Pothole Season Hits Hard: Flat Repairs Highest Per Auto Shop in the Northeast, Reveals Shift in Service Volume as a Result of Deteriorating Roads

[White Plains, New York] – [7/31/2025] – American drivers are increasingly grappling with the financial burden of unexpected maintenance driven by seasonal road damage and wear-and-tear from winter weather, a trend supported by new service data from Mavis Tire. While tire repairs are on the rise nationwide, drivers in the Northeast region are bearing the brunt of the impact (pun intended), leading the nation in tire related repair frequency per location according to this newly released data. The contributing factors point to a challenging combination of seasonal road damage, freeze-thaw cycles, and aging roads shaped by decades of tough winters, forcing consumers to dig deeper into their pockets for unanticipated maintenance.

To be specific, Precision Auto Service and repair reveals that shops in the Northeast are seeing a staggering 60% more flat tire repairs per location compared to their counterparts in the South and West (that's nearly 1.6 times the volume). This isn't just a small uptick; flat repairs now constitute over 10% of all service visits across their Northeast locations, the highest ratio of any U.S. region.

Precision Auto Service and repair locations in the South and West are also experiencing faster year-over-year growth in flat repairs (up 7.5% from the year prior), however the magnitude of the problem in the Northeast suggests a more prevalent issue. "Our data indicates that the harsh winters, characterized by potholes, road salt, debris, and cracked pavement, are taking a severe toll on tires in the Northeast," says Dan Krauss, VP of Inbound Sales Development and Conversion at Mavis. "It’s a clear, tangible reflection of the toll that harsh winter weather and seasonal road damage can take on drivers and vehicles alike."

The our data helps quantify what many drivers in the Northeast have already been experiencing on the road. According to the annual “States with the worst (and best) roads” analysis from Consumer Affairs, several Northeast states appear on the "worst" list for percentage of urban and rural roads in poor condition. A handful of these states have consistently appeared on this list for the last few years (Source: ConsumerAffairs' States With The Worst (And Best) Road Conditions 2025). 

The American Society of Civil Engineer’s (ASCE) 2025 infrastructure report card estimates that drivers spend a whopping $130 billion each year on extra vehicle repairs and operating costs because of deteriorating roads (Source: ASCE Report Card for America's Infrastructure). The same report indicates that 39% of major roads in the U.S. are in poor or mediocre condition. 

The increased prevalence of flat repairs is also creating a broader shift in consumer behavior. Rather than facing the higher cost of a full tire replacement, many drivers are opting for the more cost-effective flat patch and repair when possible, a savvy move to manage expenses.