REPENT! REPENT!!
“Repent! The hour of the Lord has come!” the preachers scream across the streets of the German town of Münster.
All around, people are ripping their clothes and speaking in tongues. Some see visions of blue flames and knights on white horses descending from the sky.
#Ham, P. (2018). New Jerusalem. William Heinemann Australia, pp. 87, 159.
https://www.penguin.com.au/books/new-jerusalem-9780143781332
It’s Easter of 1534, and the prophet Jan Matthys has declared the world is ending. But before his followers can ascend to Heaven, he must first defeat the Catholic army closing in on him and his fellow cult members.
With his sword in his hand, and just a dozen men riding beside him, he leaves the safety of the walls. They start galloping towards the army of eight thousand that surround the city. Their religion's message started out as one of peace – how did it drive them into this maelstrom of violence?
#Klötzer, R. (2016) Täuferische Geschlechterbeziehungen in der aktualisierten Christuserwartung, 1530-1551. Mennonitische Geschichtsblätter 73, pp. 19-39. https://mgbl-online.de/ojs/index.php/mgb/article/view/102131
2 GOD’S RADICAL CHILDREN
A new religious movement is causing quite a stir across 16th-century Europe. They are an extreme splinter group from the reformist movement which started in Switzerland and spread through Germany and Austria to the Netherlands.
#Arthur, A. (1999). The tailor-king: The rise and fall of the Anabaptist kingdom of Münster. Thomas Dunne Books, pg. 10
https://books.google.de/books/about/The_Tailor_King.html?id=Q1JkgIC6bW8C&redir_esc=y
Their main belief is that a connection to God doesn’t need a middle man. They want to separate church and state, oppose violence as a means to control others, and think babies are free of sin and should only be baptised when they can decide for themselves. The group also claims that the Apocalypse is just around the corner and instigates people to get baptised again under this new faith before it’s too late. The members will later be known as Anabaptists and for rulers and Catholic bishops whose power relies on everything they oppose, it’s clear that these dangerous radicals must go.
#Encyclopedia Britannica. (2026, June 12). Anabaptist. Encyclopædia Britannica. https://www.britannica.com/topic/Anabaptists
#Joireman, S. F. (2009). Anabaptism and the state: An uneasy coexistence. In S. F. Joireman (Ed.), Church, state, and citizen: Christian approaches to political engagement (pp. 73–91). Oxford University Press. https://scholarship.richmond.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1090&context=polisci-faculty-publications
#The Chronicle of the Hutterian Brethren, known as Das grosse Geschichtbuch der Hutterischen Brüder. (1987). Translated and edited by the Hutterian Brethren. Plough Publishing House, pg. 45.
https://kingdomreading.com/product/the-chronicle-of-the-hutterian-brethren-volume-1/
Some are thrown into jail for the rest of their days, others have their tongues pierced for spewing blasphemy, or are burned at the stake so they may never corrupt another soul.
Despite these grim prospects, thousands of followers flee rather than denouncing their faith.
They print pamphlets outlining their beliefs and distribute them across Europe, hoping to gain ground and recruit new members.
When a young Dutchman named Jan van Leiden stumbles upon one of those leaflets, he’s sold – and his conviction will spark a new era for the Anabaptists.
#Ham, P. (2018). New Jerusalem. William Heinemann Australia.
#Encyclopedia Britannica. (2024, March 13). Melchior Hofmann. Encyclopedia Britannica. https://www.britannica.com/biography/Melchior-Hofmann
#Arthur, A. (1999). The tailor-king: The rise and fall of the Anabaptist kingdom of Münster. Thomas Dunne Books, pg. 10.
https://books.google.de/books/about/The_Tailor_King.html?id=Q1JkgIC6bW8C&redir_esc=y
#New Histories. (2010). When religious belief meets social movement: The Münster rebellion. New Histories, 2(1). https://newhistories.sites.sheffield.ac.uk/volumes/2010-11/volume-2/issue-1-belief/when-religious-belief-meets-social-movement-the-m%C3%BCnster-rebellion
3 THE CALLING
Born a bastard, van Leiden has never had the chance to make a name for himself. He has tried being a tailor, an innkeeper, even an actor, but always failed. But now, it’s as if God is finally giving him a sign.
