How We Research
We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
Updated: 2026-09-25 · 6 min read · Independent comparison
• PUSNMI Bamboo Skewers 8 — biggest strength: 100 eight-inch bamboo skewers with a wide flat paddle handle, so you can pierce a cheese stick, hold it steady, and rotate it without burning your fingers.
• PUSNMI Bamboo Skewers 8 — biggest trade-off: they're a tool, not a barrier. They do nothing to stop cheese from oozing onto the basket, and the manufacturer says to soak them at least 10 minutes before use and keep them below 200 degrees.
• Valcatch 50/100 — biggest strength: food-grade parchment liners in 4", 6" and 8" round sizes, heat resistant up to 428°F (the description also cites 446°F/230°C), oil-proof, waterproof and non-stick, with a raised edge that shields the sides of the fryer.
• Valcatch 50/100 — biggest trade-off: they're disposable, and they don't hold or turn food — they just sit under it. You still need something to lift and flip.
• Who each pick is for: PUSNMI for anyone who wants one durable skewering and flipping tool for kabobs, appetizers and party snacks; Valcatch for anyone who hates scrubbing cheese residue out of an air fryer and wants zero cleanup.
The PUSNMI set is exactly what the name says: 100 pieces of 8-inch (20cm) bamboo, made from 100% natural bamboo with stronger plant fibers, screened and cleaned during manufacturing so they come out strong, prickle-free and unlikely to split. The design detail that matters most for air fryer cheese is the paddle end. One end is a wide flat paddle you can grip and turn; the other is sharp enough to pierce food and hold it without spinning or dropping. In my opinion, that's the single most useful thing here, because a cheese stick that rotates on its own skewer is a cheese stick that dumps its coating into the basket.
Where this set shines is anything you spear: mozzarella and cheese sticks, kabobs, fruit skewers, dessert bites, sandwiches, mini burgers, cocktail picks. The manufacturer lists them as suitable for ovens and air fryers when kept safe below 200 degrees, which is a real constraint worth respecting — a hot air fryer running a long, high-temp cycle is not this tool's friend. Soak them in water for at least 10 minutes before they go anywhere near heat. Adult supervision is needed if kids are using them. You get 100 pieces, which is plenty for a family celebration or a party tray, and they double as a small gift for family and friends.
Buy PUSNMI if you want a reusable, cheap-per-use skewering tool with a handle you can actually grab while your hands are messy. Skip it if you're mainly trying to protect the air fryer basket from grease and melted cheese — skewers won't do that, and you'll still be washing the basket afterward.
Valcatch is the other half of the equation. These are round disposable parchment liners made from food-grade pulp with a silicone oil non-stick coating — waterproof, oil-proof, grease-resistant and non-stick. They handle heat up to 428°F, and the product description puts the ceiling at 446°F/230°C, so they're comfortable in an oven, air fryer, microwave or freezer. They come in 4", 6" and 8" rounds, in packs of 50 or 100 sheets. The 4-inch size is built for jumbo muffin or cupcake pans at roughly 10 x 6.5cm, and the 6" and 8" sizes suit cheesecake and basque-style bakes at roughly 15.5 x 9cm. The 4-inch version has a 6.5cm/2.56" height; the larger ones run 9cm/3.54".
For cheese sticks specifically, the appeal is the bowl shape and the heightened edge. You don't tear, fold, cut or bend anything — you drop the liner in the basket and cook. That raised rim catches grease and keeps food from welding itself to the side of the fryer, and the non-stick surface means whatever you pull out releases cleanly. The manufacturer also notes the paper has no effect on the taste of your food, which matters if you're fussy about papery flavors bleeding into a hot snack.
Buy Valcatch if cleanup is your least favorite part of air frying and you want a liner that handles baking, roasting and air frying with the same sheet. Skip it if you need something to physically hold or turn a cheese stick — these are passive liners, and they're single-use, so you'll be restocking. If you use them in an air fryer, keep them weighed down by food and don't run them empty under a strong fan, since a light liner can shift.
Side-by-Side: Which Should You Choose?
• Best for zero-scrub cleanup after cheese melts everywhere → Valcatch 50/100. The non-stick liner catches the grease and the melted cheese never touches the basket.
• Best for party and appetizer volume → PUSNMI Bamboo Skewers 8. 100 skewers in one pack covers a full tray of kabobs, fruit picks and cocktail bites.
• Best for baking and dessert work → Valcatch 50/100. 4", 6" and 8" rounds cover jumbo cupcakes, cheesecake and basque-style bakes, not just air fryer duty.
• Best for heat tolerance → Valcatch 50/100. It's rated to 428°F (446°F/230°C per the description) versus the skewers' stated safe range below 200 degrees.
• Best for reusable value over time → PUSNMI Bamboo Skewers 8. One box is a tool you keep; liners are consumables you replace.
• Best for freezer-to-air-fryer frozen snacks → Valcatch 50/100. The liners are freezer-safe and go straight from cold storage into the basket.
• Best if you want both jobs covered → buy both. Honestly, this is the setup I'd run: a liner underneath to catch the mess, a skewer through the cheese stick so you can flip it cleanly.
If I had to pick one, I'd buy the Valcatch 50/100 liners for air fryer cheese sticks. Melted cheese is the messiest thing you can put in an air fryer, and a non-stick liner with a raised edge solves the problem the skewers can't touch. That said, the PUSNMI skewers are the better long-term tool for anyone who cooks kabobs, appetizers and party snacks regularly — and if you're making cheese sticks often, the two together are a genuinely better combo than either alone. Check the current price on Amazon before you decide, since pack size (50 vs 100 sheets, and the 4"/6"/8" options) changes what you're actually getting.
FAQ
how to air fryer cheese sticks
Skewer each cheese stick on a paddle skewer so you can turn it without tongs, then set it on a Valcatch liner in the basket so the coating and melted cheese stay off the metal. Keep the skewers below 200 degrees as the manufacturer specifies, and soak them at least 10 minutes first.
how to air fryer mozzarella sticks
how to air fry mozzarella sticks frozen
Frozen sticks go in straight from the freezer — the Valcatch liners are freezer-safe and go from cold storage to the basket without any prep. Don't thaw them first if you want the coating to stay intact, and use a liner so any blowout doesn't bake onto the basket.
how to air fry mozzarella sticks without them exploding
Two things help: don't overcrowd the basket, and don't let the sticks sit in pooled grease. A round parchment liner with a heightened edge catches the grease and keeps the sides clear, and a skewer lets you flip each stick with one clean motion instead of stabbing at it with tongs.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.
See also: Healifty 200Pcs vs HANWER 100: Air Fryer Dumplings, MESTAEK Air Fryer Paper vs Generic 100-Pack, CHUAHAHA Air Fryer Paper vs FOXYAEO 100: Can You Use