We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
Updated: 2026-09-22 · 6 min read · Independent comparison
If you want one flexible set of silicone cups that handles muffins, eggs, snacks and even air fryer bagels in almost any cooker, choose SAWNZC Silicone Baking Muffin; if you need a dedicated donut-and-bagel mold built specifically to drop into an 8QT–10QT dual-basket air fryer, choose Domigard 2.
• SAWNZC Silicone Baking Muffin — biggest strength: 12 food-grade silicone cups in 4 colors that are microwave, freezer, oven (up to 446°F) and dishwasher safe, so they work as muffin liners, egg cups, snack cups and lunchbox dividers.
• SAWNZC Silicone Baking Muffin — biggest trade-off: Each cup is standard muffin size (2.76 x 1.77 x 1.3 inches) and round, so it is not a single molded pan and won't give you a specific air fryer basket footprint.
• Domigard 2 — biggest strength: Two 5-cavity donut molds designed to fit Ninja DZ201, DZ302, DZ401, DZ550, SL201, SL400, SL401 and other 8QT–10QT dual-basket air fryers, plus COSORI Dual 9QT.
• Domigard 2 — biggest trade-off: It is a two-piece specialty mold for round shapes only, and Domigard notes you should lightly grease for sticky batters rather than relying purely on the nonstick surface.
• For bakers who want one do-everything set: SAWNZC Silicone Baking Muffin. For dual-basket air fryer owners chasing bagels and donuts: Domigard 2.
The SAWNZC set is the generalist of the two. You get 12 round silicone cups in white, green, navy and dusty blue, packed in a paper box, and the material is food-grade silicone that is BPA free. Because each cup is standard muffin size, they drop into most muffin tins or stand on their own on a flat baking sheet, which means you are not locked into one appliance. Oven, microwave, freezer and dishwasher are all fine, and the heat ceiling sits at 446°F.
Reusability is the whole pitch here. Silicone cups like these can be used for thousands of times, so the disposable paper liner habit goes away. Nonstick silicone means baked goods release with their shape intact and cleanup is just water or a dishwasher cycle. Beyond muffins, the same cups handle cooking eggs, prepping treats, dividing a lunchbox, holding snacks, or even lining a car cup holder.
Domigard 2: Who It's For
The Domigard 2 is a specialist, and it is upfront about it. This is a two-piece set of 5-cavity silicone donut molds built to fit Ninja dual-zone air fryers in the 8QT–10QT range, with the manufacturer naming DZ201, DZ302, DZ401, DZ550, SL201, SL400 and SL401, plus the COSORI Dual 9QT and other 8QT–10QT double-basket units. If you own one of those, the molds are shaped to sit in the basket instead of rattling around.
The material story is similar to the SAWNZC: BPA-free, food-grade silicone safe for direct food contact, rated from -40°F to 446°F, and fine in the air fryer, oven, microwave and dishwasher. The dimensions are 8.27 x 1.97 x 6.3 inches per mold and the set weighs 0.33 kg. Two molds means double the output in one session — useful for weekend treats, busy families, or baking with kids, and it is packaged as a gift-friendly set for holidays or birthdays. Included components are simply the 2 silicone donut molds, in black.
Cleanup is flexible silicone and nonstick, so you can rinse or dishwasher it. One honest caveat straight from the product: lightly grease before use, especially with sticky batters. In my opinion, buy this if you own a compatible dual-basket air fryer and want repeatable round shapes — bagels, donuts, and similar ring bakes — without trimming parchment. Skip it if your air fryer is a single basket, a different size, or a brand not on that compatibility list, because the fit is the entire value proposition.
Side-by-Side: Which Should You Choose?
• Best for air fryer bagels → Domigard 2. The 5-cavity molds are designed for ring-shaped bakes and fit specific dual-basket air fryers.
• Best for versatility → SAWNZC Silicone Baking Muffin. 12 cups cover muffins, eggs, snacks, lunchbox dividers and cup holder liners.
• Best for appliance compatibility → SAWNZC Silicone Baking Muffin. Standard round cups work in most muffin tins or freestanding on a sheet, with no brand list to check.
• Best for dual-basket air fryer owners → Domigard 2. Named fit for Ninja DZ201, DZ302, DZ401, DZ550, SL201, SL400, SL401 and COSORI Dual 9QT.
• Best for small, mixed baking → SAWNZC Silicone Baking Muffin. Individual cups let you bake a few at a time or mix sizes of treats on one tray.
• Best for heat-range parity → tie. Both are food-grade silicone rated to 446°F, and both are dishwasher safe.
• Best for gift-giving → Domigard 2. It is explicitly positioned as a holiday or birthday gift set for family and friends.
I would buy the SAWNZC Silicone Baking Muffin if I wanted one set that earns its cabinet space every week — muffins, eggs, snacks, and air fryer bagels without worrying about which appliance it fits. I would buy Domigard 2 only if I already owned a compatible 8QT–10QT dual-basket air fryer and knew that donuts and ring bakes were my main project. In my opinion, the SAWNZC set is the safer, more flexible pick for most kitchens, while Domigard 2 is the better tool for a narrow, specific job. Check the current price on Amazon before you decide, since either one can make sense depending on what you already own.
how to air fry bagels
Shape your dough or batter into rings and place them in a mold or cup so they hold their form in the basket. With the Domigard 2, the 5-cavity molds are sized for compatible 8QT–10QT dual-basket air fryers; with SAWNZC cups, the round silicone cups sit freestanding on a sheet or in a basket. Lightly grease silicone before sticky batters, per Domigard's own note.
how long do i air fry bagels for
Neither data sheet lists cook times or temperatures for bagels, so I won't invent a number. What the sheets do tell you is the safe ceiling: both products are rated up to 446°F and are oven, microwave and dishwasher safe, so you can follow your own bagel recipe's time and temperature as long as it stays within that range.
how do i air fry pizza bagels
Treat them like any ring-shaped bake: keep them in a mold or cup so toppings and cheese don't slide off into the basket. Domigard 2's two 5-cavity molds give you ten slots per session in a compatible dual-basket air fryer, while SAWNZC's 12 cups let you do a few at a time and are nonstick for easy release.
do silicone baking molds work in the oven and dishwasher too
Yes for both products. SAWNZC cups are oven, microwave, freezer and dishwasher safe up to 446°F, and Domigard 2's molds are rated -40°F to 446°F and are oven, microwave and dishwasher safe as well. Domigard adds that a light grease helps with sticky batters.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.
See also: Eiyisem Silicone Muffin Pan vs SAWNZC 24Pack: Air Fryer, INFRAOVENS Air Fryer Silicone vs HONGBAKE Nonstick Muffin Pan, SHEbaking Silicone Muffin Pans vs Reynolds Kitchens Air Fryer