How We Research
We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
Updated: 2026-09-22 · 9 min read · Independent comparison
• MKGDDS Air Fryer Basket — best for full-size ovens, toaster ovens and large batches; pick this if you want a 15.5 x 11.6 inch two-piece rack and tray rated to 450°F in food-grade 304 stainless steel with a nonstick finish.
• ZuKaYeHome Air Fryer Grill — best for Emeril Lagasse Everyday 360 owners who want a slim replacement tray; pick this if you need a 12 x 10 x 0.7 inch stainless pan rated to 480°F with a preheat-first requirement.
• GWY Air Fryer Baking — best for the same Emeril Lagasse Everyday 360 crowd shopping on a different spec sheet; pick this if the 12 x 10 x 0.7 inch stainless pan format matches your drawer and you want a lighter tray.
• GWYXC Air Fryer Replacement — best for PowerXL Vortex 7 QT owners; pick this if you want an oval 10.5 x 9.5 inch nonstick stainless plate with a handle and four rubber bumpers to protect the basket wall.
This is the pick I'd hand to anyone who doesn't want to think hard about compatibility. The MKGDDS set is two pieces — a basket and a crisper tray — sized at 15.5 x 11.6 x 2.1 inches with a 2.1-inch depth that gives food real vertical room. It's built from food-grade 304 stainless steel, which is the alloy you actually want in a hot, humid cooking environment, and it's rated safe up to 450°F. The finish is nonstick, and the whole thing is dishwasher safe. It weighs 1.7 pounds, so it's substantial enough to feel like a real pan rather than a foil liner, but light enough to pull out one-handed.
In daily use, the size is the story. A 15.5 by 11.6 inch footprint is a full-sheet-pan-class surface, which means you can lay out a pound of bacon in a single layer, or a tray of chicken thighs plus a side of vegetables, without stacking. The 2.1-inch depth matters more than people expect: it lets air circulate under and around food instead of trapping it flat against the metal, which is the whole point of an air fry basket. The spec sheet also describes a heat-circulation design intended to move hot air evenly so you turn food less often. Treat that as a design intent rather than a promise — dense items like thick potato wedges will still benefit from a mid-cook shake.
The nonstick surface does double duty. It reduces sticking, and it's the reason cleanup is a soak-and-rinse or a dishwasher cycle rather than a scrub. The trade-off is the one that comes with every nonstick coating: it will outlast nothing if you attack it with steel wool or a metal spatula. Use silicone or wood, and it should hold up. The other trade-off is that this is a big, flat accessory. In a compact air fryer or a small toaster oven, it simply won't fit — measure your interior before you commit, and don't buy it expecting a snug drop-in replacement for a specific machine's original basket.
Who's it for? Anyone cooking for two to four people in a full-size oven, a large toaster oven, or a big air fryer oven combo. If you're doing sheet-pan-style dinners and want the browning of a rack with the catch tray underneath, this is the most flexible piece on this list. In my opinion, it's the best all-rounder here because it's not locked to a single brand of appliance.
ZuKaYeHome Air Fryer Grill
The most important line on the spec sheet is the one about preheating. This pan has a maximum heat resistance of 480°F, but the manufacturer explicitly states that you must preheat it in an oven at 300°F for 10 minutes before first use, and warns that skipping this step can cause it to deform, bend or be damaged, shortening its life. That's unusual, and it's worth taking literally rather than treating as boilerplate. Do the preheat once, and you've protected the pan.
Day to day, this is the pan for chicken wings, fries, vegetables, pizza, steak and anything you'd otherwise put on a flat crisper plate. It grills, bakes and fries, and because it's only 0.7 inches deep, it sits low and lets air move across the surface of the food rather than around it. That's good for crisping and bad for anything saucy or wet — a 0.7-inch pan is not where you want to braise. Cleanup is dishwasher safe, and the instructions specifically say to soak it if food sticks and to avoid abrasive cloths or metal scouring balls.
The main trade-off is fitment. The spec sheet names the Emeril Lagasse Everyday 360 explicitly and states it is not compatible with the Emeril Lagasse 360 Dual Zone 25QT or 26QT French door models. If you own one of those, this is not your pan — full stop. Measure your appliance before ordering. Within its lane, though, it's a clean, simple, well-specified replacement.
