How We Research
We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
Updated: 2026-09-22 · 7 min read · Independent comparison
• TEHAUX Black Carbon Steel — biggest strength: carbon steel construction with a built-in handle, sized at 20 x 19 x 8 cm, so you can lift it, carry it and serve from it without burning your fingers.
• TEHAUX Black Carbon Steel — biggest trade-off: it's pitched as a frying pot and pizza pan rather than a cake mold, so if cakes are your main goal, the shape and height may not suit you.
• Generic Iron Cake Mold — biggest strength: food-grade iron with a stated fit for air fryer models HD9925, HD9220, HD9232, HD9233 and HD9641, plus a dishwasher-safe, non-stick surface.
• Generic Iron Cake Mold — biggest trade-off: it's a fixed 7-inch drum at roughly 6.89 x 6.50 x 2.76 inches, so if your air fryer isn't one of the listed models, you're guessing on fit.
• Who each pick is for: TEHAUX if you want one handled pan for frying and pizza; Generic Iron if you want a cake drum that's declared compatible with specific Philips air fryers.
The TEHAUX Black Carbon Steel is best understood as a handled cooking vessel for the air fryer rather than a classic baking pan. It's made of carbon steel, finished in black, and measures 20 x 19 x 8 cm — that's about 7.87 x 7.48 x 3.15 inches, with a weight of just 7.2 ounces. That light weight matters more than it sounds: a pan you can lift one-handed out of a hot basket is a pan you'll actually use on a weeknight.
What it does best is the combination of a handle and a shallow, open shape. The handle is the whole point. Air fryer baskets get hot, and most flat pans force you to reach in with tongs or a mitt and hope for the best. A handle turns that into a simple lift. The carbon steel body is described as durable and practical, and the surface is presented as easy to use and clean up. In my opinion, that "easy to clean" claim is the one that decides whether an accessory stays in the drawer or ends up in a cupboard graveyard.
Who should buy it: anyone who wants a multi-purpose pan for the air fryer — frying small batches, reheating leftovers, or using it as a pizza pan. It's also a genuinely sensible gift for a friend, family member or co-worker who's deep into air fryer cooking, because it's the kind of accessory people don't think to buy for themselves.
Who should skip it: if you're baking layer cakes or anything that needs a defined round tin with straight walls, this isn't that product. Its dimensions are close to square, and the description leans toward frying and pizza rather than cake. Also skip it if you specifically need a mold declared compatible with a named air fryer model — TEHAUX doesn't list one.
The Generic Iron Cake Mold is a purpose-built 7-inch cake drum (18 cm) made from food-grade iron. Its headline feature is fitment: it's stated to fit air fryer models HD9925, HD9220, HD9232, HD9233 and HD9641. If you own one of those, that's a real advantage — you're not measuring and hoping, you're buying something the maker says is designed for your machine.
The material story is straightforward. Food-grade iron, described as free from harmful substances, with a heat-safe cooking surface and no metallic aftertaste. It's also dishwasher safe, and the smooth non-stick surface is meant to stop food clinging, so a quick hand wash usually does the job. Its compact footprint — roughly 6.89 x 6.50 x 2.76 inches, weighing between 12.2 and 15.6 ounces — makes it easy to handle and store, which is more than you can say for a lot of bakeware.
Versatility is where it punches above its name. Beyond cakes, it's listed for french fries, onion rings, chicken strips, grilled vegetables, pizza, biscuits, cheese sticks, corn dogs and broccoli. That's a broad brief for something called a cake mold, and it means the pan can earn its shelf space even if you rarely bake. It's also marked oven safe, so it isn't locked to the air fryer.
Who should buy it: owners of the listed air fryer models who want a cake drum plus a general-purpose baking and roasting pan, and anyone who values dishwasher-safe cleanup.
Who should skip it: if your air fryer isn't one of the five named models, the fit is unverified — measure your basket first. And if you want a handle, this one doesn't have one.
• Best for lifting hot food safely → TEHAUX Black Carbon Steel. The handle is a genuine ergonomic difference, not a marketing line.
• Best for guaranteed fit with a specific air fryer → Generic Iron Cake Mold. The five named compatible models remove the guesswork.
• Best for baking cakes specifically → Generic Iron Cake Mold. It's a 7-inch cake drum; that's the job it was designed for.
• Best for frying, reheating and pizza → TEHAUX Black Carbon Steel. The shallow handled pot shape suits oil-free frying and flatbreads better.
• Best for easy cleanup → Generic Iron Cake Mold. Dishwasher safe is a concrete claim; TEHAUX only says "easy to clean up."
• Best for oven use → Generic Iron Cake Mold. It's explicitly marked oven safe; TEHAUX is positioned around the air fryer.
• Best for gifting → TEHAUX Black Carbon Steel. It's described as a present choice for friends, family and co-workers, and the handle makes it feel like a finished tool.
• Best for storage in a small kitchen → Generic Iron Cake Mold. Its compact footprint and lighter stated range make it easier to tuck away.
• Best if your air fryer model isn't listed → TEHAUX Black Carbon Steel. No fitment claim means no fitment letdown.
If I were buying for myself, I'd take the TEHAUX Black Carbon Steel. The handle is the deciding factor for me — reaching into a hot air fryer basket with tongs is the part of air frying I like least, and a handled pot solves that every single time you cook. I also like that it works as a frying vessel and a pizza pan, so it covers more of my weeknight cooking than a cake tin would.
That said, this is a fit question as much as a preference one. If you own one of the listed Philips models and cakes are the priority, the Generic Iron Cake Mold is the smarter buy: declared compatibility, dishwasher-safe cleanup, oven-safe use and a much wider food list. Check the current price on Amazon before you commit — and if you're set on the cake mold, confirm your air fryer model matches the list first.
It's described as an air fryer frying pot that also works as a pizza pan. Its shape is closer to square than round, and the description centers on frying, so I'd treat it as a multi-purpose pan rather than a dedicated cake mold.
Only if your model is one of these: HD9925, HD9220, HD9232, HD9233 or HD9641. The maker states that compatibility directly. For any other air fryer, measure your basket against the roughly 6.89 x 6.50 x 2.76 inch footprint before buying.
The Generic Iron Cake Mold wins on paper — it's explicitly dishwasher safe with a smooth non-stick surface. The TEHAUX pan is described as easy to use and clean up, but no dishwasher claim is made, so plan on hand washing.
Both are metal pans — carbon steel for the TEHAUX, food-grade iron for the Generic. Neither sheet gives a coating thickness or warranty, so durability comes down to how you treat them: avoid harsh abrasives and dry them properly, and either should hold up to regular home use.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.
See also: ACWIEOIB UCGAOIOQ Air Fryer vs Generic Air Fryer Conversion, HQT Professional Rubber Bumper vs Generic 2.6QT, Empowered Cooks Cathy Yoder's Air vs Generic Air Fryer Cooking