How We Research
We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
If you want to restore a pair of Bose on-ear headphones you already own, choose SOULWIT Earpads; if you need a complete, wireless on-ear headphone for daily listening, choose Skullcandy Icon 180. These two products sit in completely different lanes — one is a replacement part, the other is a finished pair of headphones — so the right pick comes down to whether you're fixing something or buying something.
• SOULWIT Earpads — biggest strength: high-density foam wrapped in soft protein leather, built to restore bass and noise isolation on Bose OE2/OE2i, SoundTrue OE and SoundLink OE on-ear models.
• SOULWIT Earpads — biggest trade-off: it's a spare part, not a headphone. You need a compatible Bose on-ear already in hand, and it does not fit the Bose On Ear (Generation 1).
• Skullcandy Icon 180 — biggest strength: a complete wireless on-ear headphone with up to 50 hours of battery, rapid charge, multipoint pairing and a sweat/water-resistant nano-coating.
• Skullcandy Icon 180 — biggest trade-off: no active noise cancelling and no noise control of any kind — isolation is passive only, and there's no carrying case mentioned beyond the flat-folding design.
• Who SOULWIT is for: owners of older Bose on-ear models whose pads have flattened, cracked or started flaking.
• Who Icon 180 is for: anyone who wants one ready-to-go on-ear headphone for commuting, workouts and travel.
The SOULWIT Earpads are a direct-fit replacement for the on-ear cushion on Bose OE2, OE2i, SoundTrue OE and SoundLink OE headphones. That's the whole job, and it does that job with two materials that matter: high-density foam and a soft protein leather cover. The design intent is straightforward — worn-out pads collapse, seal poorly against the ear, and drag the low end down with them. SOULWIT's claim is that its precisely modeled pads won't alter the sound performance of your Bose headphones, and they'll make an aging pair look new again.
Installation is the part most people worry about, and SOULWIT addresses it directly: the package includes earpads plus a user guide, and the stated install time is around five minutes. That's a realistic number for a pad swap on this style of on-ear headphone — you're working the new cushion over the existing mounting ring, not disassembling the driver housing.
Skullcandy Icon 180: Who It's For
The Icon 180 is a finished wireless on-ear headphone, and the spec sheet reads like it was written for people who are hard on their gear. Battery life is listed at up to 50 hours, with a rapid-charge figure of 10 minutes for 4 hours of listening — that's the kind of ratio that turns a forgotten charge into a non-event. Charging from empty takes about an hour.
Durability and portability are the other two pillars. A protective nano-coating keeps moisture out, which is what backs up the sweat- and water-resistant claim — relevant for workouts and bad weather. The frame is flat-folding and collapsible, and Skullcandy includes a 3.5mm AUX cable, so you can go wired when you want to. Multipoint pairing lets it hold two devices at once, and the Skullcandy App lets you adjust EQ, pick presets and enable Low Latency Audio.
On-ear comfort comes from plush cushions and a softly padded headband, with an oval earpiece shape and a 30mm dynamic driver rated at 109 dB sensitivity. Bluetooth 5.3 handles the wireless side, and controls are button-based — no touch panel to fight with. Color is Cement, and there's a 1-year manufacturer warranty.
Buy it if you want one headphone that covers commuting, gym sessions and travel without babysitting a charger. Skip it if noise cancelling is a requirement — the sheet lists noise control as none, so what you get is passive isolation from the on-ear seal, not active cancellation.
Side-by-Side: Which Should You Choose?
• Best for reviving headphones you already own → SOULWIT Earpads. Nothing else on this page fixes a worn Bose on-ear.
• Best for battery life → Skullcandy Icon 180. Up to 50 hours, plus 4 hours from a 10-minute rapid charge.
• Best for workouts and weather → Skullcandy Icon 180. Nano-coating for sweat and water resistance.
• Best for multiple devices → Skullcandy Icon 180. Multipoint pairing switches between two connected devices.
• Best for sound tuning → Skullcandy Icon 180. EQ and presets through the Skullcandy App.
• Best for replacing a worn seal → SOULWIT Earpads. High-density foam and protein leather restore the on-ear fit and bass response.
• Best for Bose On Ear (Generation 1) owners → neither. SOULWIT explicitly doesn't fit that generation, and Icon 180 is an entirely different headphone.
• Best for travel → Skullcandy Icon 180. Flat-folding, collapsible, lightweight and travel-ready by design.
• Best for a no-fuss one-time fix → SOULWIT Earpads. A five-minute install with an included guide.
In my opinion, if you own a compatible Bose on-ear and the pads are the only thing wrong with it, the SOULWIT Earpads are the smarter buy — you're spending a little to save a headphone you already like, and the materials are the right ones for the job. But if you're shopping for a headphone rather than a repair, I'd take the Skullcandy Icon 180 without hesitation: 50 hours of battery, rapid charge, multipoint, app EQ, sweat resistance and a foldable frame make it the far more useful object day to day. It doesn't cancel noise, and that's the one compromise I'd accept going in.
FAQ
how to wear over the ear headphones
how to clean on ear headphones
For the Icon 180, the sweat- and water-resistant nano-coating is there to keep moisture out, but you should still wipe the cushions and frame with a soft, slightly damp cloth rather than soaking them. For SOULWIT Earpads, the surface is protein leather over high-density foam — a gentle wipe keeps it clean, and you'd want to avoid harsh solvents that could dry out the leather. Let both air dry fully before use.
how to clean over the ear headphones
If your headphones are over-ear, the cushions typically lift off or unclip and can be wiped separately from the headband and drivers. That's the same basic principle that makes the SOULWIT Earpads a five-minute job on a compatible Bose on-ear: the cushion is a removable, replaceable component. For the Icon 180, keep liquids away from the button controls, the 3.5mm jack and the charging port even though the headphone is moisture resistant.
No. SOULWIT lists them as fitting the OE2, OE2i, SoundTrue OE and SoundLink OE on-ear series, and states they do not fit the Bose On Ear (Generation 1). Check your exact model before buying — that's the single most common way to get this purchase wrong.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.
See also: Jacuate Open Ear Earbuds vs Transformers Open Ear: Over Ear, JBL Soundgear Sense vs CXK Open Ear Headphones: Open Ear, Anker Soundcore P30i vs Conyat Open-Ear Headphones, Tofficu 16pairs vs YARNOW 10: Secure Fit Earhooks