How We Research
We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
Updated: 2026-09-24 · 6 min read · Independent comparison
• POPQEEN Air Fryer Liners — biggest strength: an 11.6-inch rectangular parchment sized for the Ninja FG551 Foodi Smart XL 6-in-1 Indoor Grill, plus IG601 and IG651, with a 120-piece count that suits a household running a large combo unit several times a week.
• POPQEEN Air Fryer Liners — biggest trade-off: the sheet is built around one family of large rectangular baskets, so it will overhang badly in a small dual-basket drawer.
• Eleayur 200Pcs — biggest strength: 200 sheets at 8 x 5.5 inches with a 1.8-inch raised edge, sized for dual-basket and double-stack air fryers, with a stated heat ceiling of 450°F.
• Eleayur 200Pcs — biggest trade-off: that same small footprint means it will not cover the full floor of a large single rectangular basket.
• Who each is for: POPQEEN for owners of a large rectangular Ninja grill/air fryer combo; Eleayur for anyone cooking in two drawers at once and going through liners fast.
POPQEEN's whole pitch is fit. The parchment is a rectangular sheet measuring 11.6 inches, and the brand names the Ninja FG551 Foodi Smart XL 6-in-1 Indoor Grill alongside the IG601 and IG651 as the intended hosts. That matters more than it sounds. A liner only does its job if it covers the cooking surface and stays put; a sheet that is too small lets grease run around the edges, and one that is too big curls into the heating element. POPQEEN solves that by matching a specific, large, rectangular basket shape rather than trying to be a universal size.
The material is food-grade parchment paper described as oilproof, waterproof, non-stick and heat resistant up to 428°F. That is a sensible ceiling for air frying, roasting and light grilling — the kind of temperatures you actually use for sausages, meatloaf, pizza and vegetables. Because the paper is non-stick, food lifts off without scraping, and because it is disposable, the basket itself stays largely untouched. If you have ever spent ten minutes scrubbing a grill plate after a weeknight dinner, that is the appeal here: lift the liner, bin it, and the appliance is basically clean.
Eleayur 200Pcs: Who It's For
Eleayur goes the other direction: volume and compatibility across many machines. You get 200 sheets, each 8 inches long, 5.5 inches wide and 1.8 inches high. That raised 1.8-inch wall is the detail that separates these from a flat sheet of parchment — it forms a shallow tray, so crumbs, oil and small pieces of food stay contained instead of sliding off the edge when you lift the liner out.
The compatibility list is broad and specific: Ninja DZ550, DZ201, DZ401 and DZ302 dual air fryers, the Ninja SL401 double-stack air fryer, Bella 4QT and 6QT slim models, Chefman 6QT and 9QT dual air fryers, and other double-basket or rectangular-basket units. If you own any of those, you already know the frustration of a liner that does not sit flat in a narrow drawer. Eleayur sized for exactly that geometry.
Material-wise, the sheets are made from natural wood pulp coated with food-grade silicone oil, described as BPA-free, waterproof, oil-proof, nonstick and tear-resistant, with a stated heat tolerance of 450°F — slightly higher than POPQEEN's figure. The brand also includes a genuinely useful warning: always cover at least two-thirds of the liner with food and weigh down all four corners so the paper does not lift into the heating element. That is the single most common mistake people make with any disposable liner, and it is worth taking seriously regardless of which brand you buy.
The 200-count is the headline for a reason. In a dual-basket air fryer you often use two liners per cook, so a pack this size lasts a long time and suits meal-preppers, busy families and anyone who cooks in both drawers most nights. The brand also frames it as a gift for home cooks. I would steer away from Eleayur if your air fryer is one large single rectangular basket — 8 x 5.5 inches will not span it, and you would end up using two liners side by side.
• Best for a large rectangular Ninja grill/air fryer combo → POPQEEN Air Fryer Liners, sized at 11.6 inches for the FG551, IG601 and IG651.
• Best for dual-basket and double-stack air fryers → Eleayur 200Pcs, sized at 8 x 5.5 x 1.8 inches for DZ201, DZ401, DZ550, DZ302, SL401 and similar.
• Best for a bigger supply → Eleayur 200Pcs, with 200 sheets versus POPQEEN's 120.
• Best for a raised edge that holds crumbs → Eleayur 200Pcs, whose 1.8-inch wall turns the liner into a shallow tray.
• Best for higher stated heat tolerance → Eleayur 200Pcs at 450°F versus POPQEEN at 428°F.
• Best for coverage of one big basket → POPQEEN Air Fryer Liners, since a single sheet covers the whole floor.
• Best for ovens, steamers and microwaves as well → both, since each brand lists those uses — POPQEEN as 120 multipurpose pieces, Eleayur as 200.
• Best for camping and parties → POPQEEN Air Fryer Liners, whose packaging is described as lightweight and portable.
If I were buying for myself, the deciding question would be the shape of my basket, not the size of the pack. For a large rectangular Ninja Foodi Smart XL combo, I would buy POPQEEN Air Fryer Liners — the 11.6-inch sheet is the whole point, and 120 pieces is plenty for one appliance. For a dual-basket or double-stack air fryer, I would buy Eleayur 200Pcs: the 8 x 5.5 x 1.8-inch tray shape, the 200 count and the 450°F ceiling make it the more practical everyday option. Match the liner to your basket and either one keeps your machine clean.
No. POPQEEN's sheets measure 11.6 inches and are made for large rectangular Ninja grill/air fryer combos, while Eleayur's are 8 x 5.5 x 1.8 inches and target dual-basket and double-stack air fryers. They are not interchangeable sizes.
Eleayur 200Pcs, as the name suggests, includes 200 sheets. POPQEEN Air Fryer Liners includes 120 pieces. If you use two liners per cook in a dual-basket fryer, the larger pack stretches noticeably further.
Eleayur states heat safety up to 450°F, while POPQEEN states up to 428°F. Both are well within typical air frying and baking temperatures.
Both are described as nonstick, oilproof and waterproof parchment, so food releases easily and residue is caught by the liner instead of the basket. Eleayur adds a raised edge that helps contain crumbs and oil. Either way, check the current price on Amazon and confirm the size matches your air fryer model before ordering.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.
See also: Foopama Air Fryer Liners vs MESTAEK 7, LSR LORESO Air Fryer Liners vs CHUAHAHA 7.5in: Air Fryer, Rtuopk Air Fryer vs HOTEC Air Fryer Liners: Air Fryer