Theoretical Framework & Development Process
The SA-CROT framework is built upon robust pedagogical theories and cognitive models:
Cognitive Taxonomy (Revised Bloom’s Taxonomy):
The 5-point rating scale reflects progressive levels of cognitive processing (from Understanding to Analyzing), grounded in Constructivism and Domain Specificity (Anderson & Krathwohl, 2001).
Experiential Learning & Reflection:
Grounded in adult learning principles, SA-CROT supports self-directed learning (SDL) by encouraging reflective practice and self-evaluation.
Conceptualization & Initial Item Pool Generation
The development of SA-CROT began with an extensive qualitative and conceptual mapping process to establish its face and content validity:
1. Conceptual Mapping (Maruyama et al., 2021)
Rather than relying on fragmented existing models, a comprehensive concept analysis synthesized traditional clinical reasoning literature into four integrated core thinking processes.
2. Initial 60-Item Draft Creation
An initial pool of 60 provisional items (15 per domain) was developed by synthesizing key conceptual and empirical sources:
Scientific evidence-driven: Concept analysis findings (Maruyama et al., 2021) and the SACRR (Royeen et al., 2000).
Client's narrative-driven: Concept analysis findings and reasoning frameworks from the Model of Human Occupation (MOHO; Forsyth & Kielhofner, 2012).
Professional ethics-driven: Concept analysis findings and occupational therapy code of ethics guidelines (Japanese Association of Occupational Therapists).
Practice context-driven: Concept analysis findings, community OT literature (Carrier et al., 2010), and qualitative research on personal/situational reasoning (Maruyama et al., 2017).
3. Qualitative Expert Refinement (A-CROT: 40 Items)
Through a rigorous multi-stage expert review process, the item pool was refined into the 40-item A-CROT (Assessment of Clinical Reasoning in Occupational Therapy):
Focus Group Interview 1 (n = 6 educators): Streamlined the 60 provisional items down to 40 core items.
Consensus-Building Process (n = 8 educators): Refined item phrasing and conceptual alignment.
Focus Group Interview 2 (n = 7 educators): Evaluated item descriptors and rating scale structure.
Cognitive Interviews (n = 6 target users): Assessed clarity, interpretability, and usability of the items and rating scale.
Psychometric Validation & Evolutionary Refinement (SA-CROT: 14 Items)
To transform the 40-item A-CROT into a highly efficient, robust self-assessment tool, advanced psychometric analyses were systematically applied across expanding target populations:
Advanced Rasch Analysis & Psychometric Scaling:
Rasch Measurement Theory was applied to evaluate unidimensionality, item fit, rating scale efficiency, and person-item targeting.
Extended Sample Standardization (Up to 6 Years of Practice):
In the most recent validation studies, the sample was extended to include occupational therapists with up to 6 years of clinical experience. Rasch analysis confirmed that the 14-item scale maintains strong structural validity and invariance across both students and early-to-mid-career clinicians.
Structural Cross-Validation:
Differential Item Functioning (DIF), Confirmatory Factor Analysis (CFA), and Test-Retest Reliability further established the instrument’s structural validity, absence of demographic bias, and temporal stability.
Through this multi-phase psychometric reduction and extended validation process, the 14-item SA-CROT was finalized as a streamlined, highly reliable, and widely applicable assessment tool for clinical reasoning.