Solution Development
Design Tasks
Find hardware components that fit our needs
Design the Software to help navigate surroundings
Test sensors to ensure reliable object detection
Conduct human trials to confirm comfort and function of device
Ensure that the device can be equipped even without no visual input
Design Goals
In general terms, the main goals are that the solution shall:
Increase user safety.
Increase the reliability and user performance of cane based interactions
Make the method of use intuitive and easy for users
Provide a cheap alternative to other sources, such as guide dogs and other helpers
Use standard, easily sourced parts of still high quality, but low cost
Minimize the amount of maintenance and service the device may need by making the device durable, and construct the device so that in the case of damage it can be easily repaired or replaced
Constraints
Shall not use any visual aid.
Shall be made with readily available materials.
Shall not be incredibly overpriced compared to alternatives.
Shall be lightweight (preliminary weight is 3 pounds, can be updated after testing)
Shall be easy to put on and take off.
Connection method shall be a clip that can be adjusted, not Velcro (due to Velcro's limited lifespan)
Shall not physically interfere with standard activities, such as sitting/standing/laying.
Shall be not easily broken.
Device shall be possible to put on using touch alone.
Implement some asymmetry into device to provide clear indication of what part of the device goes where relative to the user
Specifications
Distance sensors options:
Motion Based
Light Based
Sound-wave Based
Camera Based
Alert modules options:
Sound Based
Touch Based
Temperature Based
Pressure Based
Possible Solutions
Vocal alert system attached to the head
Vibration output attached to shoes
Would use these vibrations to alert of when people or animals are nearby
Multiple components that shall be connected together (belt)
allows for attachment on not just waist but wrists and ankles as well if needed
360° camera attached above head
Input from artificial intelligence or technician giving feedback
Heat output around wrists or ankles
Warms and cools as objects get closer or farther away
Pressure output
Provides pressure to part of user that is closest to an obstacle
Path Elimination
The Vocal Alert System is a valid path as it shall provide the user a functional and affordable service. The system would not likely be damaged through use so it would last the user a long time and the components needed to build it would be simple to acquire and replace making it repairable. The main issue with this idea is that it could be too obtrusive and make constant noises that others around the user would hear.
The Vibrational Output attached to shoes is a fairly good idea however some issues may arise in its functionality when walking on uneven surfaces. Additionally, other vibrations in the surroundings, like construction sites, might mask the vibrations from the output in the shoes.
A 360° Camera attached on the head would be too costly and too cumbersome for the user. The weight of the camera on the head may be too much for the user and cause them to lose balance.
A Heat Output would be too unsafe for the user as there can be risks of burns from any heating apparatus used. Also results may not be receptible for the individual in certain weather conditions making it not the best path for a solution.
A Pressure Output would be not easy to use and may pose a safety risk to the individual. Users may not be able to distinguish direction through the output making it fail its main function.
Belt with Motion Sensors is a valid path because the user shall be easily able to utilize the belt as it would be simple to put on with its asymmetrical design and easy buckling. The user shall be able to avoid objects easily because of the warning system and it shall not be too obtrusive
For both of the valid paths ("Vocal Alert System" and "Belt with Motion Sensors"), these methods
shall not use visual outputs.
auditory and touch-based respectively
shall be made from common materials
speakers and haptic outputs respectively
shall not be overpriced, especially when compared to guide dogs
shall be designed to be as lightweight as possible
shall have simple clip-connections to allow for ease of equipment
shall be designed to
not make sitting or laying down in public spaces uncomfortable
minimize damage done and easily replaceable if broken
shall have an asymmetrical design to allow for simple equipment