How We Research
We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
Updated: 2026-09-23 · 7 min read · Independent comparison
Both products solve the same problem from opposite directions. One is a soft audio headband you can throw in the washing machine. The other is a dedicated blackout eye mask with speakers buried inside the padding. Neither is a noise-cancelling headphone in the active sense, but both are built to help you sleep through noise by masking it with your own audio.
• Perytong 2 biggest strength: Two headbands in the box, ultra-thin 40mm flat drivers that create no pressure points for side sleepers, and a removable-speaker design that lets you machine wash the fabric.
• Perytong 2 biggest trade-off: It's a headband, not a blackout mask. It covers your ears, not your eyes, so it won't block light in a bright room.
• ZHENYEMEI Modal biggest strength: A 3D contoured eye mask with 100% blackout coverage, spacious eye chambers that let you blink and keep lashes and makeup intact, and Modal fabric that wicks moisture.
• ZHENYEMEI Modal biggest trade-off: One mask per pack, and the eye cups are the cleaning solution rather than the whole mask going in a machine.
• Who Perytong 2 is for: Side sleepers, athletes, travelers and anyone who wants one piece of gear for sleep sounds, calls and workouts.
• Who ZHENYEMEI Modal is for: Light-sensitive sleepers, shift workers and side sleepers who mainly need darkness plus a quiet audio track.
Perytong 2 is a 2-pack Bluetooth headband built around one specific complaint: side sleepers who get jabbed in the ear by normal earbuds. The fix is a 40mm composite driver that sits completely flat inside the fabric. There's no protruding housing, so lying on your left side, your right side, or rolling around doesn't create a pressure point. If you've ever woken up with a sore ear from a bud, that design detail is the whole pitch.
The rest of the spec sheet is unusually generous for a sleep product. Bluetooth 5.4 with a 43-foot range means your phone can stay on the nightstand or across the room without the connection dropping. Battery life is rated at 14 hours on roughly a one-hour charge, and it charges over Type-C, so a short top-up covers a full night. You also get a built-in microphone and a touch panel on the side of the headband for play/pause, track skip, volume and calls — no fumbling for your phone in the dark.
Who should skip it? Anyone whose main problem is light, not sound. Perytong 2 doesn't shade your eyes. If you sleep in a room that isn't dark, or you work night shifts and sleep during the day, a headband alone won't fix that. It's also worth noting it's a two-pack, which is great for couples or for keeping one clean while the other is in the wash, but it's more product than a single sleeper strictly needs.
ZHENYEMEI Modal: Who It's For
ZHENYEMEI Modal attacks the problem from the other end. This is a sleep mask first and an audio device second. The headline feature is 100% blackout coverage combined with an ergonomic 3D contoured shape that carves out spacious chambers around your eyes. That means no pressure on your eyeballs or eyelashes, you can blink naturally, and it won't smudge makeup or rub your lashes while you sleep. For anyone who has ever pulled off a flat mask in the morning with creases around their eyes, that's a real upgrade.
The material is Modal fabric — smooth, breathable, moisture-wicking and lightweight, which matters if you run warm at night. Inside, there's memory foam and an adjustable fit that keeps the mask in place, which is the part side sleepers usually struggle with. A mask that shifts when you roll onto your side stops blocking light, and the adjustable fit plus foam is aimed squarely at that problem. The brand lists side sleepers, travelers, shift workers and light-sensitive sleepers as the target users.
Audio comes from built-in Bluetooth speakers, so you can play music, white noise, meditation tracks or audiobooks without putting anything inside your ears. It's the same masking approach as Perytong 2 — your audio covers the noise around you rather than electronics cancelling it — but here it's paired with genuine light blocking.
Cleaning is handled differently. Instead of washing the whole thing, the 3D eye cups detach, so you can clean the parts that touch your face and keep the mask fresh without losing its shape. It ships as a single mask in Gentleman Blue, packed at roughly 10.55 x 4.65 x 1.85 inches and about 9.14 ounces. The trade-off versus Perytong 2 is straightforward: you get darkness and eye comfort, but you don't get a second unit, a microphone, touch controls, or a stated battery and Bluetooth version to compare against.
• Best for blocking light → ZHENYEMEI Modal. 100% blackout with 3D eye chambers is the entire point of the design.
• Best for masking noise with audio → Both, but differently. Perytong 2 uses Bluetooth 5.4 with a 43-foot range; ZHENYEMEI uses built-in Bluetooth speakers inside the mask.
• Best for battery and charging flexibility → Perytong 2. It's the only one of the two with published figures: 14 hours of playtime and a one-hour Type-C charge.
• Best for side sleepers → Perytong 2 for ear comfort, ZHENYEMEI Modal for eye comfort. Flat 40mm drivers versus 3D contoured cups with memory foam.
• Best for workouts, running and calls → Perytong 2. Sweat-absorbent fabric, removable speakers, a microphone and touch controls.
• Best for shift workers and daytime sleepers → ZHENYEMEI Modal. Blackout coverage is what makes daytime sleep possible.
• Best for sharing or keeping one clean → Perytong 2. It's a 2-pack with washable headbands.
• Best for makeup wearers and lash-sensitive sleepers → ZHENYEMEI Modal. The zero-pressure chambers are designed around exactly that.
In my opinion, the deciding question isn't which is better — it's what's ruining your sleep. If light is the problem, I'd buy ZHENYEMEI Modal. Blackout coverage, zero eye pressure and a moisture-wicking Modal shell solve a problem Perytong 2 simply doesn't address, and the detachable eye cups make it practical to keep clean.
If your problem is noise, ear discomfort from earbuds, or you want one headband that covers sleep, workouts and calls, I'd buy Perytong 2. Two units, flat drivers, 14 hours of battery and a machine-washable build is a lot of flexibility for the money.
If you can only pick one and you sleep in a dark room already, Perytong 2 does more jobs. If your room isn't dark, ZHENYEMEI Modal is the one that actually changes your nights.
how to block out noise with headphones
Neither of these uses active noise cancellation. They block noise by putting soft material over or around your ears and playing your own audio — white noise, rain sounds, meditation tracks or audiobooks — loud enough to mask what's around you. That masking approach works well for steady sounds like traffic, snoring or a fan.
are there noise cancelling headphones for sleeping
Yes, but "noise cancelling" gets used loosely. Both Perytong 2 and ZHENYEMEI Modal are marketed for noise blocking, and both work by sealing your ears with fabric and layering in audio. Perytong 2 uses ultra-thin 40mm drivers inside a spandex headband; ZHENYEMEI Modal puts Bluetooth speakers inside a blackout eye mask.
is it safe to wear noise cancelling headphones while sleeping
The main risk with sleep audio is pressure on your ears, which is why both designs avoid in-ear buds. Perytong 2 uses completely flat drivers so side sleeping creates no pressure points, and ZHENYEMEI Modal's 3D cups keep pressure off your eyes and lashes. Follow the manufacturer's guidance and keep volume low.
what are the best noise cancelling sleep headphones
In my opinion it comes down to your main complaint. For darkness plus audio, ZHENYEMEI Modal is the stronger pick thanks to 100% blackout and zero eye pressure. For washability, battery life and all-day use, Perytong 2 wins with 14 hours of playtime, a 2-pack and removable speakers you can machine wash.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.
See also: Perytong Sleep Headphones vs esonstyle Cat Ear Headphones, GEEKRIA Sleep Earplugs vs SIXTHGU 40dB: Noise Isolating, COMPLY 100 vs FHHDRMG Ear Plugs: Noise Isolating Sleep