Introduction
Cyber-Physical Systems (CPS) are evolving to become smarter, more autonomous, connected and collaborating. Provided with unprecedented capabilities, the CPS also represent unprecedented complexity and bring new risks that go beyond classical dependability. This website outlines a framework for complex CPS with the purposes to facilitate holistic considerations of trustworthiness and its various attributes. The framework addresses trustworthiness from both technical (e.g., safety, reliability and security, etc.) and social perspectives (e.g. w.r.t. ethics, transparency and privacy). The framework is not intended primarily to replace existing CPS frameworks, but rather to complement them by providing an approach for incorporating trustworthiness considerations as a first class citizen.
T-Framework
Complex CPS development, maintenance, and operation require the involvement of many stakeholders with different expertise. Complex CPS also consists of diverse technologies, components and structures, which are influencing each-other when integrated to provide the intended capabilities. Dealing with "trustworthy" complex CPS imposes several new challenges; requirements stemming from individual trustworthiness attributes need to be identified and it is moreover necessary to identify the dependencies between trustworthiness attributes. Such attributes may have partially conflicting goals in the first place, such as the classical trade-off between safety and availability, but may also result in mechanisms (designed into the CPS) that share the same resources and that may conflict during operation. For example, cybersecurity mechanisms such as authentication and encryption will take time to perform, impacting real-time performance, which in term may also be necessary for certain safety functions.
Given a particular CPS, our trustworthiness framework provides a set of questions as follows:
What attributes of trustworthiness are relevant for this CPS and given that trustworthiness is about relations - which relations are of concern? Answers to this question would help in identifying high-level requirements on trustworthiness.
What relationships, dependencies and trade offs exist between, (i) trustworthiness attributes in terms of their goals, (ii) how the attributes relate to different system aspects such as data, functions and computations, and, (iii) what dependencies exist between attributes due to their relationships with aspects - such as shared resources in a computing system. Answers to these questions would help in identifying traceability from attributes to the system aspects, and trade-offs between attributes relating to system design decisions.
What roles and processes are needed to address trustworthiness attributes? Finally, this question will help in identifying what needs to be done to ensure trustworthiness of a CPS during its life-cycle in terms of roles (e.g. a cybersecurity manager, functional safety manager, cybersecurity and safety architect), and processes.
The T-Framework offers several key benefits that enhance the development, deployment, and maintenance of trustworthy Cyber-Physical Systems (CPS). Here are the primary advantages:
Comprehensive Trustworthiness Coverage:
Classical Dependability: Addresses critical attributes such as safety, security, and reliability, ensuring the system is robust and dependable.
AI-Specific Trustworthiness: Integrates ethical attributes like human autonomy, transparency, fairness, and explainability, promoting ethical and responsible AI use.
Structured and Systematic Approach:
Phased Workflow: Provides a clear, step-by-step methodology from preparation to continuous improvement, facilitating thorough and organized analysis and implementation.
Scenario-Based Analysis: Uses realistic scenarios to test and evaluate the impact on trustworthiness attributes, ensuring comprehensive risk assessment and mitigation.
Stakeholder Involvement:
Diverse Perspectives: Engages a broad range of stakeholders, ensuring all relevant concerns and perspectives are considered.
Continuous Engagement: Maintains stakeholder involvement throughout the system's lifecycle, from initial requirements gathering to ongoing monitoring and feedback.
Prioritization and Trade-off Management:
Utility Tree: Utilizes a Trustworthiness Attribute Utility Tree to prioritize attributes based on their importance and impact, guiding decision-making and resource allocation.
Sensitivity and Trade-off Analysis: Identifies and documents sensitivity points and trade-offs, enabling informed decisions and balanced solutions that address multiple attributes.
Lifecycle Integration and Continuous Improvement:
Lifecycle Phases: Integrates trustworthiness considerations into each phase of the system lifecycle, ensuring ongoing compliance and adaptation to new challenges.
Continuous Improvement: Implements feedback mechanisms to maintain trustworthiness and facilitate iterative improvements.
Enhanced Documentation and Reporting:
Structured Reports: Generates comprehensive reports at the end of each phase, documenting analysis, decisions, risks, and trade-offs, providing clear and traceable records for stakeholders.
Evolving Assurance Case: Develops a living assurance case that evolves with the system, documenting how trustworthiness is maintained over time.
Ethical and User-Centric Design:
Ethical Standards: Ensures that ethical considerations, such as fairness and transparency, are integrated into the system's design and operation.
User Trust: Promotes user trust by addressing key concerns related to safety, privacy, and autonomy, making the system more acceptable and reliable for end-users.
By providing a comprehensive, structured, and iterative approach, the T-Framework ensures that CPS are not only technically robust but also ethically sound and trusted by users. This holistic approach enhances the overall quality, reliability, and acceptance of CPS in various applications.
For more detail about the comparison between T-Framework and existing CPS framework and method please refer to this page.