How We Research
We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
If you want a wireless, Xbox-native headset with a detachable boom mic and a premium metal build, choose PowerA LucidSound LS35X; if you need a wired, budget-friendly headset with a customizable look and a noise-canceling cardioid mic, choose Black Shark Gaming Headset.
• PowerA LucidSound LS35X — biggest strength: True wireless freedom via Xbox Wireless, no dongle or base station, plus a detachable boom mic and up to 15 hours of battery.
• PowerA LucidSound LS35X — biggest trade-off: Heavier at 396 g, and the wireless connection is built around Xbox, so everything else runs wired through the included 3.5mm cable.
• Black Shark Gaming Headset — biggest strength: A wired 3.5mm design that works across PC, PlayStation, Xbox, Switch and Android, with a noise-canceling cardioid mic and a lighter 340 g frame.
• Black Shark Gaming Headset — biggest trade-off: It's wired only, the USB connector just powers the LED lighting, and the build is plastic rather than metal.
• Who each pick is for: Xbox-first players who hate cables → PowerA LucidSound LS35X. Multi-platform players who want a wired, customizable headset → Black Shark Gaming Headset.
The LS35X is built around one big idea: cutting the cord on Xbox. It uses Xbox Wireless technology to connect directly to an Xbox Series X, Series S or Xbox One exactly like a controller does — no dongle, no base station, no setup ritual. You can also see connection and battery status on screen, which is a genuinely useful touch when you're mid-match and don't want to guess how much charge is left. With up to 15 hours per charge, that's a full day of sessions before you need to plug in.
Where it really earns its keep is the audio and mic design. Precision-tuned 50mm drivers push amplified stereo sound, and it supports surround sound through Dolby Atmos or Windows Sonic. The dual-mic system is the standout: a detachable, flexible boom mic handles team chat with mic monitoring (sidetone) so you can hear your own voice, and pulling the boom off activates a secondary internal mic that's fine for mobile gaming and calls. LucidSound's signature controls let you adjust volume and game/chat balance on the fly, with toggles for game mute, mic mute and mic monitoring.
Buy it if you game primarily on Xbox and want a wireless, no-cable experience with a proper detachable boom mic, on-screen battery info and a metal-accented build. Skip it if you play mostly on PlayStation, Switch or PC and want wireless everywhere — those platforms run through the included 3.5mm cable. Also skip it if you want the lightest possible headset.
Black Shark Gaming Headset: Who It's For
The Black Shark Gaming Headset (model BS-X6) takes the opposite approach: it's a straightforward, wired 3.5mm headset that just works across PC, PS4, PS5, Xbox, Switch and Android. There's no battery to charge and no pairing to fumble with — plug the 4-conductor 3.5mm plug into your controller or device and you're in. The included USB connector is only for powering the LED lighting, so don't expect it to carry audio. The 2.2 m (7.2 ft) cable gives you plenty of slack to move around.
Audio comes from 50mm dynamic drivers with a 20Hz–20kHz frequency range, 32Ω impedance and 100dB±3dB sensitivity — specs that suggest it's easy to drive from a controller or phone without extra amplification. Black Shark frames the tuning around sound imaging, so footsteps, gunfire and environmental cues come through with precision for competitive play.
The mic is where this headset makes its case. It's a bendable, noise-canceling cardioid mic with a unidirectional pickup pattern, which means it focuses on your voice and pushes background noise down. The boom is adjustable, so you can position it exactly where it captures you best. That's a smart design for people who play in shared rooms or noisy spaces.
Comfort leans on a soft headband cushion and breathable memory foam ear pads that also provide passive noise isolation. At 340 g it's lighter than the LS35X, and the plastic enclosure keeps it that way. The fun extra is the detachable Black Shark Velcro patch on the headband — you can swap it for your own design to match your team or personality, which is a nice bit of personalization you rarely see.
Buy it if you play across multiple platforms, prefer a wired connection you never have to charge, and want a mic that actively cuts background noise. Skip it if you want wireless freedom, on-screen battery monitoring, or a metal build — this one is wired and plastic.
• Best for Xbox wireless → PowerA LucidSound LS35X. Xbox Wireless connects directly, no dongle, no base station.
• Best for multi-platform play → Black Shark Gaming Headset. One 3.5mm plug covers PC, PlayStation, Xbox, Switch and Android.
• Best for battery life → PowerA LucidSound LS35X. Up to 15 hours per charge, plus on-screen battery status.
• Best for noise-free chat in loud rooms → Black Shark Gaming Headset. The noise-canceling cardioid mic isolates your voice and cuts surrounding noise.
• Best for lightweight comfort → Black Shark Gaming Headset. 340 g versus 396 g, and it's wired so there's no battery weight trade-off.
• Best for mic flexibility → PowerA LucidSound LS35X. Detachable boom mic plus a secondary internal mic for calls and mobile gaming.
• Best for a premium feel → PowerA LucidSound LS35X. Metal touchpoints, gel-cooled memory foam and a travel bag.
• Best for personalization → Black Shark Gaming Headset. Swappable Velcro headband patch and LED lighting.
If I were buying for myself and my main console was an Xbox, I'd take the PowerA LucidSound LS35X (ASIN B071JSYH33). Wireless freedom, on-screen battery info, a detachable boom mic with sidetone, and a metal-accented build are hard to argue with for Xbox-first play. In my opinion, the LS35X is the better headset for anyone who values a cable-free setup and a premium feel. If you hop between platforms, want zero charging hassle, and care about a noise-canceling mic in a shared space, the Black Shark Gaming Headset is the smarter pick. Either way, check the current price on Amazon before you commit — that's the one variable I can't judge for you.
FAQ
Yes. It connects via the 3.5mm jack on PC, PS4, PS5, Xbox, Switch and Android. Just note the USB connector is only for powering the LED lighting, not for audio.
Both are solid, but they solve different problems. The LS35X uses a detachable boom mic with mic monitoring, plus a backup internal mic. The Black Shark uses a bendable, noise-canceling cardioid mic that isolates your voice from background noise — handy in noisy rooms.
The Black Shark is lighter at 340 g versus 396 g, with breathable memory foam pads. The LS35X counters with gel-cooled memory foam, a flexible headrail and earcups that twist flat around your neck. Both are built for long play, so it comes down to whether you prefer wireless flexibility or lower weight.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.