How We Research
We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
If you want to refresh and extend the life of a pair of JBL over-ear headphones you already own, choose SOULWIT Replacement Ear Pads; if you need a complete, cable-free open-ear wireless listening setup with a smart charging case, choose Xmenha Over.
• SOULWIT Replacement Ear Pads — biggest strength: Purpose-built replacement cushions for specific JBL models, with softer protein leather, high-density foam and reinforced seams made to resist splitting and flattening.
• SOULWIT Replacement Ear Pads — biggest trade-off: It is not a headphone. It only helps if you already own one of the listed JBL models, and it carries no warranty.
• Xmenha Over — biggest strength: A self-contained Bluetooth 5.4 open-ear earbud system with a touch-screen charging case, roughly 30 hours of total playtime and an IPX5 water-resistance rating.
• Xmenha Over — biggest trade-off: Open-ear, bone-conduction-style sound leaks and trades bass isolation for awareness, and the buds themselves run only about 4–5 hours per charge.
• Who each is for: SOULWIT is for the JBL owner repairing worn pads. Xmenha Over is for someone who wants new wireless earbuds, especially for outdoor activity.
SOULWIT Replacement Ear Pads is a maintenance part, not a gadget. It is a pair of replacement cushions in grey, made from protein leather with high-density foam inside. The whole point is to bring a tired set of JBL over-ear headphones back to comfortable, wearable condition without replacing the headphones themselves. If your current pads are cracked, flaking, compressed flat or starting to separate at the seams, this is the kind of product that solves that specific problem.
The compatibility list is narrow and specific, and that matters. These pads are designed to fit the JBL E65 (E65BTNC), Live 650 (650NC/650BTNC), Live 770NC, Live 660NC and Duet NC wireless headphones. SOULWIT explicitly asks buyers to confirm their headset model before purchasing, and I would take that seriously — this is not a universal pad. If your headphones are not on that list, this product is not for you, full stop.
Xmenha Over: Who It's For
Xmenha Over is a different category entirely: a pair of open-ear wireless earbuds with a smart charging case. The headline feature is the touch-screen case. Instead of pulling out your phone, you can control volume, switch EQ modes and handle more than ten functions — including checking the time, reading battery level and setting alarms — right from the case screen. That is a genuinely unusual convenience, and for anyone who hates fiddling with a phone mid-workout, it is the main reason to look at this model.
The second defining trait is the fit. These are open-ear buds that sit outside the ear canal rather than plugging into it. Xmenha frames this around safety and awareness: you keep your surroundings audible, which is exactly what you want on a run, a bike ride or a busy street. The buds weigh only about 0.3 oz (18.14 g for the set), are made from skin-friendly ABS plastic, and use a bone-conduction driver with a 20 Hz–20,000 Hz range. The company says they are light enough that kids from age 6 up can wear them comfortably.
On connectivity and power, the spec sheet is solid for the category. Bluetooth 5.4 with roughly a 15-metre range, a claimed 1.5-hour charge time, 4–5 hours of playtime per charge and up to about 30 hours total with the case. The case is also IPX5 water-resistant, which covers sweat and light rain. There is no headphone jack — it is wireless only — and the connection is designed to be one-step: open the lid and the buds power on and pair with each other automatically.
The trade-offs are inherent to the design, not flaws. Open-ear buds do not seal your ear canal, so you get less bass punch and more ambient noise than a closed over-ear headphone. If you want deep isolation for a noisy commute or a quiet flight, this is the wrong tool. If you want awareness, sweat resistance and a screen on your case, it is exactly the right one.
Side-by-Side: Which Should You Choose?
• Best for a complete new wireless setup → Xmenha Over. Buds, case, Bluetooth and controls are all included in one package.
• Best for outdoor safety and awareness → Xmenha Over. The open-ear design keeps traffic and surroundings audible.
• Best for long listening sessions per charge → Xmenha Over. About 4–5 hours per charge and roughly 30 hours with the case, versus a passive pad with no power at all.
• Best for sweat and light rain → Xmenha Over. IPX5 water resistance on the case, versus a leather cushion that you would not want soaked.
• Best for comfort on an existing over-ear headphone → SOULWIT Replacement Ear Pads. Softer leather and high-density foam that resists flattening.
• Best if your model is not on the JBL list → Xmenha Over. SOULWIT simply will not fit anything outside its compatibility list.
• Best if you want zero batteries to manage → SOULWIT Replacement Ear Pads. No charging, no pairing, no firmware — just cushions.
In my opinion, these two products do not really compete, so the decision comes down to one question: are you fixing something or buying something new? If you own a JBL E65BTNC, Live 650BTNC, Live 660NC, Live 770NC or Duet NC and the pads are shot, I would buy the SOULWIT Replacement Ear Pads — the reinforced seams and high-density foam address the exact failure that made you search. If you have no JBL headphones and want wireless earbuds with a smart case and open-ear awareness, I would buy Xmenha Over instead. For a runner or cyclist who wants to hear traffic, Xmenha Over is the more useful purchase. For everyone else repairing a favourite pair of JBLs, SOULWIT is the one I recommend.
FAQ
The earbuds are rated for about 4–5 hours of listening per charge, and the charging case extends total use to roughly 30 hours. A full charge takes about 1.5 hours.
Generally no. The open-ear design of the Xmenha Over lets ambient sound in, which improves safety but reduces bass impact and isolation. If you want deep, sealed bass, an over-ear headphone is the better fit.
They serve completely different needs, so the fair comparison is a repair versus a new purchase. Check the current price on Amazon using the button on this page before deciding, since I do not quote prices here.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.
See also: Onkyo Headphone Amplifier DAC vs CVJ USB C Headphone, AIYIMA DAC-A2 vs CVJ Shadow Blade IEM: PC Gaming Headphones, XANAD Hard Case vs Yunsailing 10: Small on Ear Headphones, Ladont 50 vs Waneni Headphones Bulk 6