#Bühler, A & Laut, C. (2024). Das Täuferreich von Münster oder: wie eine Sekte die Stadt Münster in die Hölle auf Erden verwandelt hat, in: Darwin gefällt das: Wie Einsteins Gehirn in einer Lunchbox landete und andere Abstruse Einfälle der Menschheit. Goldmann.
https://www.penguin.de/buecher/anna-buehler-darwin-gefaellt-das/paperback/9783442143108
#Wikipedia article on Jan van Leiden.
This is how he first meets Jan Matthys in Amsterdam. A tall man with a long beard, and a commanding voice whose words can draw crowds as he declares himself a prophet chosen by God himself.
#Arthur, A. (1999). The tailor-king: The rise and fall of the Anabaptist kingdom of Münster. Thomas Dunne Books, pg. 10.
https://books.google.de/books/about/The_Tailor_King.html?id=Q1JkgIC6bW8C&redir_esc=y
#Ham, P. (2018). New Jerusalem. William Heinemann Australia.
https://www.penguin.com.au/books/new-jerusalem-9780143781332
Much like Van Leiden, he doesn’t come from much. He used to be a baker in the small Dutch city of Haarlem. Now, he is one of the most notorious Anabaptists in the capital, calling himself “the reincarnation of the Second Witness of the Apocalypse after Elijah, and the great-grandfather of Noah.”
Conventional rules no longer apply to him. While divorce remains a sin for the rest of his followers, he insists God has ordered him to leave his wife. His new bride mandated by Heaven is the fourteen-year-old daughter of a brewer from back home.
Some of the Anabaptists founders are not too sure about Matthys’ take, yet hundreds of new followers swear allegiance to his faith. Van Leiden sees him almost as a father. For him, he travels over 200 kilometers east to scout the land that Matthys has heard is a new sanctuary for the persecuted Anabaptists: a walled German city named Münster.
#Bühler, A & Laut, C. (2024). Das Täuferreich von Münster oder: wie eine Sekte die Stadt Münster in die Hölle auf Erden verwandelt hat, in: Darwin gefällt das: Wie Einsteins Gehirn in einer Lunchbox landete und andere Abstruse Einfälle der Menschheit. Goldmann.
https://www.penguin.de/buecher/anna-buehler-darwin-gefaellt-das/paperback/9783442143108
#Ham, P. (2018). New Jerusalem. William Heinemann Australia, pg. 44-46.
https://www.penguin.com.au/books/new-jerusalem-9780143781332
#New Histories. (2010). When religious belief meets social movement: The Münster rebellion. New Histories, 2(1). https://newhistories.sites.sheffield.ac.uk/volumes/2010-11/volume-2/issue-1-belief/when-religious-belief-meets-social-movement-the-m%C3%BCnster-rebellion
#Arthur, A. (1999). The tailor-king: The rise and fall of the Anabaptist kingdom of Münster. Thomas Dunne Books.
https://books.google.de/books/about/The_Tailor_King.html?id=Q1JkgIC6bW8C&redir_esc=y
4 HEAVEN ON EARTH
Say what you like, Münster under the cultists is actually a pretty nice place to live.
The poor are being cared for, given clothing, shelter, and work helping to fortify the city's walls. Monasteries are required to host and feed the new believers arriving in town. When a family dispute arises, authorities are on the scene within minutes to help settle it. Sure, at times, there is a public whipping if someone gets too drunk or is caught cheating, but for many, that is a fair price to pay and the religion gains more and more traction.
According to some reports, by late 1533, around 1400 people in Münster are converted in a single week. By the end of the year, about one-quarter of the city are Anabaptists willing to fight for their leaders if ordered to.
#Arthur, A. (1999). The tailor-king: The rise and fall of the Anabaptist kingdom of Münster. Thomas Dunne Books, pg. 24-25
https://books.google.de/books/about/The_Tailor_King.html?id=Q1JkgIC6bW8C&redir_esc=y
Many of these new conscripts are women from both noble and humble backgrounds. They can make their own confession to Christ, even against their husbands’ wills. Also, the religion calls for goods to be shared – for women who often own little and have no control over their lives, this is a powerful promise. Soon, nuns are leaving their convents and wives their homes to join the growing religious commune.
