The Research Network on Intergenerational Mobility (RNIM) is an initiative by scholars working on intergenerational mobility. The aim of the network is to provide a platform for both senior and junior researchers to discuss and disseminate the findings from their ongoing research projects on intergenerational mobility. The network will organize a virtual seminar every month.
Each seminar consists of a 60-minute presentation followed by a moderated Q&A session within a 75-minute Zoom conference. Participants can ask clarifying questions through the moderator during the presentation.
Highlight of this month
Rankings of social mobility depend critically on the dimension and indicator used. Societies that rank highly on one measure may rank poorly on another, yet existing research offers limited guidance for selecting among competing measures. We provide the first systematic evidence on preferences over four dimensions of social mobility (education, occupation, income, and wealth) and three indicators of income mobility: the rank–rank slope (RRS), absolute mobility (AM), and upward mobility from the bottom (CER25). Using a conjoint experiment and a within-subject rating design, we examine how a broadly representative US sample (N = 1,002) and experts (N = 99) rate different dimensions and indicators of social mobility. We embed these preference-based approaches in a social-welfare framework to shed light on the underlying assumptions embedded in different measures of social mobility. We report five sets of findings. First, each indicator is an exact welfare-sufficient statistic for a distinct social objective, and no indicator satisfies all normatively appealing axioms. Second, income is the dimension the public values most, in a ranking that is stable across demographic subgroups. Third, the RRS, the indicator most prominent in the academic literature, receives the least public support. AM and CER25 receive greater support, with roughly 70% of the gap associated with lower perceived fairness. Fourth, experts share the public’s ranking of dimensions but support CER25 more and AM less. Finally, incorporating these preferences into a social mobility composite measure substantially attenuates the Great Gatsby curve and shifts state rankings by up to 32 positions. These findings provide an empirical basis for selecting social mobility measures and designing evidence-based policy targets aligned with public preferences.