How We Research
We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
If you want an everyday open-ear Bluetooth headphone for running, cycling and calls on dry land, choose Purity Air Open Ear; if you need headphones that survive actual swimming and play music without a phone, choose Opinta Swimming Headphones.
• Purity Air Open Ear — biggest strength: Air-conduction open-ear design with two 15mm dynamic drivers, dual mics for calls, IPX5 sweat resistance and Bluetooth 5.3 — a straightforward wireless headphone for workouts and daily use.
• Purity Air Open Ear — biggest trade-off: IPX5 is splash/sweat resistance, not swim-proof, and it has no built-in memory, so it always needs a paired phone. Battery life is listed at 6 hours.
• Opinta Swimming Headphones — biggest strength: IPX8 waterproofing plus 32GB of onboard memory, so it can play music with no phone at all — including underwater in MP3 mode.
• Opinta Swimming Headphones — biggest trade-off: Bone conduction tuning starts at 200Hz (bass is limited by design), and Bluetooth simply doesn't work underwater — you must switch to MP3 mode in the pool.
• Who each pick is for: Purity Air Open Ear for dry-land athletes and call-heavy users; Opinta Swimming Headphones for swimmers and anyone who wants phone-free playback.
The Purity Air Open Ear is a neckband-style open-ear headphone built around air conduction. Two 15mm dynamic drivers sit at the ear openings and push sound toward your ear canal without sealing it, which is why the design keeps you aware of traffic, other runners and whatever is happening around you. That situational awareness is the whole point of the category, and it's the reason this style has become so common for outdoor training.
What stands out in the specs is the call side of things. There are dual microphones with environmental noise cancellation for voice pickup, plus touch controls for call handling. Bluetooth 5.3 and a 10-meter range cover the normal phone-in-pocket or phone-on-desk distances. The IPX5 rating means sweat and light rain aren't a problem, and at 2.8 ounces with a "secured long wearing comfort" design brief, this is clearly aimed at people who keep headphones on for hours — long runs, long rides, long workdays.
Opinta Swimming Headphones: Who It's For
The Opinta Swimming Headphones are a different animal entirely. This is a bone conduction headphone with an IPX8 waterproof rating — the highest level in the common IP scale — which the manufacturer says covers sweat, rain and actual swimming, including wearing it under a swim cap and goggles. Bone conduction sends vibration through your cheekbones instead of through the air, so your ears stay fully open, which is the same safety benefit as the Purity, just delivered differently.
The headline feature is the 32GB of built-in memory. That's the spec that changes how you use it: you load music onto the headphone itself and play it in MP3 mode with no phone involved. The manufacturer states it holds up to 8,000 tracks and supports MP3, WAV, WMA, M4A and FLAC. That matters because Bluetooth does not transmit through water — the product's own guidance is to switch to MP3 mode when you're in the pool. On land, Bluetooth 6.0 with a 10-meter range handles normal wireless use, and there's a built-in microphone for calls and voice assistant commands.
Battery is quoted at 8 hours of music playback, 110 hours of standby, and a 2-hour charge time via a magnetic connector. The trade-offs to know: bone conduction tuning runs from 200Hz to 20,000Hz, so deep bass is not its strength — this is a design characteristic of the technology, not a defect. And the 32-ohm impedance is a bit higher than typical, but since the built-in player drives the headphones directly, that's not something you need to worry about in practice.
Side-by-Side: Which Should You Choose?
• Best for swimming → Opinta Swimming Headphones. IPX8 versus IPX5 is the single biggest dividing line between these two.
• Best for calls and voice pickup → Purity Air Open Ear. Dual mics with environmental noise cancellation are explicitly part of its design.
• Best for battery life on a single charge → Opinta Swimming Headphones. 8 hours of music versus 6 hours on the Purity Air.
• Best for long-wear comfort on land → Purity Air Open Ear. At 2.8 ounces with a comfort-focused neckband and air-conduction delivery, it's built for all-day wear.
• Best for bass and full-range music detail → Purity Air Open Ear. Its 15mm dynamic drivers reach down to 20Hz, while the Opinta's bone conduction range starts at 200Hz.
• Best for the gym, running and cycling → Purity Air Open Ear. IPX5 handles sweat, and Bluetooth 5.3 is a mature, reliable wireless standard.
• Best for triathlon-style training → Opinta Swimming Headphones. It's the only one of the two that covers the swim leg as well as the bike and run.
If I had to pick one, I'd buy the Opinta Swimming Headphones, because it does something the Purity Air simply cannot: it works in the water and it works without a phone. The 32GB of memory, IPX8 rating and 8-hour battery make it the more versatile of the two, and the Bluetooth 6.0 connection covers everything you'd use the Purity for on land. That said, if your training never touches a pool and you take a lot of calls, the Purity Air Open Ear is the more natural fit — better bass, a lighter neckband and a proper dual-mic setup. Two different jobs, two different answers, and only you know which job is yours.
FAQ
No. Bluetooth signals don't travel through water, and the manufacturer's own instructions say to switch to MP3 mode when you're underwater. That's exactly why the 32GB of built-in memory exists.
Not in MP3 mode — you load tracks into the 32GB of memory and play them directly. You only need a phone for Bluetooth mode on land, such as for calls via the built-in mic.
Both are sold on Amazon, and prices change over time, so check the current price on Amazon using the button on this page before you decide. Price wasn't a factor in this comparison — I ranked them purely on design, specs and how each one fits real use.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.