Every early childhood classroom has a credential on the wall, but that credential rarely tells families, directors, or even teachers themselves what the educator was actually prepared to do. In Indiana, the qualifications required to lead a preschool classroom ask very little of educators, and many teachers enter the field without the pedagogical preparation their K–12 counterparts receive.
Behind the Credential examines that gap. Drawing on qualitative interviews with 22 early childhood stakeholders and a close look at Indiana's Paths to QUALITY system and NAEYC accreditation standards, this practitioner's guide explores how credentials, ratings, and accreditation can signal quality without guaranteeing it, and what directors, educators, and families can do about it.
Center directors and program leaders who want to understand and strengthen the preparation of their teaching teams
Early childhood educators looking to reflect on their own preparation and articulate the value of their work
Families who want to know what to look for, and what to ask, when choosing a program
Policymakers, trainers, and higher education faculty working on early childhood workforce preparation
The book is organized in three parts, moving from understanding the problem to examining it in your own work to putting what you learn into practice.
A plain-language look at what accreditation and quality-rating systems actually require, where those requirements fall short of what instructional competence demands, and why the distance between the two matters for children.
The Credential You Can See, The Preparation You Can't
What "Accredited" Actually Means
The Gap Between Compliance and Competence
Why This Matters for Kids, Not Just Paperwork
A structured self-assessment built around five dimensions of preparation. Teachers can use it to take an honest look at their own preparation, and directors can extend it into a center-wide audit of their whole instructional team.
How to Use This Guide
Formal Education: What You Actually Studied
DAP-Specific Preparation: What You Were Taught to Do
Knowing Your Center's Quality Standards
Kindergarten Readiness Alignment
Professional Belief Alignment
Scoring Yourself Honestly
The Center Director Auditing Tool
How to turn what you learn into real conversations, professional development plans, and changes in daily practice, along with stories from the field and a look at what would need to change at the policy level.
Starting the Conversation Without It Feeling Like an Evaluation
What Directors Do With What They Learn
What Teachers Do With What They Learn
Stories From the Field
Where the System Goes From Here
The Work Begins With One Honest Question
Also Included
Discussion questions for book studies, staff meetings, and college courses
A glossary of early childhood terms and acronyms
"Outside Indiana" notes to help readers outside Indiana find their own state's equivalent standards
Five appendices: a condensed Educator Preparedness Self-Assessment, a condensed Center Director Credential Audit Instrument, an Individual Professional Growth Plan, a Family Center-Tour Quick Checklist, and a Center-Wide Action Planning Worksheet
Behind the Credential: The Toolkit puts the book's findings into practice with three ready-to-use instruments:
Center Director Credential Audit Instrument: helps program leaders review staff credentials alongside the actual preparation behind them
Educator Preparedness Self-Assessment: guides teachers in reflecting on their pedagogical strengths and growth areas
Family Transparency Checklist: gives families clear questions to ask when evaluating an early childhood program
This book grew out of my Master of Science in Curriculum and Instruction capstone research at Western Governors University, a qualitative study of 22 regional and national business partners, center directors, classroom educators, licensed K–12 teachers, and parents across Indiana.
Sean McCool, M.S., is an early childhood education leader serving as a Center Director and district Quality Team Leader for NAEYC Accredited+ and PTQ Level 4 programs in Indiana. He is also a CDA Professional Development Specialist with the Council for Professional Recognition. He holds an M.S. in Curriculum and Instruction and is pursuing a second master's in Management and Leadership.
Paperback • 107 pages
Companion Toolkit • 81 pages
ISBN: 979-8-1898-2386-2
Independently published, 2026
$19.99
Interested in a book talk, training, or copies for your program or team? Let's connect.