How We Research
We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
If you want a ready-made, multi-size parchment set that covers cake pans and air fryer baskets in one box, choose Rowcay 300; if you need a big stack of small silicone-coated rounds for lining a fryer basket over and over, choose Generic 4xSilicone.
• Rowcay 300 — biggest strength: 300 precut rounds in three useful diameters (6", 8", 10"), so there's no trimming and no guessing which liner fits.
• Rowcay 300 — biggest trade-off: It's plain food-grade wood pulp paper with no silicone coating, and the largest size is still only 10".
• Generic 4xSilicone — biggest strength: A food-grade silicone coating on extra-thick 45gsm paper, in a much wider spread of round sizes from roughly 4" up to about 10".
• Generic 4xSilicone — biggest trade-off: The listing's size options are confusing and the smallest rounds are tiny, so you have to read the size chart carefully before choosing.
• Who each pick is for: Rowcay 300 for bakers and air-fryer users who want one box that covers cakes, tortilla presses and larger baskets; Generic 4xSilicone for anyone who mainly lines small air fryer baskets and wants the slickest non-stick release.
Rowcay 300 is built around the idea that you shouldn't have to cut anything. The set ships as 300 sheets split into three stacks — 100 rounds at 6", 100 at 8" and 100 at 10". That's a genuinely practical spread: the 6" rounds drop into small cake tins and compact air fryer baskets, the 8" covers standard round pans, and the 10" handles the bigger springform tins and larger fryer baskets. Nothing needs trimming, which matters more than it sounds when you're lining a pan at speed.
The paper itself is food-grade wood pulp, rated heat-resistant up to 432°F (220°C), and described as waterproof, oil-resistant and tear-resistant. Those are solid numbers for a liner — 432°F sits comfortably above typical air fryer and oven baking temperatures, so you're not flirting with the paper scorching on a normal bake. It's also lightweight and stackable, and the flat-packed presentation is neat enough that it works as a gift alongside being a working kitchen supply.
Who should buy it: home bakers who rotate between several pan sizes, anyone who uses a tortilla press, and air fryer owners who want a liner wide enough for a full basket rather than a token small round. Who should skip it: if you almost never bake in round tins and only ever line one small basket, you'll burn through the 6" stack and leave the 8" and 10" rounds sitting there — a mixed-size box is only good value if you actually use all three sizes.
Generic 4xSilicone goes the other way: it leans on the coating rather than the count. The paper is described as food-grade silicone-coated, which is the part that does the heavy lifting for release — food lifts off without sticking, and when you're done you peel the sheet out and bin it. That's the whole appeal of a liner: no scrubbing, no soaking, no scraping cheese residue off a basket.
It also uses extra-thick 45gsm paper, which is a real spec advantage in a disposable liner. Thicker paper resists tearing when you're lifting a loaded sheet out, and it holds up better under the weight of something like a grilled sandwich or a portion of fries. The size range is broader than Rowcay's on paper — six options spanning roughly 10cm (about 3.9") up to 25.5cm (about 10"), in a round shape, white. The caveat: those six sizes are selectable variants, not a single mixed box, and there's no size chart clarity beyond the listed diameters. If you pick wrong, you get a stack that doesn't fit your basket.
Who should buy it: air fryer owners who want maximum non-stick release from a thicker sheet, and anyone who already knows the exact diameter their basket needs. Who should skip it: anyone who wants one purchase to cover multiple pan sizes, and anyone who doesn't want to think hard about which of six near-identical sizes to order.
Side-by-Side: Which Should You Choose?
• Best non-stick release → Generic 4xSilicone. The food-grade silicone coating is the specific feature aimed at food not sticking, and it's the reason to pick this one.
• Best for thicker, tear-resistant sheets → Generic 4xSilicone. 45gsm paper is the heavier stock here; Rowcay doesn't publish a paper weight.
• Best for small air fryer baskets → Generic 4xSilicone. Its smaller rounds start around 10cm, which suits compact single-portion baskets better than Rowcay's 6" minimum.
• Best for high-heat confidence → Rowcay 300. A stated 432°F (220°C) rating is a concrete number to work with; Generic's listing gives no temperature figure.
• Best for bakers and gift buyers → Rowcay 300. Flat-packed, stackable and presented as gift-ready, with the sheet count printed clearly on the box.
• Best for bulk small-round volume → Generic 4xSilicone. The range is listed as 500pcs on the title, so if you only ever use one small size, you can commit to that size and get a deep stack.
• If you're lining a basket for cheese sticks → either works, but decide by size. Grab Rowcay 300 if your basket is wide, Generic 4xSilicone if it's small and you want the slicker coating.
In my opinion, Rowcay 300 is the safer buy for most people, because a 300-sheet set in 6", 8" and 10" covers nearly every round pan and basket in a normal kitchen, and the stated 432°F rating is a number I can actually check against my cooking temperatures. I'd only steer you to Generic 4xSilicone if you know your basket's exact diameter, want the silicone coating for the cleanest release, and prefer the heavier 45gsm stock. If your only job for these liners is air fryer cheese sticks in one small basket, the Generic set's smaller rounds and coated surface are the more targeted pick. Check the current price on Amazon for both and let your pan sizes decide.
how to air fryer cheese sticks
Line the basket with a parchment round first, then place the cheese sticks on top with space between them so hot air can move around each one. Cook at a temperature below the liner's heat limit — Rowcay's rounds are rated to 432°F (220°C) — and never put loose parchment in a preheating basket, since it can lift into the heating element.
how to air fryer mozzarella sticks
The main issue with mozzarella is leakage: once the coating splits, cheese runs out and welds itself to the basket. A non-stick liner catches that mess, which is exactly what the silicone-coated Generic 4xSilicone sheets are designed for. Use a round sized to your basket so the paper sits flat and doesn't curl up at the edges.
how to air fry mozzarella sticks frozen
Frozen sticks go straight in — no thawing, or the coating turns to mush before it crisps. Give them room, don't stack them, and use a liner you can lift out afterwards. If your basket is small, the smaller Generic 4xSilicone rounds (around 10–12cm) fit better than a 6" Rowcay round, which may overhang.
how to air fry mozzarella sticks without them exploding
Explosions are almost always a coating failure, not a paper problem. Freeze them solid before cooking, keep the temperature moderate rather than blazing, and don't overcrowd. A thicker liner like the 45gsm Generic 4xSilicone sheet does one useful job here: it stays intact when you pull the basket out and lift the whole batch clear of any cheese that escaped.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.
See also: CEGLIA Air fryer foil vs Generic Liner: Can You Put Aluminum, ReLuien 8 vs Wellsworth 40GSM: Air Fryer Cake, INFRAOVENS Parchment Paper Sheets vs Lekue Lékué Air Fryer