We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
Updated: 2026-09-23 · 6 min read · Independent comparison
If you want an officially licensed, plug-and-play Xbox One headset with simple inline controls, choose PDP Xbox One Afterglow; if you need a durable aluminum build, detachable mic, and virtual 3D spatial audio across multiple platforms, choose HyperX.
• PDP Afterglow LVL 3 — biggest strength: Officially licensed by Microsoft for Xbox One, with 40mm drivers that PDP says are 50 percent larger than those in standard chat headsets, plus a flexible noise-cancelling mic.
• PDP Afterglow LVL 3 — biggest trade-off: Wired only, needs the 3.5mm port on a 2nd-generation Xbox One controller (an adapter is required for 1st-gen controllers, sold separately), and it's built from plastic and faux leather rather than metal.
• HyperX Cloud Core — biggest strength: Durable aluminum frame, memory foam comfort, DTS Headphone:X spatial audio activation, and a detachable, Discord- and TeamSpeak-certified noise-cancelling mic.
• HyperX Cloud Core — biggest trade-off: The USB audio control box only works with PC and PS4, so Xbox players connect via the 3.5mm cable and lose that control box functionality. It also weighs noticeably more.
• Who each is for: PDP Afterglow is for the Xbox One player who wants a straightforward, officially licensed stereo headset at an entry-level point. HyperX Cloud Core is for someone who games across PC, Xbox, Switch, and mobile and wants one more durable headset to cover all of them.
The Afterglow LVL 3 is a stereo headset built specifically around Xbox One. PDP designed it as a clear step up from the mono chat headset that ships with the console — you get full stereo sound instead of chat-only audio. The 40mm dynamic drivers cover a 20 Hz to 20,000 Hz range, and PDP claims they're 50 percent larger than the drivers in typical chat headsets, which is the main reason this thing can push real bass and detail rather than tinny voice audio.
For controls, everything lives inline: a push-button volume control and a mic mute sit right on the cable, so you're not diving into Xbox menus mid-match. The mic itself is noise-cancelling with a flexible arm, which matters if you play in a room with a fan, a TV, or other people talking. PDP also gave it breathable leatherette ear cushions and a lay-flat design for storage. It's officially licensed by Microsoft, so you know it's meant to work with the console out of the box.
Who should buy it: the Xbox One owner who wants one headset, one cable, no setup, and doesn't care about PC or cross-platform use. Who should skip it: anyone on a 1st-generation Xbox One controller without the 3.5mm port, since you'd need a separate headset adapter. Also skip it if you want metal construction or a detachable mic — this is a plastic-and-faux-leather design, and that's the honest trade-off at this tier.
The HyperX Cloud Core is a different class of headset. It's built around a sturdy aluminum frame, which HyperX positions as the reason it can handle daily wear and tear better than an all-plastic build. The ear cups use HyperX memory foam, and the whole thing is over-ear with a closed ear-cup shape. The frequency range runs 15 Hz to 25 kHz with 16-ohm impedance and 98 dB sensitivity — a wider low-end extension than the PDP on paper, and low impedance means it's easy to drive from a controller or phone.
The headline feature is DTS Headphone:X. HyperX includes an activation code for two years of this spatial audio tech, which simulates surround positioning for better awareness of where footsteps and gunfire are coming from. The mic is detachable, flexible, and noise-cancelling, and HyperX notes it's Discord- and TeamSpeak-certified — a meaningful detail if you chat on PC. There's also a USB audio control box for mic volume, headset volume, and mute, though that box only works on PC and PS4.
On Xbox, you connect through the standard 3.5mm jack, which also covers Nintendo Switch, mobile, and VR systems that accept a 3.5mm connection. The trade-off is real: on Xbox you don't get the control box, and DTS Headphone:X is supported on PC and Xbox (Series X|S and One), so console spatial audio depends on that compatibility. The Cloud Core also weighs 14.4 ounces versus the PDP's 100 grams — that's a big difference, and it's the price of the aluminum and memory foam.
Side-by-Side: Which Should You Choose?
• Best for Xbox One simplicity → PDP Xbox One Afterglow. It's officially licensed by Microsoft, wired, and ready with no activation codes or setup.
• Best for durability → HyperX Cloud Core. The aluminum frame is designed to survive daily use far better than a plastic build.
• Best for cross-platform use → HyperX Cloud Core. PC, Xbox, Switch, mobile, and VR via 3.5mm, plus a USB control box for PC and PS4.
• Best for spatial audio → HyperX Cloud Core. DTS Headphone:X with a two-year activation code is the standout feature here.
• Best for a lightweight fit → PDP Xbox One Afterglow. At 100 grams it's dramatically lighter than the 14.4-ounce HyperX, which matters over long sessions.
• Best for chat flexibility → HyperX Cloud Core. The detachable, Discord- and TeamSpeak-certified mic is more versatile than a fixed boom.
• Best for plug-and-forget console gaming → PDP Xbox One Afterglow. Inline volume and mute, no extra box, no code.
• Best for long-session comfort materials → HyperX Cloud Core. Memory foam ear cups are a step up from standard leatherette.
My Verdict
In my opinion, the HyperX Cloud Core is the better buy for most people in 2026, simply because it does more. The aluminum frame, memory foam, detachable certified mic, and DTS Headphone:X activation give you a headset that works across PC, Xbox, and Switch instead of locking you to one console. If you're strictly an Xbox One player who wants the lightest, simplest, officially licensed option and nothing else, I'd still point you to the PDP Afterglow LVL 3 — but for anyone who plays on more than one platform, HyperX wins. Check the current price on Amazon before deciding, since that's the one thing that can flip the call.
On specs and versatility, yes — aluminum build, detachable mic, wider frequency range, and DTS spatial audio. The PDP wins on weight and Xbox-specific simplicity. It depends on whether you need multi-platform support.
Yes, via the standard 3.5mm cable. Note that the USB audio control box only works on PC and PS4, and DTS Headphone:X is supported on PC and Xbox Series X|S and Xbox One.
Only if you have a 1st-generation Xbox One wireless controller. It's designed for the 2nd-gen controller with a 3.5mm port. Older controllers need a headset adapter, which is sold separately.
The PDP is far lighter at 100 grams with breathable leatherette, so it feels less heavy over time. The HyperX uses memory foam but weighs 14.4 ounces. For pure lightness, PDP; for plush materials, HyperX.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.
See also: Herloreen Headset vs ONE LIFE Headset: Business Bluetooth, Shokz OpenDots ONE Open-Ear vs Vivezin OWS-G206, HyperX Cloud III vs iKF R2