proverbs 29:18).” Perhaps this applies just as much to the past, as much as it does to the future. While Davidson had a cure in mind, I personally find his “antiquated” perspectives about race reprehensible. However, he and many of his cohorts did believe “...that genuine culture was rooted in the organic traditions of the folk, the vitality of which derived from a firm sense of place (328).”

Rather than relying on Davidson’s controversial external academic framework for conclusive analyses, Telford has a story of 20th-century transformation as told by the very generation that lived it, as captured through the perspective of our five volunteer participants. The losses of the train depot in 1962 and next passenger service, the school closings, local shop losses, the disappearance of local doctors and pharmacies, et cetera—these are tangible losses of a specific way of life. From the perspective of our participants, these losses indicate decline, yet they also speak of community evolutionary shift from a self-contained, railroad-centric rural town to a residential community. This common pattern represents a natural evolution or economic transition. Undoubtedly, the construction of Highway 11 East “took us off the map,” as noted by Mrs. McFeature; “bypassed Limestone, Telford, and Jonesborough,” as stated by Mr. Shanks, and was the cause for the failure of local businesses, as seen by Mr. Daniels; however as noted by Mrs. Wheeler, the highway “...made it easier for people to get out of the community and back for major grocery shopping.” While this may be viewed as the story of economic loss, it is in fact the story of an evolutionary trade-off of local commerce for regional access and individual convenience. Telford evolved from a self-contained economic hub into a residential community whose residents take part in a wider regional economy.

Additionally, while the loss of the Telford Agricultural Manufacturing Company, all the flour mills, the blacksmith shops, the poultry farms, and the general stores, et cetera, may be seen as profound economic decline, it is also indicative of Telford’s evolution from a place of production (making kettles and stoves, milling flour, shipping eggs), to a place valued for its residential qualities of quietness and location where people no longer move to for a job, but for a place to build a home. And finally, in the voices of our participants, while Mrs. McFeature’s beautiful memory of a “porch-to-porch" community where “they were out to help you” is contrasted with today, where she doesn’t know anyone, and Mr. Daniels feels that “strangers” have moved in and aren’t as friendly, may both indicate a loss of community cohesion. However, as noted by Mr. Wolfe’s crucial observation, the Telford Ruritan Club “helped cement Telford together” and “keep the Telford Spirit going.” Social life in the community evolved from an informal web of daily interactions to a more organized, event-based identity in 1961 with the formation of the Telford Ruritan Club, and the existence of the Ladies’ Aid Society and Telford Community Club in the past shows that this has always been a way for local citizens to organize themselves. So, the answer to the question is that by understanding both the painful decline and the resilient evolution of Telford as a community throughout the 20th century, we can embrace the opportunities of the future through the past.

Telford is at a crossroads. It can continue down a path toward becoming a place of anonymous subdivisions, or it can choose to reclaim its unique identity by embracing the full, complex story of its evolution. In 2026, the United States will celebrate the 250th anniversary of its independence. This “fork in the road” is an opportunity not to simply use Telford as an example of a once-thriving, self-sufficient community with a strong identity diminished by modernization, globalized economics, and demographic change, but as a place where, in the 1860s, students were debating the rights of Native Americans; it was home to a pioneer abolitionist; and, a place where blacks and whites alike “played ball as a family.” This history is also evidence of a place where people were intellectually engaged, morally complex, and surprisingly progressive. While many may feel Telford has declined, as shown by lost businesses and highway bypasses, this focus misses the point of what was truly lost. Telford was not just a place with a railroad depot; it was a place with a conscience, a place of industry, and a place teeming with complex ideas. The real tragedy of becoming “no people” isn’t just losing the memory of Campbell’s store; it’s losing the memory of the Franklin Academy and the spirit of inquiry it stood for. The questions debated in the Athenian Hall in 1868—about the rights of indigenous peoples and the rightful ownership of land—are not quaint relics; they are the very same questions that challenge our national conscience today, proving that the intellectual life of this small community was deeply engaged in the great, unfinished conversations of America. If a place of higher learning such as this can be forgotten, how much more easily can the stories of everyday life, business, and community be erased? The act of recovering this history naturally illuminates areas where the work of discovery is not yet complete.

SUGGESTIONS FOR FURTHER RESEARCH

This study, while providing a new framework for understanding Telford’s evolution, also opens several promising avenues for future research. The findings presented here raise new questions and highlight areas where additional scholarship is needed:

1.      A Contemporary Ethnography: 

As noted in the limitations, this study focused on the vital perspective of lifelong elder residents. A crucial next step would be a parallel study focused on the experiences of "transplants" and younger generations to answer the question: What draws new residents to Telford, and how are they constructing the community's new identity?

2.      Archaeological and Archival Investigation: 

Two major historical mysteries remain unsolved. Further research, potentially including archaeological survey work, is needed to pinpoint the exact location of the Franklin Academy. Likewise, a deeper dive into land deeds and local records may yet reveal the precise location of key businesses like Michael Baines’ old mill which was supposedly the first on this side of the Blue Ridge Mountains.

3.      The "Fictitious Railroad": 

The landscape features identified by Mr. Robert Shanks suggest the possibility of a pre-ET&V railroad bed. This extraordinary claim warrants a dedicated interdisciplinary study, combining historical geography, engineering history, and further oral history to investigate this potential hidden transportation network.

4.      A Study of Civic Engagement: 

The limited participation in the History Harvest suggests a potential gap between a passive appreciation for history and active community engagement. A sociological or mixed-methods study could explore the barriers and opportunities for historical preservation in a residential, unincorporated community like Telford.

Next year, in 2026, we have an opportunity to make a difference. It is my hope that together we can all, “transplants” and “lifers” alike, work toward a common goal of ensuring that future generations are provided with historic insight into the development and evolution of a quiet little place in Washington County, Tennessee where agriculture used to be the primary means of subsistence and wealth. The history of the Franklin Academy debating the rights of Native Americans, or Elihu Embree’s abolitionist paper, are part of the American story and belong to everyone in Telford, not just those with deep family roots. To that end, the author has worked with Mrs. Linda Dunn, current Vice President of the Telford Ruritan Club, to produce a brochure about Telford and its full and amazing history in an effort to stimulate further interest across generations throughout the community toward the future production of a more complete archive of historic information about the Telford area. The brochure (Figure 23) asks “What’s in your attic? In a dusty box, a forgotten scrapbook, or an old trunk, you might hold a piece of Telford’s story. An old photograph, a business receipt, a letter from a relative—these are the hidden gems that bring our community’s history to life. The Telford Ruritan Club is working to preserve these memories before they are lost. If you have something you would be willing to share (we can photograph it, so you can keep the original), please contact Mr. J.D. Banks of the Telford Ruritan Club at jdbanks64@gmail.com / 937-347-7235.”

As one chapter in Telford's history ends, a new narrative quietly begins to take shape. What draws new residents to these winding roads and pastoral fields? Perhaps it is the very stillness born of economic transformation—a longing for rootedness, for a slower rhythm beyond the blur of the highway. The challenge now facing the Telford Ruritan Club, and the broader community, is not merely to preserve the past but to stitch it meaningfully into the present. Their task is to weave Telford’s rich and layered legacy—its debates, its conscience, its unvarnished character—into the living tapestry of what this place is becoming.

Figure 23. Telford Ruritan Club Historic Brochure