Harvey E. Beech, one of the first African American students to integrate higher education in North Carolina, experienced both opportunity and exclusion when he attended North Carolina State College in the early 1950s. While enrolled in a summer program, Beech was issued a “swimming card” granting access to the campus pool, a standard part of student life following physical examinations. Shortly after, officials informed him that the card had been given “by mistake” and asked for its return, effectively revoking his right to use the facility because of his race. Although he refused to surrender it, the incident exposed the deep contradictions of desegregation: Black students were granted admission but denied equal participation in social and recreational spaces. The swimming card became a powerful symbol of how systemic racism persisted beyond the classroom, reminding institutions that true equity in higher education requires inclusion across every dimension of campus life, including recreation, housing, and community spaces (University of North Carolina, 2020; Houston History Magazine, 2013).
Source: “Unbuilt: Columbia Gymnasium Proposal (1968).” Morningside Heights: 1968 Columbia Gym. N.p., n.d. Web. 11 May 2014. <http://www.morningside-heights.net/gym.htm>.
After Columbia proposed and began to construct a gym in Morningside Park in the 1960s, students and members of the West Harlem community came together in fierce opposition of the stratified gym and the ongoing gentrification of the local neighborhood that it represented. Columbia University’s expansion during this period intensified conflict, as the institution acquired more than ninety residential buildings and converted low-income housing into student dormitories. These actions displaced many Harlem residents, fueling accusations that Columbia was attempting to “sanitize” the area and push out poorer, primarily Black communities. The university’s proposed gymnasium in Morningside Park became the flashpoint. Harlem residents were promised limited access through a separate entrance, an arrangement likened to “Jim Crow” segregation. The “Gym Crow” controversy symbolized broader patterns of racial exclusion and institutional power over marginalized neighborhoods.
(Slonecker, 2008)
The protests were empowered by the Civil Rights movement, vietnam war and other countercultural movements. These movements were prevalent in both the Columbia community and the surrounding West Harlem community. Students in several groups, such as Students for a Democratic Society and Congress of Racial Equality, organized protests in opposition to the Morningside gym—protests that eventually came to a dramatic halt, leading Columbia to cancel its construction plans.
(Hernandez, 2022)
The Columbia Coalition: Columbia's perceived institutional racism along with the University's complicity in the Vietnam War through the IDA, Institute for Defense, caused a surge in Columbia students and the Harlem community forming a coalition and hundreds upon hundreds actively protesting (Slonecker, 2008).
By Noelle Hunter / Senior Staff Illustrator/Photographs courtesy of Annie Son. In 1959, Columbia announced its plans to build a new gym located in Morningside Park.
“When I was in school in Ann Arbor, and a hundred of us were Black, we were lost in the ocean there.”
– William DeHart Hubbard (Tobin, n.d.)
“He didn’t think I ought to play football. He didn’t believe that one white kid would block another white kid for a Black kid to make a touchdown.”
– Willis Ward (Tobin, n.d.)
"You get tickets to go to the football game, and the chancellor himself tells you, "Young man, I know you all didn't come over here to go to the football game. You all came to go to law school." And I didn't say anything."
-Harvey Beech (Beech, 1996)