some thoughts
I consider myself fortunate to have the opportunity to ponder over curious questions, and to interact with bright younger students. As I gather experience in my journey, I feel the necessity to communicate on certain aspects, which may possibly be useful for someone younger, walking on a similar path. On this page I plan to write such stuff. The thoughts and the experiences are personal.
1. Requests for reference (if you're a younger student, considering to contact me for a reference, please read this before writing to me) :
I have been receiving many requests for reference letters for summer program applications and graduate studies. I really appreciate that you're interested in basic science. As there are many requests, it takes considerable time to respond, so I am summarising my thoughts here.
Please note that while I do not intend to judge anyone , in a letter I am expected to provide my critical opinion on the applicant on several grounds (related to academic potential, research aptitude etc.), based on my interactions with the person. Possibly to keep a certain sense of objectivity, it is expected to support the comments based on the academic performance and/or experience based on a (long-term) project. Thus, you're very welcome to request for a reference, if you need one from me, in the following scenarios :
a) (if) you have taken (at least) two courses [and have secured the highest grade, it will be great if you have also participated in classroom discussions],
b) (if) you have pursued a long-term (reading/research) project with me (and have been serious about it).
In such cases, I will certainly consider your request and will (most likely) be glad to support your applications providing an effective letter of reference.
If this is not the case, I would request you not to consider me for a reference. You may still write to me, but it would be good to have a primary letter of reference from someone else, and my letter, if necessary, may serve as a secondary reference. Kindly note that this does not imply any judgement/opinion on your academic (or otherwise) potential, just that my letter may not be effective and may not help your cause; please do not assume otherwise. I sincerely wish you all the very best in your pursuit.
Also, please give at least one week to consider and respond to your reference request; please consider that we are usually dealing with several things. Thanks for your understanding.