How We Research
We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
Updated: 2026-09-24 · 7 min read · Independent comparison
• SelWatty Cake Barrel — biggest strength: a single, deep, food-grade iron barrel with a nonstick coating, sized at 8.7 x 8.7 x 2.8 inches, so it holds a real pile of fries, onion rings or cheese sticks without crowding.
• SelWatty Cake Barrel — biggest trade-off: it's one pan, not a set, and it's tied to specific fryer models (HD9925, HD9860, HD9905 01) even though it also fits larger fryers.
• PRETYZOOM Pizza Tray Set — biggest strength: six stainless steel pieces with a nonstick coating, so you get multiple pans for baking, roasting and even soups or stews with juices.
• PRETYZOOM Pizza Tray Set — biggest trade-off: the pieces are shallow (the listed dimension is 6.3 x 6.3 x 0.98 inches), so they're better for flat, spread-out foods than for a loaded, deep batch of cheese fries.
• Who each pick is for: SelWatty for someone who wants one deep, easy-release barrel for fries and small cakes; PRETYZOOM for someone who wants a multi-pan kit for varied air fryer cooking.
The SelWatty Cake Barrel is, at heart, a single deep pan. It's made from food-grade iron, it's BPA free, and it carries a nonstick coating that the brand positions around easy food release. The listed size — 8.7 x 8.7 x 2.8 inches — is the detail that matters most here. That depth is what makes it genuinely useful for air fryer cheese fries: you can load a proper layer of fries, scatter cheese over the top, and let the hot air circulate down into the pile instead of just skimming the surface. The same depth works for onion rings, chicken strips, cheese sticks, corn dogs and broccoli, all of which the brand explicitly lists as intended foods.
The nonstick surface is where this pan earns its keep in daily use. Fries and melted cheese are notorious for welding themselves to bare metal, so a coating designed for easy removal is a real practical win, not a marketing line. Cleanup is handled either by rinsing or by dropping it in the dishwasher, which is a genuine convenience if you cook air fryer sides several times a week. The brand also lists it for biscuits, pizza and grilled vegetables, plus broader kitchen and baking use, so it isn't a one-trick pan.
Who should buy it? If your air fryer routine revolves around a handful of recurring jobs — fries, cheese fries, small cakes, roasted veg — and you'd rather own one pan that does those well than a drawer full of pieces, this is the straightforward pick. It's also the better choice if you want something you can rinse and forget. Who should skip it? If you like cooking two or three different things at the same time, or you regularly make dishes with liquid (stews, saucy bakes), a single barrel will leave you waiting between batches. In that case, the multi-piece set below is the more sensible route.
The PRETYZOOM Pizza Tray Set is a six-piece stainless steel kit, and the word "set" is doing the heavy lifting. Where the SelWatty barrel gives you depth, this gives you breadth: multiple pans you can rotate through, which is a real advantage when you're feeding more than one person or cooking a main and a side in sequence. The pans are food-grade stainless steel with a nonstick coating, and the brand leans hard on the easy-clean angle — the coating is there specifically so food releases and washing up stays quick.
The listed dimensions tell you what these pans are actually good at. At 6.3 x 6.3 x 0.98 inches, they're shallow and compact — roughly plate-sized, with a low rim. That shape is ideal for anything you want spread out and crisped: banana fritters, roasted tomato bruschetta, chicken kebabs with french fries, lamb kebabs with hummus, and the kind of flat bakes and small pizzas the name suggests. The brand also notes they can handle soups, stews and "any foods with juices," which is unusual for air fryer accessories and worth knowing if you like saucy dishes. Beyond baking, the set is listed for juicy meat, fish, macaroni and cheese and omelets.
Who should buy it? Anyone who wants options. If you cook a rotation of different dishes, want to bake cakes and pies as well as fry, or you're buying a gift for someone setting up an air fryer kitchen, a six-piece set covers far more ground out of the box. Who should skip it? If your single priority is a big, deep batch of cheese fries with a thick layer of melted cheese, these shallow pans will force you to cook in smaller, flatter portions. Depth is not what this set is for.
• Best for deep, loaded air fryer cheese fries → SelWatty Cake Barrel. The 2.8-inch depth holds a real pile; the set's 0.98-inch pans don't.
• Best for cooking several things at once → PRETYZOOM Pizza Tray Set. Six pieces means you can work in batches or in parallel instead of waiting on one pan.
• Best for easy release and quick cleanup → either, honestly. Both use a nonstick coating; SelWatty adds dishwasher safety, which the other sheet doesn't claim.
• Best for flat, crisped foods → PRETYZOOM Pizza Tray Set. Low rims suit bruschetta, fritters, kebabs and small pizzas.
• Best for dishes with sauces or juices → PRETYZOOM Pizza Tray Set. It's the only one of the two explicitly listed for soups, stews and juicy foods.
• Best for small bakes and cakes → SelWatty Cake Barrel. The barrel shape and depth are built for batters and molded bakes.
• Best for gifting or starting from scratch → PRETYZOOM Pizza Tray Set. A six-piece kit reads as a more complete gift than a single pan.
• Best for a specific fryer model → SelWatty Cake Barrel. It's listed for HD9925, HD9860 and HD9905 01, and fits larger fryers too.
• Best for minimal storage → SelWatty Cake Barrel. One pan takes less cupboard space than six.
If I were buying for myself and my air fryer cheese fries habit, I'd take the SelWatty Cake Barrel. In my opinion, depth beats quantity for that specific job — you can't fake a thick, cheesy pile of fries in a shallow pan, and the nonstick barrel plus dishwasher-safe cleanup is exactly what I want after a messy batch. I'd recommend the PRETYZOOM Pizza Tray Set instead if you cook a wider variety, want to bake as much as you fry, or need several pans going at once. Different jobs, both sensible. Check the current price on Amazon before you commit.
FAQ
how to make air fryer cheese fries
Layer your fries in a single even layer in a deep pan like the SelWatty barrel, cook until crisp, then add cheese and return them to the air fryer briefly so it melts. The barrel's 2.8-inch depth keeps the pile contained, and its nonstick coating makes the cheesy fries easy to lift out.
Cut potatoes into even strips, toss with a little oil, and spread them in one layer so hot air reaches every side. A shallow, wide pan — the kind in the PRETYZOOM set — works well for flat, evenly spread fries, while the SelWatty barrel suits thicker or topped batches.
how to air fryer french fries frozen
Frozen fries go straight in — no thawing needed. Spread them in a single layer in whichever pan fits your batch size, shake or turn them partway through, and expect a slightly softer result than fresh-cut if you crowd the pan.
how to air fryer french fries
The main variables are even cutting, a light oil coating, and not overcrowding. Both of these accessories use a nonstick coating so fries release cleanly, and both are listed as suitable for fries — pick the barrel for depth, the set for flexibility.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.
See also: SettleDown Air Fryer Tray vs GWYXC Air Fryer Tray, Jijukor 20 vs Paeniom 6: Air Fryer Cake Pan, ABOOFAN Cake Mold Air vs Didiseaon 2pcs: Air Fryer Omelet