How We Research
We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
If you want to restore the crisping basket in a Ninja Foodi SP-series air fry oven, choose SettleDown Replacement Air Fryer; if you need reusable silicone liners that keep a 10-quart dual-basket air fryer clean, choose LYHOLKEER Silicone Air Fryer.
• SettleDown's biggest strength: it's a direct 304 stainless steel replacement basket for Ninja Foodi SP100/SP101 series ovens, heat-safe to 450°F with an ultra-fine mesh base for even crisping.
• SettleDown's biggest trade-off: it only fits those specific SP-series ovens, so if you own a different air fryer it's useless to you.
• LYHOLKEER's biggest strength: two reusable, perforated silicone liners sized for 10QT dual-basket fryers, dishwasher safe and heat-resistant to 450°F.
• LYHOLKEER's biggest trade-off: it's a liner, not a structural part — it cannot replace a broken basket, and it may carry a slight new-silicone odor that needs a boiling-water soak first.
• Buy SettleDown if your SP101 basket is worn, damaged or missing and you want the oven working again.
• Buy LYHOLKEER if your dual-basket fryer works fine and you want less scrubbing and less grease residue.
This is a repair part, not an accessory. SettleDown built it as a drop-in replacement for the Ninja Foodi SP100, SP101, SP101B1 and SP101C air fry ovens, and that compatibility list is the whole story. If your model number isn't on it, stop reading — this basket won't seat properly and you'd be buying a paperweight.
Where it earns its place is in the material and the mesh. It's food-grade 304 stainless steel, BPA free and FDA compliant, and rated safe up to 450°F. That ceiling matters because air fry ovens routinely run hot, and a basket that deforms or off-gasses at high heat is worse than no basket at all. The ultra-fine mesh base is the other real design decision: it lets hot air push up through the food instead of just around it, which is how you get even browning and how fat drips away rather than pooling. It measures 13.3 x 13.3 x 1.1 inches and weighs 3.2 ounces — light enough to lift one-handed out of a hot oven, thin enough to store flat in a drawer.
Who should buy it: anyone with one of those SP-series ovens whose original basket has scratched, warped, or gone missing, and who cooks the usual rotation — nuggets, chips, sandwiches, homemade pizza, weeknight family dinners. The non-stick surface means stuck-on food releases after a short soak rather than a scrubbing session.
Who should skip it: owners of any other air fryer brand or model, and anyone hoping to upgrade capacity or change how their oven cooks. This restores the status quo. It doesn't improve on it. SettleDown also positions it for light commercial use, but for a home kitchen the honest case is simple — you need the part, and this is the part.
LYHOLKEER sells a different kind of problem-solver. These are two reusable rectangular silicone liners, grey and black, designed specifically for the Ninja Foodi SL401, SL400 and SL451 DoubleStack air fryers, with stated fit for other 10QT dual-basket models including the DZ302, DZ401 and DZ550.
The design detail worth understanding is the perforation pattern. LYHOLKEER puts holes at the front and back rather than scattering them evenly, which is meant to keep hot air circulating through the basket instead of trapping it under a solid mat. If you've ever lined a basket with foil and wondered why the bottom of your food steamed instead of crisped, that's the problem this is solving. The liners are also described as thicker and taller than typical competitors, with dual handles so you can lift them out without hunting for a mitt.
Safety specs line up with the other pick: food-grade silicone, heat-resistant to 450°F, oil-proof, and built not to deform or tear over repeated use. They're fully dishwasher safe, which is the actual selling point — the liner catches the grease, crumbs and residue so your fryer's own basket doesn't, and cleanup becomes a rinse or a dishwasher cycle rather than a soak-and-scrub.
Two honest caveats. First, LYHOLKEER notes the liners may have a slight odor out of the packaging — that's normal for silicone, and the fix is to wash and soak them in boiling water before the first cook. Second, this is a liner. It sits inside a basket you already own. If your basket is broken, this doesn't help you.
Who should buy it: owners of 10QT dual-basket fryers who cook often and are tired of degreasing the drawers, and anyone who wants the same liners to work in a microwave, oven, steamer or regular cookware. It's also a practical pick for camping, barbecues and summer parties, where you want to serve or hold food without dirtying another dish.
Who should skip it: single-basket air fryer owners, anyone with a broken or missing basket, and cooks who prefer a bare metal surface for maximum crisp on things like wings.
• Best for replacing a broken or missing basket → SettleDown Replacement Air Fryer. It's the only one of the two that is a structural part.
• Best for reducing cleanup on a working fryer → LYHOLKEER Silicone Air Fryer. The liners take the grease hit so your basket doesn't.
• Best for Ninja Foodi SP-series owners → SettleDown. The compatibility list is SP100, SP101, SP101B1 and SP101C, and nothing else.
• Best for Ninja SL401 / SL400 / SL451 and other 10QT dual-basket owners → LYHOLKEER. This is the fit it was designed around.
• Best for even crisping → both, for different reasons. SettleDown uses an ultra-fine mesh to push heat through the food; LYHOLKEER uses front-and-back perforations to keep air moving under it.
• Best for dishwasher convenience → LYHOLKEER. It's fully dishwasher safe. SettleDown's basket is non-stick and soak-friendly, not dishwasher-claimed.
• Best for heat tolerance → a tie. Both are rated safe to 450°F.
• Best for use outside the air fryer → LYHOLKEER. It's stated for microwaves, ovens, steamers and general cookware; SettleDown is built for the oven it replaces.
• Best for a two-minute decision → SettleDown if something is broken; LYHOLKEER if nothing is. That's genuinely the whole fork in the road.
I'd buy the SettleDown Replacement Air Fryer — but only because my honest read is that people searching these two products together usually have a dead or damaged SP-series basket, and a liner can't fix that. If your SP101 is fine, my recommendation flips completely: get the LYHOLKEER Silicone Air Fryer and stop scrubbing drawers. In my opinion, the right question isn't which product is better. It's whether you're replacing a part or protecting one. Answer that and the choice makes itself.
Only if you own a Foodi SP100, SP101, SP101B1 or SP101C. It's listed as a replacement for those specific models and isn't described as fitting anything else, so check your model number before ordering.
No. They're sized for 10QT dual-basket fryers like the Ninja SL401, SL400, SL451, DZ302, DZ401 and DZ550. They're rectangular and designed as a pair for two drawers.
They solve unrelated problems, so value depends on your situation. If your basket is broken, only SettleDown fixes it; if your fryer works, LYHOLKEER is the one that changes your daily routine. Check the current price on Amazon for each before deciding.
LYHOLKEER states a slight odor is normal and recommends washing and soaking the liners in boiling water before first use. Both products are rated heat-safe to 450°F, so a pre-use soak won't affect them.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.
See also: Coukre Silicone Spatula Set vs neheewin 2: Air Fryer Spatula, SettleDown Air Fryer Tray vs GWYXC Air Fryer Tray, chengziyue 6QT vs GCQ Air fryer Replacement: Air Fryer Grill