Here's the thing about the GWY pan: on paper, its core specs read nearly identically to the ZuKaYeHome tray. Same 12 x 10 x 0.7 inch size. Same stated fitment — designed for the Emeril Lagasse Everyday 360, not compatible with the 25QT or 26QT French door models. Same 480°F heat resistance and the same mandatory preheat at 300°F for 10 minutes before first use. Same food-grade stainless steel with no BPA, described as non-toxic and tasteless and meeting FDA standards. Same dishwasher-safe cleaning with a warning against abrasive cloths and metal balls.
So why does it exist as a separate pick? Different brand, slightly different build. The listed item weight is 12.7 ounces, noticeably lighter than the ZuKaYeHome pan, and the package dimensions come in at roughly 12.32 x 10.08 x 0.87 inches. If you're carrying a tray in and out of a hot drawer repeatedly, a lighter pan is genuinely easier on the wrist. It also gives you a second source for the same footprint, which matters if one option is ever unavailable when you need it.
The trade-off is identical to the ZuKaYeHome's, plus one more: because the two pans are so close in spec, there's no strong functional reason to prefer this one unless weight or availability tips it for you. If you own the Everyday 360 and want the lighter of the two trays, I'd lean GWY. If you don't own that machine, skip both.
GWYXC Air Fryer Replacement
This one is a different animal entirely. The GWYXC grill plate is built for the PowerXL Vortex 7 QT air fryer and the spec sheet is blunt that it is not suitable for other models. It's an oval plate measuring 10.5 x 9.5 inches, made of food-grade stainless steel with an enameled nonstick coating, no BPA, and described as meeting FDA standards. It ships with four rubber bumpers and a cleaning cloth, and it weighs just 7 ounces.
The bumpers are the detail I like most. They sit on the plate's edges and protect the inner wall of the air fryer basket from scratches as you slide the plate in and out. If you've ever gouged the nonstick coating inside a fryer basket, you know why that matters — once that coating is compromised, the basket's days are numbered. The plate also has a handle, which sounds trivial until you've tried to lift a hot, greasy crisper plate out of a deep basket with tongs. And the whirlwind airflow design is intended to move hot air around the food for more even heating, which is the same goal as any perforated or raised crisper surface.
In use, this is your everyday plate for barbecue, steak, vegetables, fish, fries, pizza and wings. The nonstick coating releases food easily and cleans up in the dishwasher, and the stainless core is described as firm and resistant to deformation. Keep abrasive pads and metal scrubbers away from it — the spec sheet warns about that specifically, and damaging the coating is the fastest way to ruin a nonstick plate. The included cleaning cloth is meant to steer you toward a gentler option.
The obvious trade-off: it only fits one machine. That's a narrow lane, but a useful one, because OEM crisper plates for specific fryer models aren't always easy to source. If you have the PowerXL Vortex 7 QT and your original plate is scratched, warped or lost, this is a direct, purpose-made answer. Measure your original tray against 10.5 x 9.5 inches before ordering.
How We Picked
Some will. The MKGDDS set is explicitly designed for ovens and toaster ovens, not just air fryers, and is rated to 450°F. The ZuKaYeHome and GWY trays are built around the Emeril Lagasse Everyday 360, and the GWYXC plate is built around the PowerXL Vortex 7 QT — those three are meant to sit inside a specific appliance.
The ZuKaYeHome and GWY panels both state that stainless steel needs a preheat at 300°F for 10 minutes before first use, or the pan may deform, bend or be damaged and its lifespan shortened. It's a one-time step, but skipping it risks warping the tray.
Yes — all four are listed as dishwasher safe. Just avoid rough abrasive cloths and metal scouring balls, since those can damage the nonstick or enameled coating.
Measure your appliance's interior and your original tray, then match it against the listed dimensions: 15.5 x 11.6 x 2.1 inches for the MKGDDS set, 12 x 10 x 0.7 inches for the ZuKaYeHome and GWY pans, and 10.5 x 9.5 inches for the GWYXC plate. Two of these explicitly exclude certain Emeril Lagasse 25QT and 26QT French door models, so check the fitment notes carefully.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.
See also: stainless steel air fryer, Lammusd Stainless Steel Skewer vs Casbomy Air Fryer Skewer, best stainless steel air fryer