#Klötzer, R. (2016) Täuferische Geschlechterbeziehungen in der aktualisierten Christuserwartung, 1530-1551. Mennonitische Geschichtsblätter 73, pp. 20. https://mgbl-online.de/ojs/index.php/mgb/article/view/102131
All of this is possible because the Anabaptists pushed out the local Catholic bishop and installed a council that aligns with their views. The first Anabaptists didn’t believe in violence, but Matthys is prepared to do what is necessary to defend this holy land – and his own divine rule.
#Reinholdt, K. (2012) Ein Leib in Christo werden. Ehe und Sexualität im Täufertum der Frühen Neuzeit. Veröffentlichungen des Instituts für Europäische Geschichte Mainz 227. Göttingen: Vandenhoeck & Ruprecht, pg. 160
For a brief moment, Münster seems poised to become one of the most egalitarian Renaissance cities in Europe. But of course this is only meant as a stopover to paradise: By Matthys’ calculations, the Apocalypse is set to arrive on Easter of 1534, just a few months from now.
The signs are already there: People claim that at sunset, the sun only illuminates the faces of the converted. When the end comes, the rest will be burnt by holy fire.
Van Leiden writes to Matthys, announcing: “The fruit is ripe. So ripe that you must come and pluck it yourself.”
#Arthur, A. (1999). The tailor-king: The rise and fall of the Anabaptist kingdom of Münster. Thomas Dunne Books.
https://books.google.de/books/about/The_Tailor_King.html?id=Q1JkgIC6bW8C&redir_esc=y
#Ham, P. (2018). New Jerusalem. William Heinemann Australia.
https://www.penguin.com.au/books/new-jerusalem-9780143781332
The Prophet wastes no time, ordering every one of his followers in the Netherlands to prepare for the one-way march toward the new city of the chosen. Many of them have never left home, but there is nowhere else in Europe that is safe for the Anabaptists now.
5 HUMAN SACRIFICE
The prophet arrives in February 1534. Although the city council is already sympathetic to the Anabaptists, Matthys pushes for another election and gains a council that's completely loyal.
#Heninger, S. (2018). Building a New Jerusalem: Comparison of the Anabaptists in Münster with the Latter Day Saints in Missouri & Nauvoo. The John Whitmer Historical Association Journal, 38(2), 140–164.
With the government in his palm, Mathys brings strict order to the Anabaptists’ utopia. His next step to purify the city is to baptize anyone who still hasn’t converted. If they refuse, he locks them in their homes or throws them out of the city in the dead of winter.
Being a dissident isn’t an option. An old blacksmith tries to denounce Matthys as a false prophet, but is immediately stabbed and shot. Catholic nuns who refuse to convert witness their churches being axed and their manuscripts burned on the cathedral square. Some even say Matthys' followers are using their sacred texts as toilet paper.
#Fischer, C. (August, 2004). Die Täufer in Münster (1534/35): Recht und Verfassung einer chiliastischen Theokratie. forum historiae iuris, 12.
https://forhistiur.net/legacy/articles/pdf-files/0408fischer.pdf
#Ham, P. (2018). New Jerusalem. William Heinemann Australia, pg. 88
https://www.penguin.com.au/books/new-jerusalem-9780143781332
To many in the outside world, the community has gone too far. Franz von Waldeck, the former Prince-Bishop of Münster, is determined to liberate the city from these extremists and restore the old faith. The radicals have barricaded themselves behind the city walls, so the Bishop assembles an army of mercenaries and besieges the city. Now, it’s only a matter of time before the false prophet falls.
#Ham, P. (2018). New Jerusalem. William Heinemann Australia, Ch. 29.
https://www.penguin.com.au/books/new-jerusalem-9780143781332
Matthys needs a new plan – and on Easter Sunday, the date he predicted for the Apocalypse, God reveals the solution to him: He must come out of the city with only a handful of men and defeat the Bishop himself.
The Prophet answers the divine call and rides into battle, convinced that a miracle will arrive.
Because today is judgement day, and with the lord by his side, Jan Matthys has nothing to fear.
Instead, he is stabbed, beaten, and cut to pieces. His head is set on a pole for everyone in the city to see – a failed prophet who leaves his flock surrounded by enemies. But this isn’t the end of violence, it’s just the beginning.
