We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
Updated: 2026-09-17 · 7 min read · Independent comparison
If you want a lightweight wired earbud for calls and music on the go, choose Skullcandy Ink'd+; if you need certified hearing protection with Bluetooth audio for loud work, choose PROTEAR Hearing Protection NRR. That's the short version. They look like they belong in the same conversation because both sit in or around your ears, but they solve two completely different problems, and once you see the specs side by side the split becomes obvious.
• Skullcandy Ink'd+ biggest strength: a tiny, corded 3.5 mm earbud with inline call and track control — plug it into anything with a headphone jack and it just works.
• Skullcandy Ink'd+ biggest trade-off: it's a discontinued wired model with passive noise isolation only, and its "wireless technology: Infrared" field is a spec-sheet oddity that doesn't change the fact that this is a cable-dependent product.
• PROTEAR Hearing Protection NRR biggest strength: rated hearing protection (ANSI S3.19 NRR 25 dB, CE EN352-1 SNR 30 dB) combined with Bluetooth 5.4 streaming and a claimed 40+ hours of playback.
• PROTEAR Hearing Protection NRR biggest trade-off: it's a full over-ear earmuff built for workshops, mowing and machinery — bulky next to a pocket earbud, and no AM/FM radio built in.
• Who each pick is for: the Ink'd+ is for someone who wants cheap, simple wired audio; the PROTEAR is for someone whose ears need real protection while they work or listen.
The Ink'd+ is a classic wired in-ear bud. It uses a 3.5 mm jack, a 16-ohm impedance dynamic driver, and a frequency range of 20 Hz to 20,000 Hz — the standard full-range spec you'd expect from a basic music earbud. There's no battery, no pairing, no charging case. You plug it into a phone with a headphone jack, a laptop, a tablet, a handheld console, or an in-flight entertainment port, and it plays.
The feature set is deliberately minimal. You get a built-in microphone and a remote button for call control and track control — take a call, play, pause, skip. The earpieces are rounded in-ear tips made from ABS plastic, and Skullcandy includes multiple ear gel sizes so you can dial in the fit. That fit matters, because the only noise reduction here is sound isolation: a sealed tip physically blocks some surrounding noise. There's no active noise cancellation and no rating attached to it. Skullcandy also backs it with a 1-year manufacturer warranty.
One honest caveat: the Ink'd+ is listed as discontinued on Amazon. That doesn't change what it is, but if you specifically want this exact model and color, availability can be inconsistent, so it's worth confirming the listing before you commit.
PROTEAR Hearing Protection NRR: Who It's For
The PROTEAR is a different animal entirely. This is a Bluetooth earmuff whose primary job is protecting your hearing, with entertainment bolted on as a bonus. The protection is the headline: it's rated to ANSI S3.19 NRR 25 dB under the US standard and CE EN352-1 SNR 30 dB under the European standard. That's a real, testable reduction in how much noise reaches your ears — the kind of number that matters when you're standing next to a running mower, a table saw or a workshop full of machinery.
Then there's the audio side. Bluetooth 5.4 handles the connection, and PROTEAR notes the newer version doubles throughput versus the older 1 Mbps standard and improves transmission stability while drawing less power. You can stream from a phone or any Bluetooth device, and there's an integrated microphone so you can answer calls without pulling the muffs off. Playback is quoted at 40+ hours over Bluetooth, or up to 120+ hours in AUX mode, powered by a built-in 1200 mAh lithium battery charged over USB. No disposable batteries to buy.
Comfort gets real attention too. The ear cups are described as extremely soft, with a design that accounts for wearing glasses, and the headband is adjustable with cutouts so it still fits comfortably under a hat. The whole thing is described as low-profile and lightweight for long sessions. Fit type is listed as standard, and it comes in a black-and-gray finish.
Who should buy it: anyone whose day involves loud, sustained noise — mowing, woodworking, shooting, operating noisy machines, even loud concerts and festivals — and who wants music or a podcast while they work. Who should skip it: if you want a discreet earbud for casual listening, this is overkill and physically bulky. And note the explicit limitation: there's no AM/FM radio built in, so if radio is your thing, look elsewhere in the brand's lineup.
• Best for hearing protection → PROTEAR Hearing Protection NRR. It carries rated NRR 25 dB / SNR 30 dB protection. The Ink'd+ offers fit-based isolation with no rating.
• Best for simplicity and zero charging → Skullcandy Ink'd+. Wired 3.5 mm connection, no battery, no pairing, no firmware.
• Best for long listening sessions away from a plug → PROTEAR Hearing Protection NRR. 40+ hours over Bluetooth and 120+ hours in AUX mode from a 1200 mAh battery.
• Best for phone calls under a helmet or earmuff → PROTEAR Hearing Protection NRR. The integrated microphone lets you take calls hands-free without removing the muffs.
• Best for travel and pocket carry → Skullcandy Ink'd+. A corded in-ear bud with included ear gel sizes and a 1-year manufacturer warranty is about as packable as audio gets.
• Best for noisy hobbies — mowing, shooting, woodworking, concerts → PROTEAR Hearing Protection NRR. This is exactly the use case it was designed around.
• Best for kids or shared devices with a headphone jack → Skullcandy Ink'd+. The 3.5 mm plug works with anything that has a jack, and the listed age range covers kids.
• Best for comfort with glasses or hats → PROTEAR Hearing Protection NRR. Soft cups and a cutout headband are built for that.
In my opinion, these two shouldn't really be competing — the right answer depends entirely on whether your ears need protecting or just entertaining. If your priority is hearing safety in loud environments, I'd buy the PROTEAR Hearing Protection NRR. The certified NRR 25 dB rating is the whole point, and the Bluetooth 5.4 streaming, integrated mic and huge battery life make it genuinely pleasant to wear for hours. If you just want a cheap, dependable wired earbud for calls and music and you never step into a loud workplace, the Skullcandy Ink'd+ is the simpler, lighter pick — provided you can still find it, since it's discontinued. For most people reading a comparison that includes "hearing protection" in the title, the PROTEAR is the one that actually does what the keyword promises.
They work differently. The PROTEAR is a rated hearing protector with NRR 25 dB / SNR 30 dB. The Ink'd+ relies on passive sound isolation from an in-ear seal and carries no noise reduction rating. For loud environments, the PROTEAR is the safer choice.
I wouldn't rely on it. In-ear isolation reduces some surrounding sound, but it isn't tested protection. For mowing, sawing or machinery, you want a product with a real NRR like the PROTEAR.
No. PROTEAR explicitly notes the Bluetooth noise-cancelling headphone does not include AM/FM functionality. It streams from Bluetooth devices or works over AUX.
The Ink'd+ has no battery at all — it runs off whatever it's plugged into. The PROTEAR quotes 40+ hours over Bluetooth and up to 120+ hours in AUX mode from its 1200 mAh battery.
Yes — prices and availability change, and the Ink'd+ is listed as discontinued, so it's worth checking the current price on Amazon for both before you decide.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.