We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
Updated: 2026-09-23 · 6 min read · Independent comparison
If you want a liner that is cut to sit flat in a square 8QT basket and gives you the most sheets for everyday air frying, choose TCSNOE Air Fryer Paper; if you need a round liner with raised edges that holds oil and sauce in and fits a wider range of 8–12 QT baskets, choose Empowered Cooks Cathy Yoder's Round.
• TCSNOE Air Fryer Paper — biggest strength: 125 pre-cut 9x9 inch square sheets sized specifically for 8QT square air fryers like the Chefman Crispinator and TurboFry Touch XL, with a 450°F heat ceiling.
• TCSNOE Air Fryer Paper — biggest trade-off: It's a flat square sheet, so there are no raised sides to pool juices and sauces, and being square it may not sit cleanly in a round basket.
• Empowered Cooks Cathy Yoder's Round — biggest strength: 128 round 9-inch sheets with raised edges that contain grease, and a fit range spanning most 8–12 QT air fryer baskets.
• Empowered Cooks Cathy Yoder's Round — biggest trade-off: Its heat resistance tops out at 425°F, lower than the TCSNOE's 450°F, and a round sheet can leave the corners of a square basket unprotected.
• Who each pick is for: Go TCSNOE if your air fryer is an 8QT square model and you want maximum basket coverage on the bottom; go Empowered Cooks if you own a round or larger 8–12 QT basket and cook greasy, saucy food that runs.
TCSNOE's liners are a fit-first product. They're built as 9x9 inch squares specifically to be compatible with the Chefman Crispinator 6-in-1 8QT, and they also list compatibility with the Chefman TurboFry Touch XL 8QT and the Easy-View 8QT. If your fryer is one of those, the geometry just works — the square sits in the square basket and covers the base rather than floating over it.
What it does best is straightforward protection. The paper is unbleached, BPA-free parchment, food-safe for direct contact, and rated to withstand up to 450°F without burning. It's non-stick and oil-proof, so grease, crumbs and sauces stay on the sheet instead of baking onto the basket. You get 125 pre-cut sheets — no trimming, no cutting a roll to size. Place, cook, toss. The brand also notes it's fine in the microwave, steamer and oven, so it's not a single-appliance purchase.
Who should skip it: if you own a round basket, or a unit outside that 8QT square family, the fit advantage disappears. And if you regularly cook wings, fish or saucy dishes, the flat sheet has no lip to hold runoff — you'll be relying on the paper itself to soak it up rather than on a raised wall. Also note the brand's own instruction: don't put the liner in during preheating, and make sure food holds it flat against the basket.
Empowered Cooks Cathy Yoder's Round: Who It's For
Empowered Cooks takes the opposite approach: the paper does the containing. These are 9-inch round sheets with raised edges, and that lip is the whole point. Oil, juices and sticky sauces pool inside the liner instead of running off into the basket. For greasy favorites — wings, fish, frozen snacks — that's a real difference in how much scrubbing you do afterward.
The other half of the pitch is sturdiness. The brand describes these as thicker, sturdier paper sized to lie flat and hold shape from start to finish, rather than curling, floating or tearing mid-cook — a common complaint with thin liners in a high-airflow basket. They're PFAS-free, BPA-free, non-toxic food-grade paper, and heat-safe to 425°F. The pack is 128 sheets, and the sizing is meant to fit most 8–12 QT air fryer baskets — the brand's own advice is to measure your basket before ordering, which is worth taking seriously given that spread.
Who should buy it: anyone with a round basket, a larger 8–12 QT unit, or a household that cooks messy, saucy food often. The 128-count suits daily cooking and meal prep. In my opinion, the raised edge is the most useful feature here — it's the difference between a liner that catches mess and one that merely lines the floor.
Who should skip it: if your air fryer is a square 8QT model, a round sheet leaves the corners of the basket exposed. And if you routinely cook at the very top of the temperature range, note the 425°F ceiling — below the TCSNOE's 450°F.
• Best for a square 8QT basket → TCSNOE Air Fryer Paper. The 9x9 inch square is designed around exactly that basket shape.
• Best for 8–12 QT or round baskets → Empowered Cooks Cathy Yoder's Round. It's sized to span that wider range, with the brand advising you measure first.
• Best for greasy, saucy food → Empowered Cooks. Raised edges hold oil and juices in instead of letting them run across the basket.
• Best for maximum heat tolerance → TCSNOE. 450°F versus 425°F — relevant if you push high-temperature roasting or reheating.
• Best for the least trimming and fuss → TCSNOE. 125 pre-cut sheets sized for a specific basket family, so there's nothing to measure or cut.
• Best for sturdier paper that won't curl → Empowered Cooks. The brand specifically builds these thicker to stay flat through the cook.
• Best sheet count → essentially a tie. 125 versus 128 — the difference is negligible in daily use.
• Best for multi-appliance use → TCSNOE. It's also listed for microwave, steamer and oven, not just the air fryer.
I'd buy TCSNOE Air Fryer Paper — but only if I owned a square 8QT Chefman-style air fryer, because that's the entire reason it exists. In that case it wins on fit, on heat ceiling and on the fact that you never have to think about sizing.
If I owned a round basket or a bigger 8–12 QT unit, or if my cooking leaned toward wings, fish and saucy trays, I'd switch to Empowered Cooks Cathy Yoder's Round. The raised edges are the feature that actually changes your cleanup. Fitting the liner to your basket matters more than anything else here.
how to use air fryer parchment liners
Preheat the air fryer first and do not put the liner in during preheating. Once preheated, place the liner in the basket and make sure it lies flat, then add enough food to hold it down. Cook as normal, then lift out and discard the sheet — that's the sequence TCSNOE describes for its liners, and the same logic applies to any parchment liner.
are air fryer parchment liners safe
Both products are described as food-grade, BPA-free paper — TCSNOE unbleached parchment, Empowered Cooks PFAS-free and non-toxic — and each carries a stated heat limit: 450°F for TCSNOE and 425°F for Empowered Cooks. Staying within that limit and keeping the liner flat under food is the practical safety rule. Never leave a loose liner in during preheat, since airflow can lift it.
are air fryer liners parchment
Yes — both of these are parchment paper liners, sold as pre-cut disposable sheets rather than rolls. TCSNOE's are 9x9 inch squares in unbleached parchment; Empowered Cooks' are 9-inch rounds in brown paper with raised edges. Neither is a reusable silicone or metal insert.
are air fryer liners necessary
No — they're a convenience, not a requirement. What they buy you is cleanup: TCSNOE's non-stick, oil-proof sheet keeps grease and crumbs off the basket floor, and Empowered Cooks' raised edge keeps sauces and juices from running off. If you don't mind scrubbing, you don't need them. If a clean basket with no soaking is worth it to you, check the current price on Amazon for whichever shape matches your air fryer.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.
See also: Empowered Cooks Cathy Yoder's Air vs Generic Air Fryer Cooking, Unomor 20Pcs vs Empowered Cooks Cathy Yoder's AirFryer, Empowered Cooks Cathy Yoder's vs Racvofy 6