#Heninger, S. (2018). Building a New Jerusalem: Comparison of the Anabaptists in Münster with the Latter Day Saints in Missouri & Nauvoo. The John Whitmer Historical Association Journal, 38(2), 140–164.
6 A NEW MESSIAH
The Prophet is dead, and Easter has come and gone without Judgment Day. Could the radical Anabaptists have been wrong all along?
Van Leiden doesn’t think so. In fact, he is starting to believe this was the divine plan all along.
Surely, Matthys just got his math wrong – or he just wasn’t the one to bring salvation to the people.
Van Leiden declares himself the new leader and appoints a council of elders: a pack of twelve handpicked yes-men who will rule both public and private matters across Münster.
#Heninger, S. (2018). Building a New Jerusalem: Comparison of the Anabaptists in Münster with the Latter Day Saints in MIssouri & Nauvoo. The John Whitmer Historical Association Journal, 38(2), 140-164.
https://www.jstor.org/stable/26614539
#Williams, G. H. (1992). The radical Reformation. Sixteenth Century Journal Publishers, pg. 567
https://archive.org/details/radicalreformati0000will_w5t9/page/566/mode/2up
To cement his power even further, Van Leiden decides to marry Matthys’s widow. And rather than leaving his wife, he simply changes the rules.
All marriages are declared invalid, and polygamy is introduced. Women and girls as young as 12 are forced to wed. A man may take many wives, but they may not take many husbands.
He names practical reasons:
Many women came to Münster to live their new faith, while men who refused baptism were driven out. Other men died fighting for the Anabaptists. Münster is left with barely 1,500 men, but three times as many women. The old ideas of equality are long forgotten. Van Leiden reduces women to one function: producing the next generation of believers.
#Reinholdt, K. (2012) Ein Leib in Christo werden. Ehe und Sexualität im Täufertum der Frühen Neuzeit. Veröffentlichungen des Instituts für Europäische Geschichte Mainz 227. Göttingen: Vandenhoeck & Ruprecht, pp. 82, 160
#Fischer, C. (August, 2004). Die Täufer in Münster (1534/35): Recht und Verfassung einer chiliastischen Theokratie. forum historiae iuris, 12, paragrpah 42.
https://forhistiur.net/legacy/articles/pdf-files/0408fischer.pdf
The moment a man's wife is pregnant, he has the duty to take another - and then another, and so on. Any woman who refuses to share her husband with another wife is either imprisoned or executed. Van Leiden himself goes on to have 16 wives.
#Fischer, C. (August, 2004). Die Täufer in Münster (1534/35): Recht und Verfassung einer chiliastischen Theokratie. forum historiae iuris, 12, footnote 80.
https://forhistiur.net/legacy/articles/pdf-files/0408fischer.pdf
#Klötzer, R. (2016) Täuferische Geschlechterbeziehungen in der aktualisierten Christuserwartung, 1530-1551. Mennonitische Geschichtsblätter 73, pg. 30. https://mgbl-online.de/ojs/index.php/mgb/article/view/102131
Not all of them quietly accept this passive role: one of his wives tries an assassintion attempt on the bishop camped outside, but is caught and killed. When van Leiden hears of it, he is furious - not over her death, but because a woman dared to act on her own. They must be watched even more closely, along with everyone else.
Because the city is still under siege, this new council imposes a strict code of rules meant to keep everyone in check. Disobeying one’s master, speaking against the leaders of the town, or even complaining can be cause for execution. Play, drink and revelry are forbidden – working towards salvation is serious business.
For a man who didn’t grow up with much, Van Leiden has come a long way, and by the time September comes, he is convinced he must proclaim himself king not only of Münster but of the entire world. So he has himself anointed and prepares to finally defeat the Bishop’s army, which is still camped outside the city’s gates.
#Williams, G. H. (1992). The radical Reformation. Sixteenth Century Journal Publishers, pg. 571.
https://archive.org/details/radicalreformati0000will_w5t9/page/566/mode/2up
But among the city’s armed men, unrest is growing. After months of siege, food has almost run out. Horses, cats and dogs have already been eaten, and even rats and frogs have begun to dwindle, so people have started chewing on their shoes and the bark of any trees that haven’t been cut down to fortify the city walls.
Hungry and exhausted, they begin to pray for an end to van Leiden’s rule.
#Ham, P. (2018). New Jerusalem. William Heinemann Australia, pg. 207.
https://www.penguin.com.au/books/new-jerusalem-9780143781332
7 DELIVER US FROM EVIL
For over a year, the city walls have withstood the siege, but inside, everything is dying. A man named Heinrich Gresbeck can take no more. He had come to the city only to visit his mother, but the siege trapped him inside.
#Dejeumont, C. (2006). La réforme du mariage dans la communauté anabaptiste de Münster: quelle utopie? Clio. Femmes, Genre, Histoire 24, pp. 27–57.
In May 1535, he slips out of Münster, only for the Bishop’s army to immediately capture him. To save his life, he tells them everything they need to know to beat Van Leiden. To prove he is truly against the Anabaptists, he agrees to swim around the moat encircling the city, inspecting the walls to look for any secret entrances and sections where guards have left their posts.
#Ham, P. (2018). New Jerusalem. William Heinemann Australia, pg. 215.
https://www.penguin.com.au/books/new-jerusalem-9780143781332
With this new intelligence,an assault comes on the night of June 24. When the attack begins, many locals lock themselves into their houses, but at least 800 armed and loyal fanatics strike back.
At the Cathedral Square, defenders have assembled an impressive barricade out of sixteen armored war wagons shooting cannons at the invaders. The incoming fire is brutal, but the Bishop's men won’t concede the city.
As if protected by a holy force, they manage to push through the barricade and slay every rival unwilling to bend the knee.
#Ham, P. (2018). New Jerusalem. William Heinemann Australia, pg. 215.
https://www.penguin.com.au/books/new-jerusalem-9780143781332
#Arthur, A. (1999). The tailor-king: The rise and fall of the Anabaptist kingdom of Münster. Thomas Dunne Books.
https://books.google.de/books/about/The_Tailor_King.html?id=Q1JkgIC6bW8C&redir_esc=y
Jan van Leiden is taken prisoner. Unlike the previous prophet, he will keep his head. The Bishop wants him conscious until the end. A scaffold is raised where his throne once stood.
There, his flesh is picked off his bones with red-hot tongs.
Van Leiden’s dead body is then packed into an iron cage and hoisted up the church tower for all to see.
#Korupka: Gewalt und Krieg, Extremismus und Terror, 2011, pf. 114
https://lit-verlag.de/isbn/978-3-643-11322-1/
#Ham, P. (2018). New Jerusalem. William Heineimann Australia, pg. 228.
https://www.penguin.com.au/books/new-jerusalem-9780143781332
And that's it: the end of the Anabaptists utopian dream.
The city is strictly back in Catholic hands and all Protestant footholds close by are wiped out to prevent another disaster like this. Most anabaptist defenders are killed, the ones who can flee split up – some who believe violence is justified against any non-believers go underground, other peaceful ones persist and eventually evolve into various new faiths, like the Mennonites. They still keep the tradition of letting adults choose to get baptized – and follow strict pacifism.
#Ham, P. (2018). New Jerusalem. William Heineimann Australia, pg. 220.
https://www.penguin.com.au/books/new-jerusalem-9780143781332
#Crome, A. (2021). The Münster Rising, Memories of Violence, and Perceptions of Dissent in Restoration England, The Historical Journal 65, pp. 946–968.
#Reinholdt, K. (2012) Ein Leib in Christo werden. Ehe und Sexualität im Täufertum der Frühen Neuzeit. Veröffentlichungen des Instituts für Europäische Geschichte Mainz 227. Göttingen: Vandenhoeck & Ruprecht, pg. 160
Most likely over a thousand people died during the siege of Münster and the city will take almost two decades to get its political and economical stability back. And the citizens are forced to never forget: Van Leiden's cage still hangs outside the church today.
#Town History of Münster, Stadt Münster.
https://www.stadt-muenster.de/en/tourismus/peace-of-westphalia/town-history/793-to-1800
It would be easy to dismiss Münster as just a weird chapter in history. But while its prophets have long since turned to dust, the promise that made people kneel before them is still with us. That the last shall be first, that the world can be made just. Even if those noble ends can become an excuse for humanity's very worst.